I remember at UBS we used to write in 2000s how and why China’s property market was the most important in the world. Fast fwd to 2021, it still is. At over 16% GDP, its more than 2 x US real estate in 2008. Evergrande et al are key to real estate, & metaphor for the economy /1
It surely cannot be allowed to end up in a messy default with collapsing property prices a) anyway b) so close to nov 22 Party Congress, but govt restructuring plan can’t wait too long as fin distress mounts /2
That said, extend and pretend, and other restructuring solutions will only defer a denouement for real estate, which is cyclically and structurally weak and having regulatory headwinds, incl from Common Prosperity. /3
So, even if the govt managed to manage the current crisis for a year or so the allocation of costs among creditors and households is unavoidable, now sooner than later. Losses will occur, prices will fall at least in real terms and growth will be pegged back. Ends.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with George Magnus

George Magnus Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @georgemagnus1

10 Aug
China’s crackdown on tech, finance & data isn’t over, and while each firm/sector has its own tale,the big pic is more ominous/political and not just about regulation. My take on why CCP is providing latest in why ‘inevitable rise’ isn’t a slam dunk at all newstatesman.com/world/asia/202…
Aside from fact that CCP is not comprised of economic magicians, China’s development path, which many extrapolate on spreadies to mid century +, isn’t a mechanical concept. Too many need reminding of both. /2
I’m addition to Red Flag structural headwinds, China now faces the most hostile external environment in over 4 decades. What some see as it’s Sputnik moment may also be game changer in more troubling, negative ways. /3
Read 8 tweets
3 Aug
China tech crackdown rolls on, today the gaming sector. But what do all these sector campaigns in tech, finance and data actually mean? Is China boldly going, or screwing up? /1 Tencent Shares Dive After Chinese Media Brand Online Games ‘Spiritual Opium’ bloomberg.com/news/articles/…
Much of what’s going on falls under Xi’s social agenda, aka common prosperity, in which the CCP will act against tendency of markets to exacerbate inequality or threaten party’s control of data, unchallenged power and so on. /2
You can come up with reasons on a case by case basis to see China blazing a trail that many liberals would support to act against consumer technologies that add little to economic welfare and may undermine it /3
Read 5 tweets
30 Jul
Interesting chart from Capital Economics showing how mkt valuation of Chinese equities has slumped to lowest since the 14/15 crash, other than covid in early 20. How much further will this go? /1
Or is this the buying opportunity many hope it represents? The answer is strongly weighted towards the former, ie China’s robust moves to restrain free and open capital markets is part of a wider script even allowing for ostensibly reasonable social agenda goals. /2
So acting pro ppl who can’t afford expensive tutoring, gig workers, data privacy all seem fair, but the bigger picture is a political clamp down on private firms and entrepreneurs. Remember ‘the party leads everything’, and we can see evidence predating Ant by a long way /3
Read 4 tweets
27 Jul
China's tech etc crackdown is leading to a huge valuation change, eg here NASDAQ Golden Dragon Index capturing lge and mid cap Ch tech stocks trading in NY. Buying opportunity or giant wake up call? Here's why it's more likely the latter /1
Fair to say that every sector has its own tale to tell.. fintech, data, tutoring, music streaming etc. But the big pic narrative is abt the pol crackdown on private firms, especially those with lots of foreign investment (direct and via listings in the US), interest and ideas./2
More private firms are being brought to heel as control > growth and innovation.Contradiction is clear. Government doubtless believes in power of tech firms to change the world in its favour but clampdown is frustrating its own ambition. Not widely appreciated yet, or priced /3
Read 4 tweets
1 Jul
The centenary is actually later this month not today, but the CCP doesn’t let facts interfere with its version of history. Today’s big speech by Gen Sec Xi Jinping was typically nationalistic. Main take aways /1 Image
In a strongly nationalist appeal to his own citizens and warning to the US and other states, the main take-away is irony. He emphasised and drew applause for saying that foreign powers would ‘get their heads bashed’ if they attempted to bully or influence China.  /2
Yet outside China, the dominant view is that it is Beijing that seeks to bully, influence, and even interfere so as to stifle criticism of and gather support for China’s narratives and actions.  /3
Read 5 tweets
12 May
Some inflation comment here. With annual CPI now at 4.2% and core at 3%, the post pandemic path of inflation is clearly stirring worries. The monthly changes this year so far are feisty, but there are some good reasons to think this isn't simply a post pandemic thing /1
One key factor is the monetary backdrop which is still quite unusual, and accommodative in ways that we never saw after the GFC. Demand deposits, not just banks' balances at the Fed, are booming, making for potentially very fertile spending backdrop. /2
Materials shortages, long delivery times, supply chain choke points are joining rising commodity prices and rising pay in a chorus of inflation pressures, we haven't seen for a long time. Service workers comp rose by over 5% annualised in Q1, the biggest gain for 20 yrs /3
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(