MASTER Thread on current PROBLEMS in GST ( law, procedure & Returns)

GST can be Good & Simple if Following problems r resolved . I am aware that There is no discussion, No representation, No hope abt these Problems getting solved

But Still I am making list

READ ALL 25 points
1. ITC restrictions in 36(4) and 16(2)(aa)
2. ITC Denial of utilizing u/r 86B
3. ITC reversal due to 180 days Non-payment
4. No ITC allowed for CG in Export refund
5. No ITC allowed for CG & Services in Inverted duty refund
6. Whole return filling Mechanism
7. Non Effective GST Annual Return format
8. No CAP on Max. LATE FEES
9. No Amnesty for GSTR 9/9C
10. No relaxation on Sec. 16(4) regarding time limit
11. No Discussion on Petrol / Diesel inclusion in GST
12. No Discussion on Rate Neutralization
13. Not reducing High penalizing Interest rate 18/24%
14. No Negative liability allowed in 3B
15. Not Changing QRMP to QRQP
16. No revocations of Cancelled dealers.
17. Significant delay in approving Registration
18. No online Appeals - No tribunals
19. No involvement of Professional Bodies or Industry Association in GST council decision making
20. Daily changes by Notifications, Circulars & PR
21. Wide power to officers under 21A & 86A for cancellations + suspension
22. Useless forms like GSTR 10 & ITC 4
23. Harassment to categorizing exporters into Risky exporters & not giving refunds
24. Harassment due to Minor errors in Eway Bill lead to major penalties
25. Obsession with HSN DETAILS . Cumbersome for MSME

Portal Issues I have already covered 20 points in other posts so Not covering here.
you may see that at


You may add burning issues in GST law & policies in comments below

end of thread

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with CA Harshil sheth

CA Harshil sheth Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @CA_HarshilSHETH

1 Jul
4 years of GST - THREAD ON UNANSWERED QUESTIONS

This thread is different than anything else

Here are list of some Unanswered Questions. Its about those "WHY" which You must have encountered these questions in these 4 years.

like CGST of one state not available to Other
Do read all. Add more in Comments .

Here it goes

1. Why Credit of CGST of other state not available in state in which Taxpayer is registered ?? Why? There is only one CGST act. Right? Have you ever thought?
2. In refund in Export. Why ITC of CG not allowed whereas ITC of Input services allowed? This curtail refund Amt. Also If I m doing export with IGST then Full IGST is allowed as Refund. Why such discrimination in both scheme ? If purpose is to give full refund to Exporters
Read 11 tweets
30 Jun
GST REGISTRATION related Questions - A thread

WHETHER PERSON is LIABLE to REGISTER in EACH CASE ?
(SECTION 22 to 25 & DEFINITION OF AGGREGATE Turnover will be helpful )

Here are Incomes of some persons from his Profit loss accounts
1. A trader having 38 lakh turnover ( Taxable Goods) + 1 lakh Rent from residential house +1 lakh Interest from FD and saving bank account

2 An advocate earning 19 lakh from consultancy on which recipient is paying tax on RCM basis + 2 lac rent from Commercial Property
3. An advocate earning 19 lakh from consultancy + 2 lakh income from interest of FD / SB a/c

4. A doctor having income of Rs 19 lakh from his consultancy + 2 Lac income of commission from suggesting medicine of a particular company
Read 6 tweets
11 Jun
THREAD on GST portal issues

Inspired from @ca_shridhar post
I Have added few points & made this list

Its not about Portal glitches or Its Getting down/slow its capacity issue or anything abt Law. We made list here list how GST Portal inefficient to give full fledged experience
1. Negative figure in GSTR 3B-
Law is clear but Portal is still not ready for same. Negative Figure in 3B is necessary . Definitely not provided because technical team is not ready.
2. Headache of Jumping to screens while searching in B2B -
While searching particular Invoice in B2B in GSTR 1 Screen , U can Always view only 5 invoice in one screen in B2B in GSTR 1
Imagine u hv 450 invoice of diff GSTIN then there will be 90 times jumping
Read 15 tweets
27 Apr
Thread on closing FY 20-21

I knw its turbulent times.. Working from Home.. Limited sources .. Doing Compliance for Clients who are also not able to cope up in difficult times
And no Extention of dates

Here is CHECKLIST for GST & IT

#GST
#IT
Prepare list of clients in each following category and make 100% sure that U have done following compliance for each month
👉GST
Check in All Monthly /Quarterly Clients

✅ GSTR1 filed upto MARCH 2021
✅GSTR 3B filed upto MARCH 2021
✅GSTR 9/9C filed upto FY 19-20 ( if applicable)

👉GST
Check in Composition clients
✅ CMP 8 filed upto Q4
✅ GSTR 4 Filed Upto FY 20-21
Read 9 tweets
3 Apr
Thread on TCS FOR FY 20-21 END AND TCS FOR FY 21-22 START- VERY IMPORTANT

tweet 1

>>>>Action required for TCS on Sale of Goods for Financial Year 2020-21

>Note- TCS was made applicable to those whose FY 19-20 Turnover was Crossing 10 cr
tweet 2

a. In case, you are liable to collect TCS after 01-10-2020 for sales of goods, then for march month ,ensure to pay TCS by 7th April 2021 for Q4. (not 30th april)
The due date for TCS return is 15-5-2021 ( not 31st may)
tweet 3

b. Also check your books of Accounts , From 1-10-2020, If you have not collected or short collected from the customer then You need to Reconcile with books and Pay the difference before 7th April 2021 and File TCS return before 15-5-2021.. Rate was 0.075% till March.
Read 6 tweets
12 Mar
Thread -
1
Future of GST Professionals practise
is
RECONCILIATION

On OUTWARD side-

You will be making Reco of following source of Figures

Books Figures
3B Figures
GSTR 1 Figures
E invoice Figures
GSTR 9 figures
26AS Figures
2
On ITC side-

U all know that
Reco needed in

Books Figures
3B Figures
GSTR 2B Figures
GSTR 2A Figures
GSTR 9 table 6
GSTR 9 table 8A

And some Ppl prefer to make their own version of Excel Summary for Annual data
So Reco with that Also
---
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(