Thread by @mcnees

Mathematician Bernhard Riemann was born #OTD in 1826. He made deep contributions to complex analysis and number theory, but is best remembered by physicists for his work on the foundations of geometry that would one day provide the mathematical framework for general relativity.

Riemann was the star pupil of Gauss, who described Riemann's PhD thesis on complex variables as the work of someone with “a gloriously fertile originality.” I try to use this phrase in every rec letter that I write.

A few years later, when Riemann was up for a faculty position, Gauss set him the task of reformulating the foundations of geometry.

Nbd, just the greatest mathematician of the age asking him to reformulate the foundations of a subject spelled out by Euclid 2,000 years earlier.

Riemann's lecture "On the Hypotheses Which Lie at the Foundations of Geometry," developing and expanding the ideas of his mentor Gauss into what we now call Riemannian geometry, was delivered in 1854. A translation is available here: lymcanada.org/wp-content/upl…

Riemann's geometry is broader than the geometry axiomatized by Euclid. He generalizes the infinitesimal version of the Pythagorean theorem describing the distance between two nearby points, and dispenses with the infamous 5th axiom about parallel lines.

(Euclid's 5th postulate basically says that if I give you a straight line and a point not on that line, both in a plane, you can draw a second line through the point that never intersects the first line. That's not true on intrinsically curved surfaces like a globe or a saddle.)

Riemann introduced a number of now-familar concepts in his lecture: the metric tensor as the quadratic form governing infinitesimal distances, curved spaces of arbitrary dimension, geodesics, normal coordinates, and the curvature tensor that now bears his name.

He also asked whether or not his approach to geometry, based as it was on mathematically local statements about space, could be a valid description of physical reality if matter is discrete. He suggested that this was a question for physicists, not mathematicians.

Others would try to shape Riemann's ideas into a theory relating the motion of matter and the curvature of space. Clifford's "Space Theory of Matter" is a notable example.

https://twitter.com/mcnees/status/1230907076370714625

It was Einstein, of course, who finally got it right. Riemann's work (following Gauss, Lobachevsky, and others) freed mathematicians from rigid notions of space and geometry, and provided Einstein with the mathematical framework needed to express the ideas of general relativity.

(That is, it was Einstein who first understood how Riemannian geometry applies in the physical world. He learned about the work of Riemann, Ricci, and others from his friend and colleague Marcel Grossman.)

Unfortunately, Riemann was never in very good health, and in 1862 he developed tuberculosis. He convalesced in Italy off and on for a few years, but eventually succumbed to the illness, passing away in 1866. He was only 39 years old.

Riemann was supposedly working on something at the time, and there is an apocryphal story that many unpublished works –– the products of his "gloriously fertile originality" –– were carelessly discarded by someone cleaning out his quarters after he passed away.