Good Behaviour vs Bad Kids. Here's one of Robin Grille's summaries of t empirical evidence:
"Contrary to popular myth, many studies show that whn childrn expect rewards, they perform more poorly....Rewards kill creativity. They discourage risk-taking." naturalchild.org/articles/robin…
2. "Rewards and praise condition children to seek approval; they end up doing things to impress, instead of doing things for themselves. This can hold back the development of self-motivation and makes them dependent on outside opinion." naturalchild.org/articles/robin…
3. "Rewarding children's compliance is the flip-side of punishing their disobedience. It is seduction in the place of tyranny. Many studies show that people who use more rewards also use more punishment; they are more likely to be autocratic." naturalchild.org/articles/robin…
4. "Meanwhile, the rewarder is like an assessor, judging what merits praise and what doesn't. This makes them somewhat scary to the child. The use of praise or rewards does not make children feel supported. It makes them feel evaluated and judged." naturalchild.org/articles/robin…
5. "Avoiding praise does not mean holding back the love and delight we feel for our childrn, nor our instinctual desire to encourage them - far from it! It is perfectly possible to join in with our children and celebrate every step of their unfolding, without being manipulative."
6/end. "The way is not to praise children but to APPRECIATE THEM. At school, when the work is made intrinsically interesting, enjoyable, meaningful and relevant, this works better than reward systems to improve both t quality & t commitment to the work." naturalchild.org/articles/robin…
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Why is it sometimes hard for members of professional groups to see how ordinary practices can be harmful to children?
A THREAD that looks back on history for some help.
Why did I want to write it? Well, t @BPSOfficial call for a ban on isolation rooms has sparked disagreement.
2. Many of you will have heard me talk about James Robertson's work in hospitals in 1950s. He was concerned about t common, ordinary policies that separated young children frm parents. He was so concerned, he made a film to help ppl see. Here's t trailer.
3. It was ordinary, accepted practice to restrict children from seeing parents until 'visiting times', which were often only on a Saturday. Children cried intensely for their parents. Eventually they would stop. The staff saw 'settling'. Robertson saw 'emotional deterioration'.
I was awake too early this morn, the stories I’ve been hearing circling uncomfortably around my head. What are they stories of? How our exhaustion & fear is leading us to damage young children. A THREAD on BEING BRAVE and SAYING NO.
(2) Story 1: A mum carries background worry all day at her work abt her beloved 1-year-old, because she has never seen inside the nursery where her baby now spends her day. Never even *seen* it. I wonder: How many other mums & dads are coping with the same disorienting worry?
(3) Story 2: Children are dropped off on a busy high street, next to traffic. T risk of COVID is deemed to make it too dangerous for them to come inside. I think: Okay, so the toughest moment of every day for these children is taking place amidst sensory onslaught.
New THREAD on authoritarianism & attitudes toward children.
I woke to enthusiasm frm many of you abt my thread yesterdy on this topic, so I thought I might expand on it. I believe that understandng these links helps give depth & sense to much of what is happening in our society.
2. Here is ystrdy's thread.
The most essential thing I say in it is: Fight fear.
The second most essential thing is: Adults hold beliefs about how children shd 'be'. Those beliefs are related to their sense of threat.
(Yes, that can feel surprisng.)
3. Stanley Feldman is a leading political science researcher. Here is his 2020 paper, drawing on data frm 1763 Americns in 2016. His key conclusn: t more authoritarian a person is (more controlling of children), t more intolerance & threat they feel. stanleyfeldman.site44.com/Feldman_Author…
The link between childhood & authoritarianism. A THREAD -
because there is more & more talk about the rise in authoritarianism in British culture & I think it is important to recognise the links with parenting styles.
2. Political Scientist Stephen Feldman has done classic research on authoritarianism. He argues that "authoritarian predispositions originate in t conflict betwn t values of social conformity &personal autonomy."
COVID conflicts are rich breeding grounds. jstor.org/stable/3792510
3. So how do you measure 'authoritarian predispositions'? (Note: I find the answer unnerving.) It turns out to be simple. You ask 4 questns :
Do you think it is more important for a child to: 1) have independence or respect for elders? 2) have obedience or self-reliance?...
When childcare becomes about the money rather than the care. A THREAD.
I've done some digging on this harmful govt proposal to alter ratios from 1adult:3babies to 1adult:5babies. I thought I'd share with you all what I found.
2. Can I begin early by linking to the recent post from @Dr2NisreenAlwan & @IanLaveryMP showing our Prime Minister stating explicitly that what matters in policy is what is profitable, not what makes life worthwhile. "Most important metric: wage growth."
3. OK. A 'research report' was released Oct 2020 by the Dept for Educ (Eng & Wales) entitled: "Occupancy & staff ratios at early years providers". Conducted by the 'Govt National Centre for Social Research'. Based on figures before the pandemic. assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/upl…
WHY is it hard for many men to appreciate women's terror? WHY is #NotAllMen trendng this morn re #SarahEverard ? A THREAD.
I write it because I believe that once you can MAKE SENSE of confusng things, they stop being so distressng &exhaustng. You're better placed to tackle them.
2. If you aren't a feminist theorist or writer or reader, it is easy to miss how far back &how widely spread t discountng of women's experience is, in deference to men's. Seeing ths breadth is hard, gut-wrenchng. But SEEING it helped me make sense.I was more effective w/ my rage.
3. Here is t result of my attmpt to SEE, co-written 21 yrs ago. Most ppl think of me as a 'baby psychologist'. They don't know I wrote a feminist text abt The Male Norm. But I did. (It helped me understnd even more t importnce of caring for our childrn.) Let me give some quotes.