The Bank of Canada made borrowing cheaper than inflation.

Now just 3 massive funds own over 10% of primary rental housing in West Toronto... but concentrated in a 12-block radius.

Quick thread on 🇨🇦 serving up the poor on a platter.
🧵👇 #Toronto

@Hulchanski @Martine_August
2. Pensions and institutional investors usually have a massive fixed-income strategy. This is income that comes in regularly.

It's usually bonds. Bonds are essentially owning an issuer's debt, and the yield is the interest they pay to you regularly.
3. Bond yields are determined by how much capital is in the system. If everyone wants to lend you money, you don't have to pay a lot.

Think of Zuckerberg, who pays less than 1% on his mortgage.

The opposite is also true. Think of people with bad credit, that have to pay extra.
4. It's supposed to be self-regulating. However, central banks have increasingly intervened in this process.

Since the Great Recession, they've adopted the mindset, "if everyone just had a little extra cheap credit, things would be better."

No one has to go broke!
5. So they flood the market to keep rates low. During the pandemic, they even bought 40% of government issuance to make sure the extra borrowing didn't lead to increasing rates.

But, when the central bank does that, where do the existing bond investors go?
6. They still have to produce a return, and they don't want to lose money to inflation. Especially if they're a pension, that has to pay inflation out.

So they've been going to alternative asset managers, like Blackrock. We're not talking about Blackrock today, but similar ones.
7. Now these alternative asset managers have way too much money. So what do they do? Part of it flows into mega new residential real estate funds.

Rents can rise *at least* as fast as inflation, and faster if people move out, municipalities approve above guideline rents, etc.
8. The longer rates are held lower, the more money flows to these funds buying real estate.

They just keep getting more cash as institutions have to beat inflation.

Get money cheaper than inflation. Get rent at inflation. The property value is practically just free gains.
9. In the TO situation, risk is building up.

Concentrating in an area can create a monopolistic environment.

I'm not saying they're intentionally acting as a monopoly, but ~10% of their holdings are vacant.

If you asked me to build a monopoly, I would do exactly this.
10. This doesn't impact just one area though. Adjacent neighborhoods use it as comps.

The behavior is only in one area, but the impact will radiate from the area they're concentrated in.

The Fed's plan to fund more rentals will flow directly into their pocket.
11. Cheap money is a great way to expand empires.

The issue is, if you don't have an empire, you're just a sitting duck waiting for a well-funded empire to claim you.

The crisis is about to get a lot worse, and it's because of the reckless printing the BoC has been doing.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Stephen Punwasi 🌋 🚀

Stephen Punwasi 🌋 🚀 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @StephenPunwasi

1 Sep
Income taxes are a tax on labor.

Property taxes are a tax on the monopoly of public resources.

Why are property taxes so low, while labor taxes are so high?

Your first hint is the class of people who designed the tax system.
2. The one thing (real) capitalists and socialists agree on is land is prone to a natural monopoly.

Monopolies are against the public’s interest, so the theory is it needs to be made inefficient to hold land without a real use.

Thread for folks asking for an explanation.
3. Life is ideally a balance between private wealth and the interest of the public.

The Lauderdale Paradox is one of the first explorations into the concept.

Every gain a private person makes, uses public resources. Improvements to life come at the expense of the public. 🤷‍♂️🧵👇
Read 4 tweets
29 Aug
What if socialism is the secret to great hair? 🧐 Image
2. Exhibit B. @David_Moscrop before and after socialism. 🧐 ImageImage
3. exhibit C. @elonmusk before and after billions in government subsidies. Coincidence? 🧐🤷‍♂️ ImageImage
Read 4 tweets
26 Aug
🇨🇦 proving it’s a banana republic.

The first election where people under 40 will outnumber Boomers…

… and 🇨🇦 won’t be setting up campus voting for the first time in decades because of “… the minority government situation.”

#cdnpoli #ItsOurVote
What Elections Canada is doing is voter suppression.

If this happened in 🇺🇸, Canadians would talk about how GOP is corrupt and they’re so glad they live in 🇨🇦.

Now that the elections officer Trudeau appointed removed access to voters he polls poorly with? Silence. 🤷‍♂️

#Elxn44
I don’t think the Liberals know how shitty this looks, but give it a few days.

Elections Canada is galvanizing distrust in your governance with young people right now.
Read 4 tweets
24 Aug
I see Incel/YIMBY Twitter is coordinating criticism of me.

Here's a brief recap of our relationship.

<thread> 🧵 👇

#ToRe #VanRe
2.

Me (2016): Corrupt politicians from China are washing their money in Vancouver, in one of the biggest grafts in history.

YIMBYS: RACIST! That's a lie!

China (2017): Canada. Turn over our fucking criminals.
3.

Me (2017): We built one of the most elaborate capital tracking systems, more complicated than the gov. Money laundering is rampant in Vancouver. This is how it comes in, right down to the gang.

YIMBYS: Fake news!

BC gov (2018): Stephen's right, down to the gang and origin.
Read 11 tweets
24 Aug
Liberals now promising a ban on foreign ownership of real estate.

I thought Liberal supporters said this was xenophobic when the Conservatives proposed it? 🤷‍♂️

#elxn44 #VanRe #ToRe
2. Interesting sidenote. Trudeau made the announcement in Hamilton, Ontario.

The IMF told us Hamilton was 40% overvalued, one of the largest overvaluations in the world.

Here's the IMF model they shared, and this exclusively happened under the Liberal government.

#HamOnt
3. For anyone else that's curious, this is what the IMF models look like for Toronto and Vancouver.

Once again, almost all of this gap between fundamentals and price occurs under the Liberal government.

#ToRe #VanRe

betterdwelling.com/canadian-real-…
Read 6 tweets
22 Aug
People keep comparing rent subsidies to minimum wage increases.

This isn't even close to the same, and implies a very poor grasp of basic economics and business.

Quick thread. 🧵👇
2. Idiots say if you raise the minimum wage by $1, it'll result in much more expensive food.

We know that's not necessarily true, because a $1 increase to labor is not a $1 increase to product output. It doesn't take a whole hour.

It takes 5 min. So it adds 9 cents.
3. Giving cash subsidies for market housing is very different. When the cost of shelter is rising fast, the market can more easily absorb it.

That's how high home prices are justified. They cut interest rates, so now people can carry a higher cost of housing.
Read 15 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(