Thread by @amerhadiazmi

Sempoerna memulakan pagi pertama di #DewanRakyat dengan mempersoalkan ordinan darurat!

Bukit Gelugor sambung.

“The rule which regulates the house cannot supersede the Constitution”

He asked Art Harun: “Are you a government lapdog? Are you a government lapdog?”

Government MPs responded calling him kurang ajar.

Langkawi @chedetofficial stood up and call this parliament assembly as improper and against the wishes of Yang diPertuan Agong.

“Ini adalah satu penipuan” - @chedetofficial

“We don’t need a penerangan, we need a perbahasan” - @chedetofficial

“basically Tun is saying the meeting should have been an email” - @ushardaniele

Tun @chedetofficial cite Muhyiddin and Hamzah Zainuddin’s misguided Sabah election in 2020 as being the cause of this widespread Covid-19 infection.

Puchong questions why there is no voting in the parliament agenda.

“If there is no chance to vote, how can we decide whether this government failed or not?”

“Kalau benar kerajaan ini gagal sudah sampai masa untuk Perdana Menteri meletak jawatan!” - Puchong @GobindSinghDeo

Art Harun performance macam pakai processor Celeron pagi ni

My MP… the way he wears his face mask is a visual representation of his performance…

Art Harun muted Sepang. He said all opposition MPs are just repeating the same thing.

Bayan Baru kata Muhyiddin Yassin derhaka kepada Agong sebab delay parlimen dan tak benarkan ordinan darurat dibahaskan.

“Tuan Speaker, jangan heret parlimen ke arah kederhakaan!”

Speaker allowed Kuala Krau to speak. Opposition MPs protest since Kuala Krau is a timbalan menteri, hence a member of the executive. This is against parliamentary convention.

Kota Bharu @takiyuddin61 explains that in Malaysia there is a normal parliamentary session, and there is a special session.

He argues standing order is part of the Constitution. Puchong again counters saying standing order cannot supersede the Constitution.

Pulai and Puchong questions why there is no debate and no vote. Argues that the government disobeyed Agong.

Speaker argues that this session is indeed a special session, and Prime Minister can call and dictate the matter of the session.

“Urusan sidang khas ini mesti ditetapkan oleh Perdana Menteri”

Pulai: “Speaker you are misleading the house.

“Agong titah Perdana Menteri untuk bukak parlimen [untuk bahas dan undi]”

Art: “PERATURAN MESYUARAT KATA BILA SAYA BERUCAP YANG BERHORMAT DIAM”

“SAYA TAK BERSETUJU DENGAN SEMUA YANG BERHORMAT KATA TADI”

Emphasis his.

Art Harun rage quit

Port Dickson @anwaribrahim argues Agong’s instruction was clear: normal parliament session, not a special one

“Kalau ingkar maknanya derhaka!” - @anwaribrahim

“Nak belanja puluh bilion, tak ada undi!” - @anwaribrahim

Port Dickson kata sampai sekarang kerajaan tak terus terang umum darurat tak akan dilanjutkan melangkaui 1 Ogos

Beruas asks what is the function of calling parliament when no decision can be made.

“Macam sembang-sembang… bicara kopitiam”

Arau dan Pasir Salak dah mula

Kota Bharu @takiyuddin61 shows a document showing Agong consented to a special parliamentary session.

He also spoke on record saying that the government will not advise Agong to extend the emergency after it ends in August.

“Document speaks louder than word” - @takiyuddin61

Muhyiddin is giving his speech. No one gives a shit

Bagan is talking over Pagoh, Pagoh ignores and keep reading

Kota Bharu @takiyuddin61 clarified, decision to revoke emergency ordinance was made on July 21.

Pagoh continues his speech after interrupted earlier

Not sure what Papar is doing here

Muhyiddin: “Sejak ambil alih tampuk pemerintahan, kami diuji dengan krisis politik yang getir”

I wonder why 🤔

Since, according to @takiyuddin61, the emergency ordinances have been revoked as of July 21, that means there’s nothing for parliament to debate or vote on.

Interesting

Also, Art Harun tapped out. Rashid Hasnon is chairing the assembly

Two hours in, @NajibRazak hasn’t made a single sound in parliament

Pandan @drwanazizah got up and spoke on behalf of Malaysian doctors on their wellbeing #HartalDoktorKontrak

Bagan @guanenglim asks if emergency ordinances have been revoked on July 21, how can compounds still be issued?

