Folks, it's time. I'm watching it. A little solo Disasterologists At The Movies.

#DATM #EMGTwitter
Whew. A pretty graphic opening wildfire scene, an explosion, and the classic 'family having breakfast together' to reel us in...
I didn't quite think through how difficult this will be to live-tweet without spoilers... I'll keep things very vague since probably none of you have seen this yet. 😬
Unsurprisingly there are SOME gender dynamics occurring in this movie.

(Make an explicitly feminist, start to finish, disaster movie, you cowards.)
This movie is just crimes and flashbacks to people dying in a wildfire. To be fair, that is exactly what the trailer suggested.

Relatedly, I do not care for Nicholas Hoult!
This movie attempts to address mental health issues among smoke jumpers but it doesn't do more than raise the issue (so far) of PTSD which seems like a real lost opportunity. The message is basically "if you fail your psych eval you get banished" which is... 🙃
My biggest take away for everyone in reference to this movie is that you should not intentionally set wildfires.

This just reminded me of my favorite wildfire article ever written: slate.com/human-interest…
One of my favorite things in disaster films is seeing what they do to isolate characters from help. This time it was lightning knocking out the radio.
Oh, man. Medina Senghore and Angelina Jolie are too good for this script!!!!

Just desperate for films that tell new, good disaster stories. Greenland was fine for what it was but surely we can do better in this moment of constant crisis.
Could have done without the copaganda in this. I would have stopped watching tbh if I hadn’t already committed to tweeting about it.

(Do keep in mind that I hate almost all disaster movies.)
This film is at its best when the women are committing murder!
I’m going to leave the fire analysis to the fire folks.

Classic ending with all the formal responders showing up. No mention of recovery (though didn't seem to be much if any damage, so.) Really an emergency, not a disaster.
(That's not a spoiler because these movies are so formulaic.)

In the past year, I've watched about 170 disaster movies for research @thisisjohnfest & I are doing.

We were also on @disaster_pod talking about all of this if you’d like to hear more.
I will say this movie is on the fence for me in terms of whether it’s a disaster movie or not. One of the ways I assess this is if you took the hazard out of the movie would the plot be the same. If you took the wildfire out of this movie the plot would be largely unaffected. So.
I just... write better disaster movies? It's weird to me that this seems so difficult? Presumably they just make these movies for a very specific kind of person who is not me. That's fine. I just think Hollywood should do better (which, sure).

BYE. Have a good night!

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Dr. Samantha Montano

Dr. Samantha Montano Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @SamLMontano

12 May
*stares in the entire body of emergency management research* Image
This all was of course best summarized by Dr. Tierney on #COVIDCalls many many months ago. Image
Read 5 tweets
18 Feb
Hi.

COULD SOMEONE PLEASE GIVE US MONEY TO STUDY HOW CLIMATE CHANGE WILL IMPACT THE EMERGENCY MANAGEMENT SYSTEM?

We don't even need that much money to do this!
ok. I know I'm screaming but I'm actually 100% serious.

@BillGates -- I hear you're into climate adaptation now. Great! Give us money!!
There is so little money being spent on disaster research and there's even less being spent specifically on *emergency management*.

I'm just completely out of ways of trying to explain why this is urgent research! Look around!!
Read 12 tweets
17 Feb
Among the many horrific things Rush Limbaugh did and said he was also a persistent disaster denialist.

It's a long list but in the past few years, he actively encouraged people not to follow hurricane evacuation orders (while evacuating himself). buzzfeednews.com/article/davidm…
He persistently lied about climate change and their relationship to disasters.

nytimes.com/2020/09/15/bus…
The Trump administration oversaw two failed catastrophic responses of which the death tolls are still being counted.

“Can you remember any natural disaster where the Trump administration is thought to have really blown it”

mediamatters.org/coronavirus-co…
Read 4 tweets
17 Feb
This is another disaster where the needs are so geographically widespread that my best advice on giving is to just pick a person/group/ organization and give them money.
My personal approach in a situation like this is to do the following:
1. Help anyone I know personally who needs help
2. Donate to any groups I've worked with before/ know they're effective
3. Local groups that serve marginalized people that haven't gotten many donations
I do usually recommend donating to groups that work on recovery rather than response. I actually feel differently in this situation specifically because of the pandemic. So this isn't a factor I'm considering right now.
Read 4 tweets
17 Feb
They're also not connecting this to broader issues with our approach to emergency management.

If you're new around here (hi, welcome) and here's a thread on how democrats (including Biden) love to ignore emergency management.
I often get comments about how my criticism of various democrats re: disasters is unfair because "at least they aren't Trump". 😅

Sure, democrats are not chucking paper towels at people but they also are not doing an effective job of meeting disaster-related needs.
What is happening right now is, unfortunately, a perfect example of why elected officials (national and local) need to explain the causes of disasters AND what they are going to do to prevent them in the future.
Read 12 tweets
17 Feb
A common genre of disaster tweet is someone making a snarky comment that blames disaster survivors for the disaster because of their state’s political affiliation.

A short thread.
This is a problem for several reasons but the big one is that generally the same communities that tend to be most impacted by disasters are the same ones that are most likely to be kept from voting.
I wrote about this a few months ago right before the election.

disasterology.substack.com/p/disasterolog… Image
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(