Waris Shah was not a cheerleader for invasions by Ahmad Abdali but he certainly has not referred to the latter as "rabid dog of Kabul".

– Thread

The seat of Ahmad Shah Abdali was Qandahar and Waris Shah always refers to him as Qandahari. "Kabuli dogs" gets mention only once in ImageImage
the Heer when he likens a group of aggressive women to the Kabuli bitches (female dogs). Its poetry so it is open to interpretation but he is mostly likely talking about the Kabuli breed of dogs rather than Kabuli women. He certainly is not talking about Ahmad Shah Abdali. ImageImage
He always refers to Ahmad Shah Abdali and his force as Qandahari in his poetry. Screenshots from an Urdu translation of Heer (available on Rekhta website): ImageImage
Punjabi nationalists should refrain from presenting poetry of Waris Shah as words of Quran. Using the same Heer, one can also vilify Punjabis. For example Waris Shah says that all Jats are iman-farosh (ایمان فروش), thieves and high-way robbers. Image
An interesting side fact is that Waris Shah (a Sayyid) considered Sayyids, Mughals as well as Pashtuns as nobility (شرفا) of Punjab. Many of those Pashtuns settled in Punjab, spoke Pashto as evident from his poetry. ImageImage
Note that Waris Shah derisively likens men and women to various kinds of animals through out his poetry. Thats why its almost certain that he is talking about a breed of dogs from Kabul.

Some screenshots from an Urdu translation of Heer in prose form : ImageImageImageImage

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Barmazid برمزید

Barmazid برمزید Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Pashz7

23 Oct
Ahmad Shah Durrani had a high repute in early 19th century.

James Rattrey visited his tomb in 1839 and writes : "The sovereign who sleeps there, called by the Afghauns “the faultless King,” was the greatest monarch their country ever produced. The people of every Eastern nation ImageImage
whether friend or foe, speak still in terms of the greatest admiration of his military skill, his nobleness of heart, clemency, and decision of character. His virtues were as numberless as his victories."

[….]"In addition to his science and military skill, he was fond of study
, and patronised men of learning and piety. In his latter years he was anxious to obtain the character of a saint: in this his Majesty’s wishes have been fulfilled, for his temple is regarded as the very perfection of sanctity, and is resorted to as a place of retirement by
Read 11 tweets
23 Oct
Let me share some details which one cant get from simple google search.

Huzaifa is copying info from a website which has missed a very important detail ; Muqqarab Khan Gakkhar owed allegiance to Ahmad Shah Durrani and was steadfast supporter of Afghans.

(continued) Image
According to Hari Ram Gupta (author of "History of the Sikhs"), Muqarrab Khan Gakkar gave his daughter in marriage to Ahmad Shah Durrani.

Another Gakkhar chief Karam Khan Gakkhar gave one of his daughter in marriage to Shah Wali Khan (the Wazir of Durrani empire) and
another to Jahan Khan Popalzai (the sipah-salar of Durrani empire). (Source: "Tarikh i Gakkharan" by Raja Dahir Zaman, p-311).

Gakkhars sided with Pashtuns when Marathas invaded Punjab. In November 1758 Pashtuns and Gakkhars in concert occupied the Gujarat pargana and crossed
Read 5 tweets
23 Oct
So?. Shuja Shuja Durrani allegedly cutting the manhood of one of his slave does not prove that all Durranis punished their slaves in that manner. You were talking about Adina Beg and Ahmad Shah Abdali, and then you blurted out that all "Durranis" used to do the mentioned Image
acts. You have yet to provide the evidence for your second claim that "Durranis" (Ahmad Shah Abdali, all of his successors, and his entire tribe) used to force their slaves to have sex in front of them for entertainment. I am waiting for it.
Your second screenshot from Dalryample's book says that Fateh Jang allegedly raped soldiers of the garrison. It is not relevant to your original claim that "Durranis" forced their slaves to have sex in front of them for entertainment. I m still waiting.

Read 4 tweets
22 Oct
Waris Shah (Punjabi Muslim poet) has derided Sikhs in his poetry.

Waris Shah says that in 1766-67 AD, Jats (Sikhs) became the chieftains of Punjab. Under their rule, 'Ashrafia' (noble families) were in ruins while lowly people prospered. Thieves became Chauhdris (continued) ImageImage
(headmen of the village), women of bad-character assumed the garbs of righteous, and groups of ill-natured people prospered many times.

The word Waris Shah has used, is Jat but he is definitely talking about Sikhs (who were mostly Jats) here because it were them who had
achieved dominance over much of Punjab in 1767.

Waris Shah has also lamented the fall of Muslim Ashrafia elsewhere :
Read 4 tweets
18 Oct
Sikhs of 18th century considered cow a sacred animal and they killed any Punjabi musalman who dared to slaughter cow and eat its meat.

In 1767 Hira Singh (leader of Nakai misl) received information that Muslims slaughtered cow and ate beef in the territory under Shaikh Subhan
Chishti, the 'Sajjada Nishin' (the hereditary guardian) of the famous shrine of the saint Farid Shakarganj, in Pakpattan. Hira Singh collected a large number of troops and proceeded to Pakpattan to plunder the jagir of Shaikh Subhan and punish its Muslim population.

The news of
the intended attack had reached Shaikh Subhan. He and his men opposed Sikhs at some distance from the Pakpattan town. Hira Singh was hit by a bullet in the head and died instantly. The Sikhs were dispersed with great loss. Shaikh Subhan Chishti pursued them with 4,000 cavalry,
Read 4 tweets
17 Oct
Sikhs owed their rise in 18th century to Adina Beg Arian (a Punjabi Muslim). The latter believed in "chaos is a ladder" and used Sikh marauders to destroy the law & order of Punjab. The suffers of his dangerous games, were none other than his own Punjabi

(Continued in thread)
Muslims. Mughals would have easily exterminated the menace of Sikh marauders but Adina Beg (who was in the service of Mughals) made sure that Sikh marauders were not eliminated.

Some time after the invasion of Nadir Shah Afsar, Zakariya Khan (the Mughal governor of Lahore subah)
appointed Adina Beg as Nazim (governor) of Jalandhar Doab and ordered him to crush the Sikh marauders there who were not powerful at that time. Adina Beg did the opposite, he nurtured the Sikh marauders. James Browne, writing in 1787, says : "The force he (Adina Beg) had him was
Read 28 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(