The Arg fell in less than half an hour after Ghani’s exit to a group who, we now know, belong to the Haqqani faction of Taliban.
How could the Haqqani terrorists so quickly reach Kabul from their positions outside the capital city?
It seems like they were working with their accomplices inside the Arg and had prior positions inside the city. Before the defense minister was able to act to defend the president’s office, they got to Arg.
This blitzkrieg-like attack gives rise to the suspicion that President Ghani and the Haqqani group, who belong to the same Pashtun tribal confederacy as him, i.e. the Qaljayis, were conspiring together; Arg was given to the Taliban in conjunction with Ghani’s escape.
The one man who could have stopped the Taliban take-over, i.e the defense minister, was kept away.
...
The two grand tribal confederacies, Qaljayis and Dorranis, have long competed with one another. Their power struggle is a theme of Afghanistan’s political history.
In their search for a strong supporter, Qaljayis became closer to Pakistan (the current Pakistani prime minister...is also a Qaljayi.) Meanwhile, Dorrani politicians found themselves closer to Qatar which, given its sheer wealth, has become a major powerbroker in the region.
The same theme that animated the Ghani-Karzai clash will now see a clash between Sirajuddin Haqqani, a Qaljani who considers himself a caliph, and Hibatullah Akhundzada, a Dorrani who prefers the Commander of the Faithful title.
If Akhundzada is actually alive and finally appears in front of TV cameras, the competition will intensify.
We can thus conclude that the leadership of Taliban, too, is engulfed with ethnic and tribal conflicts between Dorranis and Qaljayis and these tensions could add to
the challenges and increasing rivalries. This is especially true since we have yet to see proof that Akhundzada is indeed alive and well.
...
Sirajuddin Haqqani is close to capturing an effective caliphate for himself; the power is going to be
completely transferred from Dorranis to Qaljayis. This explains why the supporters of Mr. Haqqani have taken into calling him Caliph — they are paving the way to his reaching the top Taliban leadership position. english.aawsat.com/home/article/3…
It is interesting to note, my line of thought also matches this wavelength - but not on the lines of a tribal confederacy.
Tajikistan has become the centre of focus of the world these days. So, what do we know about that country? First of all, a race by name Tajik doesn't exist. Tajik in Persian means someone who is not a Turk and speaks Persian. What of Dushanbe?
Dushanbe means Monday in Persian - Dushanbe was a settlement built on a monday market site on the local trade routes. Now, this place traditionally had no distinct history though the race is attested to at least 500 BC.
There is a controversy over who they are - are they Persianized locals like the Scythians or Persian immigrants, there is no clear information. Tajikistan was just a part of the Central Asian Empires and rarely a part of the expanded Persian and Chinese Empires - Scythians,
Let me present another conspiracy theory. Some projections estimate that Karakoram Highway will be permanently destroyed by 2024-25 because of the surging Shishpar Glacier and China has got two options -
spend hunderds of millions to build a new road or search for an alternative. Now, an alternative exists - Taliban controlled Afghanistan. China can enter either through Wakhan or Termez and if Taliban can guarantee stability,
China-Iran link is a far better proposition than the loss making, terror infested CPEC. China knows this and Pakistan knows this. So, what should Pakistan do? And if Taliban sees no use with Pakistan, with CPEC dead, what will Pakistan do?
Tibet is another legally murky territory. China invaded and occupied it but the erstwhile government of Tibet fled to India. So, China's occupation itself is still disputed. Now, going further back into history. Let me talk about three distinct units which matter -
Tibet, Guge and South Tibet. Guge is a tricky subject. It was an independent kingdom and almost alm history, it was independent of Tibet. In 1642, Ladakh invaded Guge and conquered it. Consequently, the border between Ladakh and Tibet was marked near Mt Kailash.
In 1684, Ladakh was pushed back and a treaty was signed. The border is loosely defined to be between Stok, Ruthog and Ngari. But because of the religious importance attached to Manasarovara, Ladakh was given a village - Minsar just by the sacred lake. Likewise, Bhutan,
Now that Afghanistan disaster is nearing an end, there are a few questions for the Indian Government.1 1. What is your strategic outlook with regard to Pakistan for the next ten years? Is there a long term plan available to tackle the Pakistani nuisance for good?
Yes. Pakistan is just nuisance grade, but nuisance nonetheless. 2. What is going to be with Afghanistan? Where do you see Afghanistan in the next ten years? Are we going for a sedentary Taliban ruled Afghanistan or are we going for something completely different?
3. Every country achieved something out of this Afghan fiasco. What did India gain? Are you thinking of establishing a land bridge as a precaution? 4. What role is India going to play in controlling Helmand-Gwadar drug smuggling axis? Any proactive and aggressive steps planned?
Need not be. Chinachara comes from China -> Kinnaur and not China. China, Aparachina and Mahachina should be looked from that angle. Also. Guge Country is traditionally called as Hunadesa -> Possibly because of Xiongnu incursions.
Plus you need to look at gold digging ants as well. This is something which is related to Aksai Chin-Ruthog area. Possibly what we are looking at is Trans-Karakoram Tract and not northern Afghanistan. Now, because this discussion IIRC originated from Gupta tribute,
either Skandagupta or Kumaragupta - one of them mentions Kailasa in his conquests - clearly, he entered the Guge Plains in force.
From Gen @Muham_madi1's Wiki page.
"Expecting the eruption of a civil war after the American withdrawal, officers have been gravitating towards ethnic groupings and powerful generals, with Mohammadi and the Pashtu Defense Minister Wardak at the head of the two largest cliques."
In June 2010, Bismillah Khan was transferred from his position as Army Chief of Staff to the post of Interior Minister by President Hamid Karzai.
The departure of Mohammadi from the Ministry of Defense leaves no one who can rival Wardak in stature, which could mean a weakening of centrifugal forces.