To give myself as much grief as I dole out: I should have taken more seriously the point I made, late last year, about the need for people to see amends made after a hellish 2020.
BBB is not some giveaway. It’s an apology for the failure to provide a functioning nation-state.
@zachdcarter nails this in a piece he’s adapted for the Atlantic. Public-health arguments for keeping schools closed for much of 2020 were sound — but the results were punishing & traumatic. theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/…
Is it fair to hold Dems accountable for Republicans’ refusal to take the pandemic seriously in its early stages, which locked in extended school closures & a horrific death toll? No. To blame teachers? No.
But does it make sense to means test what amounts to an apology? Also no.
(A postscript: I don’t care for much of the popularist critique of ‘progressive staffers’ — but a progressive sector whose workplace norms made more room for parents & the non-affluent might have had a better read on how much stress the school closures caused.)
(* Not lumping Patrick in with the popularists, to be clear. I’m in full agreement with him.)
Sargent: “One plausible explanation, suggested by Zachary Carter, is that generalized parental anxieties about school closures and their rocky reopening sparked anger at Democrats.”
(To resurface a line of thought I’ve shared, it seems bass-ackwards to blame teachers for a societal failure to take the measures needed to curb the spread of the virus or invest in making classrooms safe. But here we are, nevertheless.)
“We were so willing to take seriously a global pandemic, but we’re not willing to say, ‘Yeah, inflation is a problem, and supply chain is a problem, and we don’t have enough workers in our work force.’”
Thing #1: Can we name what Dems in the WH and Congress should have done to immediately solve the chip shortage?
Hell: part of the shortage results from the failure of Texas to keep the lights on last winter, ruining countless chips in mid-production. Biden’s fault? How?
Thing #2: A huge purpose of the Build Back Better agenda is to help people get back into the work force by providing crucial supports: child care, home care, and so on.
Maybe it’s a better use of a Dem representative’s time to lay into the Dems on the Hill blocking that?
It seems seems strange, TBH, to expect voters to make the GOP pay a price for Trump or Jan. 6 when Democrats in government seem sluggish — if not outright diffident and unenthused — about extracting one. How many months did the party blow seeking a bipartisan 1/6 panel, again?
How many months did Dems in Congress fritter away seeking Republican stewardship of an investigation into their own party, which precipated 1/6? How many leading Dems have offered — still offer — paeans to bipartisan cooperation with the GOP, the party of Trump and 1/6?
Like I said this AM, McAuliffe swept a field of hopefuls to his left— including a real-deal democratic socialist. The party fell into line, as it reliably has in Virginia for as long as I’ve lived here.
Whatever happened tonight, don’t put it on progressives. It ain’t our doing.
What Youngkin and the Va. GOP did this year is a light update of the Trump playbook: floating and propelling a storyline that meshes with the candidate’s narrative (‘her emails’), and relying on the use of official/gov’t platforms (see, e.g., the below) … vox.com/2015/9/30/9423…
… partisan media orgs, and stochastic outrage to perpetuate that storyline without a campaign spending heavily for paid media to put that storyline across.
The ‘critical race theory’ panic is essentially the upscale companion brand of ‘Great Replacement’ talk. It gives those trying to mobilize people who see themselves as part of the gentry, rather than the rabble, a way to dress racialized fear in safe, khaki-and-fleece garb.
That reality explains why we see the likes of Sully fanning the flames of ‘critical race theory’ panic—and why Fox constantly switches between serving up lite, easier-going CRT messaging on its dayside & Tucker’s uncut white-nationalist rhetoric at night. mediamatters.org/white-national…
Both lines of racialized nonsense share the same root fear: that some radical other is imposing a foreign culture or mode of thought on our children, and ‘we’ need to stop it. See what Sully wrote again: