I suppose the audience for this is quite niche, but I'm going to go ahead and summarize a very early hard SF story namely Kepler's Somnium (Dream).
Background Johannes Kepler (1571 – 1630) was a German Renaissance astronomer, astrologer, and mathematician. 1/
He is wrote the Epitome astronomiae Copernicanae in which he formulated heliocentrism (based on Copernicus, but with elliptic trajectories). Now, heliocentrism was a total game changer because it opened the possbility to a plurality of worlds 2/
To get a sense of how radical and shocking, one reason heliocentrism faced such difficulty is that we would expect a parallax among the fixed stars. Since we don't that must mean the cosmos is truly enormous, and the stars very far away. Copernicus' reply: it is simply so. 3/
So folks had to swallow an enormous universe, which opened up (even before people conceived of galaxies and such) a plurality of worlds. Think of e.g., Giordano Bruno's De l'infinito universo et mondi, an infinite universe filled with worlds. 4/
So, the dream (Somnium) was written around 1611, and Kepler's aim was to show what astronomy would look like as seen from another planet. This is a kind of long thought experiment to play with the idea of non-geocentrism 5/
It starts out with a narrator who "attentively contemplated the Moon and the stars I peacefully settled on my couch and fell into a rather deep sleep. In my sleep I seemed to have picked up a book, from the bookshelf to read it through." - he reads the book ... 6/
Then we get introduced to Duracotus and his mother Fiolxhilde, they are both Icelanders. The mother is a witch, making herbal remedies for the captains of nearby ships that she places in small sacks made of goat skin 7/
Son and mother get into a heated argument because he cut open one of the sacks out of curiosity, and all the contents spilled out. She puts him on a ship, bound England and Norway 8/
Captain goes to Denmark because he had some letters of Tycho Brahe, who lived on the island of Hven. Now we get a cameo surprise appearance of Tycho (!!) Boy goes ashore and delivers the letters to Tycho, who is pleased and asks him many questions (in Danish) 9/
Now...difficult to suspend belief but Duracotus (14 years old at the time) learns Danish and astronomy in a matter of weeks from Tycho. And he decides to stay on Hven: "These activities reminded me of my mother – in fact she had a constant habit of talking to the moon." awww 10/
After several years of learning astronomy "the most divine of sciences" Duracotus returns to his mom who is sorry to have sent him away on a ship in a fit of anger. They compare notes on astronomy (she also knows a lot). They reconcile 11/
Fiolxhilde then initiates her son in the occult art of summoning spirits (called "daemons") so he can converse with them and learn new astronomical facts. They do some wonderful witchcraft and summoning together (hmm this is SF and fantasy crossover) 12/
This is when he learns about Levania, located 50,000 German miles above the Earth "The journey to and from this island from our Earth is very seldom open; but when it is accessible, its easy for our people" - but for humans it is very dangerous 13/
Apparently, you cannot be fat, or sedentary. Best suited are "dried up old women", them, and Spaniards, for this arduous journey which takes 4 hours and described in lovely SF detail 14/
He describes in detail how "Just as geographers divide the Earth's globe into five zones due to celestial phenomena, so Levania consists of two hemispheres, the one of the Subvolvans, and the other of the Privolvans." - how the sun appears from Levania, the seasons etc 15/
Lots and lots of astronomical detail e.g., "a 19 star-year cycle or in 235 days, summer occurs 20 times and winter just as often towards the poles, and at the equator 40 times. Just as we have our months they have 6 days in all during the summer, the rest belong to winter" 16/
Some stuff on eclipses too "Because they have long days and nights, they experience most frequent eclipses of both heavenly bodies." - so all this detail is meant to show that you can do astronomy not just from Earth but that an alien species could also do astronomy 17/
that opens up the dazzling possibility of aliens doing astronomy all across different parts of the universe. Kepler hereby shows that by pushing the Earth from its center, the Earth loses its central position and becomes just a planet. Once you do that, the world becomes vast 18/
Oh and it ends with "this was all a dream" (oldest trope ever, but I assume not when Kepler was writing
"I came back to my senses, found that my head was on a cushion and my body wrapped up in a blanket." 19/
You can read an entire translation of this story here frostydrew.org/papers.dc/pape…
I am tagging @ericlinuskaplan @eschwitz @CChrisrose -- who might be interested!

