There's two wildly differing responses among those who've known, either personally or through their family histories, suffering, injustice and deep deep pain.
Group 1 empathise with all those who suffer similarly. They seek understanding, they act with compassion, they CARE.
Group 2, for some awful reason which is clearly also part of the human condition, go on to inflict similar pain on others, and rejoice in doing so.
That's often even true of CEOs or office bullies, let alone what goes on in Palestine.
See also: those born poor who end up rich, then spend the rest of their lives voting for the right and to kick even more shit in the faces of those they've left behind.
So much of Israel's behaviour is based on fear. Fear, above all, of *it happening again*.
And I can empathise with fear. Can't all of us?
But fear will never, ever be an excuse. It's up to us - all of us - to confront our fears, face them down, and never allow our own trauma to be inflicted on others.
Fear, pain, suffering, trauma actually drives many of the best people in this world on to do amazing things for the benefit of everyone.
They're the people I admire. They're the people I exalt and look up to. Above all, because they are BRAVE.
I sympathise, hugely, with those whose fears and trauma are so deep-rooted that they feel paralysed and helpless. It's up to everyone to help people like that; to give them the tools so they can change their lives for the better.
But I will never sympathise with those whose use their fears for ill. To persecute others, intimidate others, bully others and kill others.
Nobody on the left should ever support that. Ever. And you're not of the left if you do.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
At Mauthausen, from where my grandmother, great-grandmother and two great-aunts were finally liberated in 1945, Jews were thrown down this notorious staircase to their deaths by Nazis - who thought what they were doing was hilarious.
These were known as the 'Stairs of Death'.
In Papa, Hungary, before my grandmother and her family were taken first to the ghetto, then sent to Auschwitz, they were giving shelter to 2 young children: sent there by cousins in Slovakia who hoped, prayed, they might be safe in Hungary.
One day, they had a knock on the door.
The two children were taken away by the police. And outside, people - my grandmother's own neighbours - cheered and celebrated. The children were never seen again.
"In order to have real adjustment within our personalities, we all want the well‐adjusted life in order to avoid neurosis, or schizophrenic personalities.
But I say to you, my friends, as I move to my conclusion...
... There are certain things in our nation and in the world, (to) which I am proud to be maladjusted, and (to) which I hope all men of goodwill will be maladjusted…
I’m about convinced now that there is need for a new organization in our world.
The International Association for the Advancement of Creative Maladjustment – men and women who will be as maladjusted as the prophet Amos…
As maladjusted as Abraham Lincoln who had the vision to see that this nation would not survive half-slave and half-free…
What do the following electorally successful leaders - left, centre, right - have in common?
- Biden
- Obama
- Ardern
- Sturgeon
- Reagan
- Clinton
- Johnson
- Blair
The answer lies in how they communicate(d) their message: selling a vision by telling a story.
Storytelling is absolutely integral to my methodology as an English teacher. I think we all communicate through stories in many ways - and my aim with students is to get them to build their own stories via videos, images and their own imagination, creativity & critical thinking.
Notice how all eight of the individuals I've listed above define(d) themselves much more by what they were *for* than what they were against. Notice, too, how few - if any - of them ever got that angry at their opponents.
Below, a Newsnight discussion which some of you may remember. I'm posting it because in my view, nothing better encapsulates the cultural divide in Britain - nor why the Tories know they're onto something re: 'the war on woke'.
Starkey is both offensive and terrifyingly prescient. He basically predicts the crumbling of the Red Wall AND Boris Johnson's British exceptionalism.
What did we on the left do? Quite naturally, quite understandably, label him as 'privileged' and pigeonhole him as 'racist'.
There is no way of bridging that divide. These are two colossally different world views on show.
And it's just plain stupid for Labour to even try. We'll never be able to out-Tory the Tories; nor should we even want to.
Thinking about Boris Johnson's success - and like it or not, as a politician (but certainly not as a Prime Minister), he's a quite massive success - prompts me to write something about human nature.
You see: we all *assume* that we want honest, trustworthy, dignified leaders.
Just as we all *assume* that we want honest, trustworthy, socially responsible corporate CEOs.
But we don't get them. And something about human nature indulges this for some reason. Especially when it comes to politics.
John Major, Gordon Brown, Ed Miliband and Jeremy Corbyn are all profoundly decent, honest people. All four got walloped at the ballot box.
Tony Blair, David Cameron and Boris Johnson are anything but honest. All three succeeded at the ballot box.