"Invert, always invert: Turn a situation or problem upside down. Look at it backward. Instead of looking for success, make a list of how to fail instead. Tell me where I’m going to die, that is, so I don’t go there." – Charlie Munger
So @blocknative has been looking closely at EIP-1559 vs legacy txs since this question & one thing I learned from the discussions absolutely blew my brain up:
Since EIP-1559 there are often a large number of transactions sitting in the tx pool EVEN WHEN BLOCKS ARE NEARLY EMPTY.
Say whaaaa?! That must be a bug, right? Or are miners just mining empty blocks for shits and giggles? It’s not always the case, right?
No. No. Wrong.
This is actually…er…the design.
Big brains may see it already but if you have a brain like mine, I’ll walk you thru it. 😁
Note:
- Type 2 = EIP-1559 transactions
- Type 0 = legacy, gas price transactions
- Effective Fee = aka effective tip (see attached). how much the miner will get from the tx. how txs are sorted in a node’s tx pool. presumably the order txs are included in.
This system's increasing obsession with, and glorification of, money (or "value" as y'all call it) is probably the largest threat to a system that can create money-value out of code and tweets.
Having money doesn't necessarily improve you condition.
Creating new money doesn't necessarily improve society and the human condition.
Having money *can* give you some power. It can give you some control. It can give you some choices otherwise unavailable. The more you have, the more it *can* give you, to a point.
But creating new money doesn't give you any power outside that circle of money.
Its the middle of August. EIP-1559 is here. The current Base Fee is `40.` For simplicity, and 0% of confidence in the future state of the network, let's say there's an equal probability that the base fee is any number between `30` and `50` if your TX is included in block....
What TX fee do you use?
Oh what's that? You don't have enough information? Okay fine.
Background:
Base Fee = Set by network, is burned, changes each block by <12.5%. You know the Current Base Fee (40).
Tip = Set by user/wallet. Paid to miner.
Max Fee = Set by user/wallet. Amt you send your TX with. Max you could pay.
I know a lot of research and technical brilliance went into EIP-1559. And I know I've stayed relatively quiet on the subject for a variety of reasons but...ugh. fml.
EIP-1559 does NOT deliver.
(ps: read before you speak. this isn't personal so don't @ me like it is. 😒)
EIP-1559, along with other EIPs, were initially conceived and proposed because the gas limit/gas price mechanism could be better. It's could be more efficient. It could be better for users. It could introduce more certainty. Improving things is GOOD.