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Helen De Cruz

Helen De Cruz Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Helenreflects

7 May
Reading Scruton on environmental philosophy. It's a clearly, lucidly written book, a lot of Heidegger though and I just don't think nationalism and environmental conservation are going to work, ultimately.
OMG this book is so anti-EU. (!!) I still find it super-useful to see this articulated though, so I appreciate the book. I would answer to Scruton that well nation states got a big push (funds, people giving their lives), of course they're doing well.
Also, not all is well. We are confronted with global stuff (pandemic, and climate change, hello) and nation states are simply not up to the job. And the failings of nation states are weirdly incapsulated in the resurgent nationalism cf this excellent piece theguardian.com/news/2018/apr/…
Read 4 tweets
17 Apr
Watching the Penn&Teller masterclass on magic, here are their philosophical views on the practice.
Though the word has supernatural P&T overtones, they are thorough naturalists. "No-one leaves the theater believing something that we ourselves do not think is true on purpose." 1/
Penn: "illusion" = visual effect to accomplish a trick, e.g., mirror to make something appear different. Smart thing = the tricks.--tricks "involve intellectual engagements on the part of the audience" and involves "exploring epistemology" (how do we know what is true?" 2/
"[magic] is the heaviest philosophical ideas you can possibly have, dealt with in the silliest way"--it is playground for serious epistemological topics such as what to believe and what not (so Teller), you can play because there are no (dire) consequences. 3/
Read 6 tweets
17 Apr
Some recent Uber drives and conversations (so long ago I was in an Uber!) about the vaccines make me think about misinformation and how important epistemic rights are. Many of these drivers had deeply mistaken, distorted beliefs about the vaccines and were hesitant to get them 1/
In this paper Lani Watson characterizes epistemic rights as a subset of human rights, more specifically "right to information, the right to know, the right to true and justified beliefs, the right to understand, and the right to truth" 2/

tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.108…
The Uber drivers I spoke to had distorted, mistaken beliefs about vaccines namely: that they would not be efficacious, that they weren't tested rigorously, that it was some scheme by Bill Gates, that they were unnecessary for them etc. All these beliefs are circulating 3/
Read 10 tweets
11 Apr
@CT_Bergstrom Pfff the philosophical community has discussed this amply. If only he read some philosophy then at least he would be read up on it. This is an excellent paper on the topic
bostonreview.net/race-philosoph…
@CT_Bergstrom Since I think few people will click through, let me just highlight a few important passages of this piece. The authors,
@RDembroff
and Dee Payton, argue that there is an asymmetry between being transgender and being transracial 1/
@CT_Bergstrom @RDembroff They write "... it is a mistake to base this asymmetry on notions about who “really is” a woman or who “really is” Black. The social world is a dynamic and ever-changing place...."2/
Read 10 tweets
11 Apr
Reading Heidi (Spyri) to my son. I loved the book as a kid and the descriptions of the mountains are still magical. But now... I'm just not sure if I love the book quite so much. There are two problems. First, there is Alm-uncle (grandfather). Basically a bunch of bigots 1/
Who rejected him and cast him out because he came as a single father with a small child back from Naples to the small village in Switzerland. Oooh he's a single dad. He must've done something wrong. And he was shunned. And now he's supposed to make amends with the community 2/
Second major problem: there are strong disabled characters (the grandma of Peter and the girl Clara) - this is good. But their disability is portrayed as something that voids their life almost from all meaning, super-negative. We see this through Heidi's eyes in parts, still 3/
Read 4 tweets
11 Apr
OMG I am having an absolute blast listening to Chris Voss, former hostage negotiator, talk about how to negotiate. I have no idea if these techniques work but my God it is so entertaining. My next negotiation (and we negotiate so frequently), I am going all in!
For posterity, I'm going to put some tips by this hostage negotiator in a thread.
Tip #1: Negotiation is about building trust and establishing a relationship. It is counterproductive to go in with a bottom line. Much better to establish relationship & see what can be achieved 2/
(side note: I find it so interesting to have a hostage negotiator of all people advocate for non-zero sum negotiation tactics. This makes me think that zero-sum or not really is an attitude, not so much driven by circumstance as we think) 3/
Read 24 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(