Facebook is still providing traffickers with a direct line to financiers of looting activities.

Here, a looter in Egypt posts a video of the pharaonic reliefs he has access to, he just needs funding to help finish the site

A recent case shows how a funding scheme works-THREAD
On June 30, Egypt announced the detention of a gang of 19 people, including a wealthy businessman and a former MP, for a vast scheme that involved both looting and trafficking antiquities

english.ahram.org.eg/NewsContent/1/…
Businessman Hassan Rateb was not doing the illegal excavating of course, but it was an activity he spent millions to help finance.

youm7.com/story/2021/7/1…
Looting of archaeological sites at a large scale can be an expensive endeavor.

This is particularly the case Egypt where looters will often drill through stone or dive into tombs filled with ground water. Both require expensive heavy equipment that the lay person cannot afford.
But for many the investment is worth the risk, particularly when valuable artifacts can be found and laundered into the market to feed a western appetite for antiquities— like the 114 trafficked Egyptian artifacts seized in France last month egypttoday.com/Article/1/1053…
According to prosecutors in the recent case of the 19-person looting gang, businessman Hassan Ratib didn't just finance the illicit excavations.

He used his international connections to facilitate the smuggling to artifacts abroad. almasryalyoum.com/news/details/2…
And Ratib was engaged in more than just financing looting and smuggling antiquities - he was using the scheme for money laundering too

"The evidence also established the accusations of smuggling, destruction, and money laundering." dailynewsegypt.com/2021/06/30/egy…
It's also important to remember that a former member of parliament was leading this antiquities gang.

Alaa Hassanein was a MP from the Mubarak-era.

His extracurricular interests are eccentric to say the least... albawaba.com/news/egyptian-…
Former MP Hassanein has previously been billed as the "deputy of jinns and demons" for his "ability" to speak to spirits.

Some of Hassanein's magical spirit books that he used for the looting at sites were seized by authorities.

m.akhbarelyom.com/news/newdetail…
While it seems silly, the use of magical incantations to speak to jinns and open tombs is a common piece of looting folklore

Facebook is often used by believers of this folklore to seek out sheikhs who can cleanse potential tombs of jinn In exchange for a cut of the antiquities
Massive Facebook pages that are dedicated to teaching users how to loot antiquities are pushing the need to pay sheikhs for this "service" and sharing photos and videos with alleged jinn guarding tomb treasures.

This looting FB page has over 2 million followers.
The Egyptian gov. has sent a strong message by arresting a businessman and former MP for antiquities trafficking and illegal excavation

But even these strong efforts will make little difference when Facebook continues to facilitate the same activities on its 2.85bn-user platform

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with ATHAR Project

ATHAR Project Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ATHARProject

14 Dec 20
THREAD: How Facebook's facilitation of antiquities trafficking can feed conflicts.

Here, a user in Yemen posts a Quran for sale in a Facebook group for manuscript and antiquities trafficking.

The group was created last month despite FB's June policy banning such activity.
The user's Facebook page lists his location in Sana'a, Yemen.

Sana'a's old city is a @UNESCO World Heritage site that has played an important role in both Arab and Islamic history. whc.unesco.org/en/list/385/

In recent years, the area has been devastated by conflict.
A deeper look at this user's Facebook profile shows that he "likes" (and follows) multiple pages for the sale of weapons.

Much of Sana'a has been captured by Houthi forces, who are mired in a conflict against Sunni tribes and their allies including Saudi Arabia.
Read 10 tweets
6 Dec 20
THREAD: This group created last month for trafficking Jewish artifacts and manuscripts is still growing

Material from users in conflict zones is still pervasive and generating interest

This user listed in Benghazi, Libya posted a series of Jewish books and manuscripts for sale
Whether these manuscripts are real or fake, they can still fund illicit networks. In some cases, like the forged Dead Sea Scrolls at the Bible museum, real ancient & looted material can be used to make forgeries.

The September date in the user's photos suggests they are not new.
Regardless of the authenticity, the items generate significant interest among other users in the group

Over a dozen users reply to inquire if the materials are available in Marrakech, Tunisia, Algeria, or Libya

The group admin replies to inquiries to confirm items are in Libya
Read 5 tweets
30 Nov 20
THREAD: Facebook relies on the public, researchers, & journalists to moderate their platform. But even blatantly violating content does not get removed.

On Sat. we reported weapons for sale in an antiquities trafficking group—it went as expected.

Facebook, this is unacceptable.
On Saturday, November 28, ATHAR found and reported an advertisement post in a Facebook antiquities trafficking group that was offering weapons for sale to anyone in Egypt.

The user, listed in Cairo, was offering delivery to any governorate.
Facebook's Community Standards explicitly ban content that "Attempts to buy, sell, trade, donate, gift or solicit firearms...between private individuals, unless posted by a real brick and mortar store, legitimate website, brand or government agency"

facebook.com/communitystand…
Read 15 tweets
28 Nov 20
THREAD UPDATE 2: Three days ago we highlighted how this Facebook group created on Nov 6 for trafficking books and artifacts had doubled.

It gained another 500+ members in that 3 days, and more illicit material is being offered for sale from across MENA, including in conflict. Image
New material is offered in this antiquities trafficking Facebook group every hour.

Just three hours ago a user, who does not have a listed location, offered a handwritten Quran for sale.

Within minutes group members inquired about the price.

This is the Facebook black market. Image
On Nov. 27 a user listed in Basra, Iraq offered 16 artifacts for sale in the Facebook trafficking group created on Nov. 6.

While most of the material is likely fake, *it still monetizes illicit networks,* and pieces like the gold coins can be sold for their material value. ImageImageImageImage
Read 6 tweets
25 Nov 20
THREAD UPDATE: Just one week ago we posted this new Facebook group created for trafficking Jewish manuscripts and artifacts

7 days later, the membership has more than doubled from 727 members to roughly 1,600 members

That's a rate of over 120 new members per day since last week
This Facebook trafficking group's rapid growth means that members are offering trafficked pieces for sale more frequently.

Just 4 hours ago a user with an unlisted location offered a torah scroll for sale.

Reminder: Facebook banned the sale of historical artifacts in June.
Material is still being offered from countries in conflict in the Facebook group for trafficking Jewish manuscripts and artifacts.

Just 5 hours ago, a user in Tripoli, Libya offered a historic Hebrew book for sale. He claims that it is 170 years old.
Read 5 tweets
18 Nov 20
THREAD: Today Zuck faced a lot of questions about FB hate speech. But the platform is also hosting criminal activity.

In the case of antiquities war crime, Facebook is actually *facilitating* it.

We'll show how once trafficker in Libya is using FB to maximize potential buyers Image
A user who lists his location as Darnah, Libya is a prime example of how Facebook has rapidly accelerated transnational trafficking in conflict zones.

This Libya-based user recently posted Libyan antiquities for sale across multiple Facebook groups for antiquities trafficking ImageImage
The user's authored his first post on October 24 in a Facebook antiquities trafficking group with roughly 13,000 members.

His post included no text, only a photo of a statue.

This is often a signal to other users that the pictured item is for sale. (see atharproject.org/report2019/) Image
Read 12 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(