.@jnpowell1 has written an important article in @FT (£ - I assume) about Johnson govt casual disregard for Northern Ireland ft.com/content/bb92d1…
Lots of blame attached to Frost and Johnson. But I think he could cast his net wider. As @UKandEU #Brexitwitnessarchive shows there was hardly any consideration of the consequences of a Leave vote in the decision to hold a referendum.
Read interviews here....ukandeu.ac.uk/brexit-witness…
David Cameron appointed eurosceptics as NI secretary - who did not believe there were risks because they would point out there was already a VAT/currency border and whose Brexenthusiam would outweigh them anyway
Meanwhile most of the civil service - along with other politicians - had allowed the delicate and precarious balance of the Good Friday/Belfast agreement to slip into the shadows. (same went for the devolution settlements)
Theresa May did raise concerns as Home Secretary during the campaign. But the moment she was PM she drew red lines that made a border problem inevitable - however much she committed to no hard border.
She then made matters worse by her election. Can't blame her for the losses of SDLP/Alliance seats, but she did a desperate deal with the DUP which showed she was willing to sacrifice the UK govt guardian role on the agreement for party gain.
All along the UK underestimated Ireland and EU support for Ireland. Ireland played its diplomatic hand brilliantly, had been thinking through in advance and the EU did not throw a small member state overboard as some here seemed to expect.
To be fair to May, she was forced to wake up to Northern Irish issues and by the time of Chequers, was trying to square the circle of Brexit and her commitments in the island of Ireland. But she ended up impaled on the Irish trilemma.
Boris Johnson made one good decision on Northern Ireland - the appointment of Julian Smith as NI secretary for a few months. But for the rest his government's track record has been pretty shameful as Jonathan sets out.
That is not to say the EU is blameless. The latest list of concessions from the EU show just how little thought through the imposition of an international trade border in a national economy really was.
These could - should - have been negotiated in 2020, before the Protocol took effect. But it was not the EU's Brexit. It was a UK decision to hold a referendum. not to do contingency thinking or planning.
To rush into Article 50 without a clear end point. To set red lines, without working through their implications. To reject all compromises (by both sides) in the hope of getting their pure Brexit/reversal of the decision.
To rush to get any deal to "get Brexit done". To make promises, knowingly exacerbate tensions and to suggest commitments were for mugs. Maybe the government will read Jonathan's piece and rediscover its obligations to all of Northern Ireland.
And maybe if they are watching the Blair/Brown documentary, think what the Northern Ireland episode of a documentary on Brexit might look like in 25 years time. "the hand of history..." ENDS.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Jill Rutter

Jill Rutter Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @jillongovt

18 Oct
Next week Rishi Sunak will deliver his Budget. This week we should finally see @hmtreasury #netzero review. New @instituteforgov report says Chancellor must start talking (publicly) about net zero instituteforgovernment.org.uk/publications/n…
A bit in Budget 2020. Nothing in Budget 2021 or his party conference speech .. but the impacts on revenues from fossil fuels can't be ignored and the system could do a much better job promoting pro-net zero actions
first we need to see the long-awaited review on who pays. but he needs to go further and set out how he will adapt the tax system to support the transition to a #netzero economy.
Read 10 tweets
1 Oct
really interesting from @so_says_sally (and not just cos she quotes me) .. my experience a decade ago from @DefraGovUK was that it was really hard to get @DHSCgovuk out of its health service silo and interested in wider policy
so its great news they are now interested in air quality (they weren't then); we tried to interest DH as was in fuel poverty (hypothermia kills) - no interest. So I think there is scope for depts realising benefits where there are real synergies
the problems for a line dept come where their cross-cutting priority cuts across a departmental priority and they need to persuade it to go in another direction..
Read 4 tweets
23 Sep
the new Levelling Up taskforce under Andy Haldane is interesting for govt structure nerds (and an interesting contrast to govt structures for #netzero) @CommonsBEIS
Haldane is perm sec for 6 months (levelling up will take longer than that .. but first focus will be on working out what this means...) reporting jointly to Michael Gove and the PM.
The people working for him will be (I understand) a joint team from @cabinetofficeuk and the new DLUHC. not cleat how they relate to the delivery unit (but until we know what LU is...they can't do that much)
Read 9 tweets
23 Sep
The latest @UKandEU #Brexitwitnessarchive interview with @AJBMarshall is essential reading for anyone interested in how #brexit impacted govt-business relations (more on that to come from us - watch this space) - he led @britishchambers
On business frustration in the noughties at increasing red tape - but also concern it was not just Brussels to blame Image
.@britishchambers had an impartial stance in the referendum - but that was broken when its Director-General came out for Leave - and catapulted Adam into the leadership Image
Read 22 tweets
15 Sep
so its back to Scotland this week in @UKandEU #Brexitwitnessarchive with an interview with former SNP Europe spokesperson @StephenGethins. Lets pick out some highlights...
we start with the role the debate about Europe played in the 2014 independence referendum
Gethins was elected to Westminster in the SNP sweep in 2015 ... and spoke straight away on the EU referendum..but the govt did not engage at all with the SNP over the terms of that referendum - wonder if David Cameron regrets not taking those amendments?
Read 17 tweets
13 Sep
Interesting to see the outrage at how the govt has gone about deciding the health and social care levy package which suggests people don't understand how tax policy gets made in the UK govt
In a way this was exceptional, because it looks as though this may have been a three way decision, involving the Health Secretary as well... normally any tax decision is a Chancellor-PM bilateral at best
Cabinet not consulted in advance? well at least this time they knew it was under discussion and could have made representations... for a normal Budget they are presented with the fait accompli on the morning when all the docs are printed
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(