If Art is Celeron, Rashid is Mediatek

Iskandar Puteri @limkitsiang questions why for 5 days the nation was not told that the emergency ordinances have been revoked

Mat Sabu tarik kerusi Anwar again. Classic move

Port Dickson @anwaribrahim is talking about the hardship faced by doctors.

“Doktor kalau dah mogok ni dia kecewa betul. Janganlah kita pandang ringan, jumlah dia 23 ribu, sampai kini belum ada kepastian”

#HartalDoktorKontrak

Arau bantah, tanya apa PH buat untuk doktor-doktor kontrak waktu PH dalam kerajaan

Gombak @AzminAli, out of nowhere: “Saya ada carta!”

Langkawi @chedetofficial TLDR: Kerajaan gagal, PM letak jawatan.

Parlimen breaks for lunch

So in summary:
1. Darurat tak akan dilanjutkan @takiyuddin61

2. Ordinan darurat dah dimansuhkan pada 21 Julai @takiyuddin61

Persoalan (oleh @guanenglim et al):
1. Kenapa pemansuhan tak diumumkan

2. Kalau dah mansuh, maknanya kuasa untuk kompaun pun termansuh

Inilah sebabnya parlimen kena bersidang

And we are back. Afternoon session of the ‘special’ parliamentary sitting, first of five days. Deputy Speaker @AzalinaOthmanS is chairing this session. Interesting to see, given her stance on things

Jelebu, on government side, mula dengan bercakap pasal kerajaan PH tak halang kemasukan pelancong China, back in January 2020

Dia tak dapat memo pasal penubuhan kerajaan Perikatan Nasional barangkali

Jelebu suggests private hospitals take in Covid patients. He didn’t get the memo they already did, and that private hospitals have been instructed to take non-Covid patients from government hospitals to make space for Covid patients there.

Deputy Speaker @AzalinaOthmanS is firm and cool headed. Kalau processor, dia Intel Xeon.

Kota Raja @MSabu_Official has the floor now, trashing darurat.

“Hari ini darurat ditarik secara diam-diam, sebab kalau diundi, Perdana Menteri akan kalah”

“Boleh bagi anugerah kepada Perdana Menteri. Selepas darurat angka dah sampai satu juta” - @MSabu_Official

“Kenapa kita tak boleh korbankan seorang [Muhyiddin], untuk selamatkan Malaysia ini?” - @MSabu_Official

Jempol (BN), implied that Rina Harun is a failure, bagi bantuan tapi tak sampai. Menarik

Jempol pun petik pasal pelacong China.

Shah Alam @KhalidSamad countered, saying when they hand the government over to PN there was zero Covid case for 11 days

Semporna now, questioning the money spent by this government of less than two year, spending almost 1 trillion ringgit in the form of moritorium, EPF, etc

“Case spike in Shah Alam, tutup di Perlis!” - Shafie Apdal

“Middle income earners that we built all these years dah collapsed dah!” - Shafie Apdal

The whole front row of the government side is empty by the way. No ministers are left in the dewan it seems.

Biasa la, bila sembang pasal Sabah

Sibuti raised an important point:

DUN Sarawak will automatically be dissolved the day the emergency is over. Election needs to happen 60 days from that date. Is Sarawak ready for election, Delta variant and all?

Stampin tanya Sibuti, setuju ke tak darurat diumumkan di Sarawak untuk elakkan pilihanraya.

Sibuti setuju.

“[Sarawak] belum bersedia lagi untuk pilihanraya dalam 60 hari lagi”

Muar @SyedSaddiq kutuk Muhyiddin, kata pengundi Pagoh lari datang Muar, mintak laptop sebab MP Pagoh tak perform

“Kerajaan jangan takut dengan tauke-tauke sarung tangan” - @SyedSaddiq, ketika mencadangkan windfall tax terhadap syarikat-syarikat ini.

“Umno, dekat social media pumpang-pumpang, dalam dewan SENYAP! Jangan la takut, kita LAWAN!” - @SyedSaddiq

“Yang jaga pintu sepadan negara ialah kementerian dalam negeri. Siapa menteri dalam negeri [dalam kerajaan PH] yang membenarkan pelancong luar masuk?” – @SyedSaddiq

Untuk rekod, Menteri Dalam Negeri dalam Kerajaan Pakatan Harapan ialah @MuhyiddinYassin

Secara tak langsung, Jelebu dan Jempol awal tadi mempersoalkan kewibawaan Perdana Menteri ketika memegang portfolio KDN

Arau mempersoalkan apa yang pembangkang maksudkan dengan #kerajaangagal, and promptly kena kutuk secara berjemaah

Rashid is back on the speaker chair btw, along with the durian jokes against him

Permatang Pauh has the floor

“Parlimen ini cerminan rakyat” – @n_izzah

True that. Jangan komplen sangat, kita yang undi MP-MP ni semua kawan-kawan

“Subsidi untuk menyelamatkan ekonomi Malaysia ialah subsidi rakyat untuk rakyat” - @n_izzah, talking about our EPF money

@n_izzah warns of the impending musim tengkujuh, and the possibility of Covid clusters when people are forced to relocate to shelters. Farsighted. Why is she not PM?

“Janganlah ambil tindakan terhadap doktor yang menyertai hartal ini” – @n_izzah

Polis dah buka kertas siasatan terhadap doktor-doktor ini, tengahari tadi.

Pasir Puteh. Can’t be anything important. Aku nak bancuh teh jap

“Pandang ke depan, saya taknak ungkit,” said Pasir Puteh before starting to ungkit about Selangor’s Covid cases, and Sabah’s election being triggered by Semporna’s decision to dissolve Sabah assembly

Haha Bukit Mertajam.

“PM cirit pun boleh umumkan, takkan ordinan darurat dimansuhkan tak boleh umum?” - @scheekeong

PONTIAN!

Pontian speeding through 12 points in under a minute. @ahmadmaslan ni pakai processor Apple M1. 10/10 would recommend.

7 more points in the time it takes me to type this.

“Ada banyak lagi, berpuluh-puluh” – @ahmadmaslan after his time runs out. Ahmad Maslan cares

Pasir Mas ada kedai tomyam sedap tepi sungai, dekat-dekat pejabat pos. Can confirm, tebing sungai tengah terhakis

Arau is arguing MPs kutuk Timbalan Speaker buat pesta durian sebagai mengutuk sifat peribadi Timbalan Speaker.

Sifat peribadi Timbalan Speaker Rashid Hasnon ialah pesta durian?…

Jelutong ni riuh aih… sama naik ja dengan Arau

Pulai is taking us down memory lane, from Memali to MH17 to Sulu incursion, talking about responsibility.

“17 ribu mati… di mana menteri kesihatan?”

Simpang Renggam @maszlee bercakap tentang sekolah. SOP, vaccinate teachers, vaccinate students taking SPM & STAM with parent’s consent. All very sensible things

“Sikap jadong yang dipamerkan oleh Kementerian Pendidikan sebelum ini, perlu diubah” – @maszlee

Jadong ni apa kawan-kawan? Jahat, bodoh, dan sombong. Dicipta oleh Prof Syed Hussein Alatas

@maszlee also calls for autonomy for schools to decide instead of letting Putrajaya dictate on things they have no clue about

Art is back, reject @PattoKasthuri’s request to talk about women’s issue.

“Hari ni kita rugi dua jam, kalau tak 24 orang boleh berhujah hari ni”

@scheekeong asks Speaker where is the Prime Minister. Both PM and his deputy is not in Dewan Rakyat

PM and DPM left @tzafrul_aziz to answer on the government’s behalf, in his capacity as Coordinating Minister for Covid Recovery. Opposition MPs are not having it

“Belum pernah dalam sejarah negara ini soalan substantif tentang perlembagaan dan darurat dijawab oleh Menteri Kewangan!” – @anwaribrahim

Oh DPM @IsmailSabri60 is here now. He’s arguing @tzafrul_aziz is the right person to answer.

“Menteri kewangan sebagai menteri penyelaras yang tahu nak jawab apa”

So PM tau apa?

Good time to remember that the Finance Minister is a senator. He does not speak on behalf of any rakyat in a chamber called ‘Dewan Rakyat’.

Puchong is asking questions that, I think, @tzafrul_aziz have no idea how to answer

Bingo, @tzafrul_aziz passed the buck to @takiyuddin61 “who will answer later”

Gombak is up, assisting the cornered finance minister. Earlier he had a chart, now he’s talking about lists.

I spoke too soon. Dia ada flashcard pulak. Show and tell day in Dewan Rakyat

HAHAHA. @tzafrul_aziz’s interesting slip of the tongue, saying Lembah Pantai instead of Lembah Klang. 🤨

Sabah will receive the single dose Cansino and Johnson & Johnson vaccine. This was revealed by Finance Minister @tzafrul_aziz when pressed about it by Sabah MPs in parliament.

@Khairykj will formally announce it on Wednesday, he said.

Parliament ends with many things left unanswered. Esok turn @DrAdhamBaba to explain about Covid. Good luck to him, seems like it will be a rough day.