Leaked CDC slides on delta variant got you concerned?

I find the slides insightful & largely reassuring

Bottom line

Delta variant is a problem

Vaccines prevent vast majority of infections, transmission

And nearly all hospitalizations, deaths

Thread

washingtonpost.com/context/cdc-br…
So let's talk about what's in the slides about the delta variant

First, it is really, really contagious

Like more contagious than Ebola, Spanish Flu and probably chicken pox

Really contagious

2/n
Second, it appears to cause more serious disease if you get infected

I've been worried this is the case but certainly not sure

The data here is suggestive but not definitive

So reasonable to say delta probably more severe

3/n
But the vaccines are working.

Let me repeat, the vaccines are working

80-90% effectiveness against symptomatic infection

90-95% effectiveness against severe disease

That's what the data from other countries say

But what about data from our country??

Glad you asked

4/n
Right now, about 35K vaccinated Americans having breakthrough infections weekly

Sound high?

Actually, probably 300K unvaccinated Americans having infections weekly

And given 50% of Americans are vaccinated

That's a rough vaccine effectiveness of around 88%

Very rough

5/n
Oh -- and protection against severe infection well above 90%

So yeah, vaccines are working fine

But what about this whole breakthrough infections and spreadability?

Can vaccinated folks with breakthrough spread?

Yes. And this is the bad news

6/9
CDC cites several studies (and I'm aware of even more data) showing

vaccinated folks with breakthrough infections have similar viral loads to unvaccinated folks with infections

These are viral loads, not actual evidence of similar transmission

But a reasonable assumption

7/9
Then CDC has modeling that says universal masking is critically important

But they assume no other behavior change like some folks avoiding large gatherings, etc.

But you know what their model also says would work great?

Near universal vaccinations

8/9
So bottom line?

Yeah, delta variant is bad. Like really bad

Our vaccines are good. Like really good

Breakthrough infections happen

Sometimes they may spread to others

But if enough people get the shot

The pandemic does come to an end

Fin

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Ashish K. Jha, MD, MPH

Ashish K. Jha, MD, MPH Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ashishkjha

31 Jul
Lots of confusion about what Provincetown outbreak & CDC guidance mean

Mainly: how to think about spread among the vaccinated

And as importantly, what we know and what we don't

So a short thread
First, the P-town outbreak unusual

Many thousands of people (some unvaccinated) showed up to celebrate July 4

Leading to packed bars, clubs, and lots of mixing of vaccinated and unvaccinated folks in tight quarters

Ideal conditions for COVID spread

And COVID did spread

2/n
And there were a lot of infections, including among vaccinated folks

We've seen this before -- Singapore airport, Yankees clubhouse

Key issue is: did vaccines fail to

1. Prevent infection?
2. Prevent spread?
3. Prevent severe illness?
Read 8 tweets
28 Jul
CDC revised its mask recommendations for vaccinated people

Its causing relief among in some circles, confusion in others and anger in others yet

My take?

A modest change with likely modest effects

A change that is responding to the realities on the ground

Thread
So here's the thing

Changing guidance in response to new evidence isn't flip-flopping

Its what we should always do

CDC said in May that vaccinated people are largely safe (they rarely get infected, they don't spread)

That was correct

At the time

Before Delta showed up

2/5
With delta:

unvaccinated people have 1000X the viral load of the previous variant

And now, new data (we haven't seen it yet) suggests:

While breakthrough infections are uncommon

But when they happen, some vaccinated folks have a high viral load too

Not ideal

3/6
Read 7 tweets
25 Jul
For much of winter, spring, I was VERY optimistic we'd have a great summer with few infections, deaths

Through June, things looked good

But situation has clearly turned worse

There are 3 things that have turned out worse than I anticipated

So lets talk about them

Thread
1. Delta -- turns out to be way more contagious than anything we've seen before

2. Vaccinations. We hit a wall with under 50% of population fully immunized

3. Waning immunity -- still prelim -- but more breakthrough infections as folks get further out from their shots

2/4
Combo:

Super contagious variant
Lots of unvaccinated folks
And more breakthrough infections

Sets up a vicious cycle

And a tough few months ahead

We need to break the cycle

How?

Public health measures (masks, reduced indoor gatherings, ventilation, testing) will help

3/4
Read 4 tweets
21 Jul
Vaccinations have fallen off a cliff

We are now administering about 500K shots a day -- half of them 2nd shots

At this rate, it'll take about another year to get to 80% fully vaccinated

But we can do better than that if we do a few things

Short thread
If we continue vaccinating 250K new folks/day, yes, it'll take another year to get to 80%

But of course, as we vaccinate,

remaining population gets harder to reach...so things will slow further

So what to do?

First, it'll help to get kids 5-11 eligible -- probably fall

2/4
But that won't be near enough

So what will help?

1. Continue reaching out to unvaccinated, answering questions, improving access

2. FDA full approval. Yes, this will help a lot

3. Schools & businesses creating virus-free spaces through vaccination requirements

3/4
Read 5 tweets
10 Jul
Don't love to see this

Infections up nationally -- about 50% from two weeks ago

This is the Delta variant now widespread

Test positive from 1.7% --> 3.2% nationally

But this is not the whole story

Infections increasing in 22 states
Holding steady in 15
Falling in 13

Thread
Here are your three most vaccinated states -- still low, holding steady

Combined, Test + around 0.6%

And your three lowest vaccinated states -- not great

Combined, Test + around 6%

But even in states with moderate degrees of vaccinations, cases are rising
Thankfully, unlikely to see run on hospitals nationally

Because most high risk folks vaccinated

But more infections, hospitalizations unfortunately on the way unless we:

1. Employ public health measures again (masks, distancing etc)

2. Get 60-65% of population vaccinated

End
Read 4 tweets
8 Jul
As of today,

4 "green" states on @CovidActNow map

3 New England states & South Dakota!

Why green? Because they have very low numbers of infections

How? Largely from population immunity

Lets compare VT and SD -- two states that took different paths to get here

Thread
Vermont and South Dakota are actually very similar

Both have slightly older, white, rural populations

Have comparable median incomes

Both have Republican governors

And these days, they look super similar on infections

Here they are over past 2 months

2/5
But here's where they diverge

Vermont has vaccinated (1+ shot) nearly 75% of its population

SD? 50%

Vermont has a high degree of immunity through vaccinations

So how does SD have high population immunity?

Prior infections

Here's how pandemic has played out in both states
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(