In the next days @IUCN is hosting its world conservation congress. But we need to scrutinise the solutions of the conservation industry from an angle of justice and rights.
A short 🧵why the alternative summit (watch online tomorrow!) is so important.1/x ourlandournature.org
Why am I so interested in this topic? I studied a MSc in conservation management in the UK and I do think we all should criticise the sectors or industries we work in and push them to improve. Conservation has a racist, colonial past and in some places a neo-colonial present. 2/x
No one in the alternative congress says that conservation of wildlife and ecosystems is not necessary - there is no question the situation is urgent. But we are challenging how this should be done and who takes the decisions. 3/x
Most importantly, Indigenous and local communities want their land rights fully protected and not be evicted when new protected areas are created by gov and big conservation NGOs.
While mainstream conservation often pays lip service to "include local communities" or obtain "free prior and informed consent" this is often not respected in practice - particularly in Asia and Africa.
It is our responsibility to make sure they keep their promises. 5/x
The alternative congress highlights the shortcomings and problems with the conservation industry, but also provides an alternative vision how biodiversity could be protected by the communities themselves.
Watch the congress to hear the speakers! It's streamed for free! 6/x
A big part of the discussion is on the 30x30 proposal, to protect 30% of the Earth' surface by 2030. Catchy slogan, but no science in the numbers.
If you don't have time to watch, have a read here to get an overview. 7/x
As everyone knows and agrees protecting 30% doesn't magically solve the biodiversity crisis, as long as we don't target the real drivers (habitat loss due to e.g. industrial agriculture; overfishing; climate change; pollution etc) which would mean restricting industries. 8/x
The intergov panel of biodiv experts @IPBES noted in their last global 2019 report that we must steer away from the paradigm of econ growth, in a recent workshop report together with IPCC they also suggested "finding alternatives to capitalism". 9/x
However, a lot of conservation actors are determined capitalists who think they could protect biodiversity by selling forests as carbon credits to BlackRock or creating international biodiversity offset markets. Follow @greenfinanceobs for infos on this. 10/x
Where all of this is headed also depends on how we in the global North support frontline communities.
How media reports about the IUCN conference
Who donors chose to donate to
Who conservation students chose to work for
Whether we protest and engage in direct action
11/x
I am in no ways an expert on these issues, but people who speak in the alternative congress are, so please check out their organisation websites or follow their social media accounts to learn more and see how to support them. 13/x ourlandournature.org/speakers
To sum up: we need to take care of the living planet, but not in the way the mainstream conservation industry tells us. We need to respect people's rights to their lands, water respected and we need to end capitalism. There are sadly no shortcuts. 14/14
(btw yes, I am also here in Marseille to connect with people, learn from the speakers, plan further projects to support, just no point to put a spotlight on myself)
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The death of 43 people at sea doesn't create a fraction of the media attention compared to a pipeline rupture extinguished in 5 hours.
The worsening climate crisis - and pictures on social media - will not shock people into action. What matters is personal, real experience. 1/x
I am not saying the pipeline rupture isn't terrible. But people care for 5 seconds and then move on. In case of shipwrecks hardly anyone cares. That's the risk we are facing with the climate crisis. Everyone getting used to people dying from heat strokes or wildfires. 2/x
And in fact, people are suffering and dying from the climate crisis and resulting air pollution already in the millions every year and it is nearly completely normalised. Covid did prove once again how quickly people can normalise preventable deaths and gov failure. 3/x
On the topic of my representation in the media. I find it frustrating.
If I see anyone writing an article saying "Carola the voice of the migrants" again, I will seriously consider to never speak to any journalist again. It seems mostly completely pointless.
Here is why.
1/n
First, as anyone can tell you, migrants and refugees have voices of their own. I have never claimed to speak for them. It's completely wrong to make it appear as if I was talking on behalf of someone else, I will never speak "for migrants" as they can speak for themselves.
2/n
I have not given a single interview on "migration" since last autumn. I pass on all those requests. Whenever I give interviews it's about connecting topics of social justice and the environment. Remember, I am an ecologist, not any sort of migration expert.
3/n
I think it's hard to make that hashtag trend cause my understanding is the majority of EU citizens don't know that agency even exists, less so what they do.
/1
The European border agency "protects" the EU external borders at land and sea.
Often, they protect it from people who try to get here to claim asylum. Why do people want to get here at all? Because of massive global inequality, caused by capitalism, colonialism, racism. /2
So what is the Frontex mission then?
An attempt to continue "business as usual", shutting off the globally priviledged EU from the misery we cause around the globe by extraction of resources and cheap labour. They are the guards of Fortress Europe. /3
Today it's the day of #Chernobyl disaster. Many people still suffer from health impacts.
A large part of the contaminated area is now a biosphere reserve (Ukraine & Belarus). Here some short parts of an interview I did in 12/18 with reserve educator Viktoria Melnychuk.
1/x
"A lot of visitors are scared to come here, especially Ukrainians. There was no information. People didn't know what had happened and which process has been made since. We try to change this and provide information."
2/x
"For us it's important to change people's mind. They come here thinking everything is bad and destroyed. They leave thinking that life finds ways to recover from disaster, that things can be restored and that there is hope for our children."
3/x
Apart from rescue capacity we also lack the possibility to see and report what is going on in the Med. This week a Maltese gov vessel refused to rescue and destroyed the engine of a rubber boat as reported in a call to Alarm Phone. /2
What worries me at large is that authorities use the health crisis as an argument to prevent rescue vessels to go out at sea or find safe ports. Even though Libya now declared it's ports unsafe due to war activities and shelling. /3