"The first scientist to question the discovery was Vincent Racaniello, He said the fragment might have come from a mixed virus with pieces of the MERS virus in it, or even from something the bat ate."
41. Kawaoka & MERS
I learned of Kawaoka's reckless violations from Robert Finnegan, former editor of Jakarta Post, who was tracking theft of MERS & other viruses from NAMRU-2 by a senior lab technician who smuggled the dangerous materials to Wisconsin Uni
Lineage C coronaviruses like HKU5 MERS and HKU4 uses the DPP4 receptor. the furin site of HKU5 is ancestral (not "acquired") and MERS obtained it via 2 snp changing a HKU4 serine into an arginine.
Lela Urishadze, Zoonotic pathogens and their molecular epidemiological characteristics in Georgian bats, Dissertation, Ilia State University, Tbilisi, Georgia, 2018)
"Potentially the WIV may have been attempting to swap in the MERS-CoV spike gene using targeted RNA recombination (Masters and Rottier, 2005) or perhaps experimenting with a pseudotyped MERS-CoV spike vector"
3. That is a significant claim
"the WIV appears to have been simultaneously using a HKU4r-CoV backbone for independent research"
So while doing EHA NIH funded work, at the same time they were "experimenting" with the reverse!
"Viral isolates will remain at the Wuhan Institute of Virology initially. Isolates, reagents and any other
products, will be made available to other NIH-funded researchers via applicable WIV and EHA Material Transfer Agreements and/or icensing agreements"
3. Cells (Page 203)
• Records are maintained for each of the cell lines regarding 1. the origin of the cell lines 2. when they were resuscitated 3. number of passages 4. all test results 5. any unique distinguishing growth behavior 6. any known genetic features.
2. we believe a more transparent and comprehensive system of reporting biological incidents to a neutral third party would help reduce the number of laboratory incidents
3. it could be broadened to include all kinds of incident data. In our opinion, an international version of such a reporting system would also help reduce the number and severity of laboratory incidents, both locally and worldwide
"JP Chretien is a Navy doctor & Program Manager at the DARPA, in the Biological Technologies Office. Previously, JP led the Pandemic Warning mission in the Department of Defense"
The database contains information for geographical distribution, ecological status, species traits, and parasites and hyperparasites for 679 bat species known to occur in caves or use caves in their life histories.
"LAOS PI or Co-Investigators to conduct field
trip to assess markets, identify wildlife in them & arrange for shipment of bats and other high-risk host species to WIV Laboratory in China"