1. CDS. While Navy and Airforce continued with their progressive training since 1990, Army was completely consumed in Counter Insurgency. It shifted its assembly line of producing generals to CI. A Lieutenant in 1990 is a Maj Gen/Lt Gen today. We have product of CI all over.
2. CDS. We have the Army Commanders and Chief who were Captains in 1989-85, and the only lot commissioned prior to CI that started in 1990. They have spent their service from Major to Lt Gen/General in CI. The upward mobility was provided by CI or commanding a Strike Corps.
3. CDS. Focusing on CI. All one has to do is to list out every Lt Gen promoted from 2001 to date and simply see their Command. Command of unit, Brigade, Division and Corps. 99% earned their ranks due to Counter Insurgency. They invested in CI industry.
4. CDS. Now take the Strike Corps. 1971-2020 was spent on two fronts. Invest in CI for promotions or create Pakistan phobia while ignoring China. Eyes were closed when it came to China. Result? THREE Strike Corps, all three for Pakistan front that too limited to plains.
5. CDS. Investment was in high decibel exercised like Brasstacks, total show-biz and keeping Armoured and Mech in centre. While Infantry grabbed CI, the Armoured Corps latched on to Strike Corps. The swag decided the threat. Each kept eyes closed to China with just one exception.
6. CDS. Result? A. No one ever spoke of two front war. B. Pre 71 Army dealt with two Pak fronts and executed a two front war, we forgot. C. China was conveniently tucked in backyard and any posting on China border was such a low career option. D. No unified structure of command
7. CDS. in China front. E. No strategy to handle China. F. No dedicated command for China. G. No Strike Corps for China. H. Practically China was made invisible by Army till Galwan jolt. WHO DID THIS? The Counter Insurgency & Strike Corps generation on assembly line since 90’s
8. CDS. No one ever wrote on Two Front War with China and Pakistan. No war games. No brain storming. No suggestion to convert one of the three strike corps for China. The Generals burdened Govt with Mountain Strike Corps a decade back. It requires in excess of a lac Cr.
9. CDS. Now soon as CDS selection comes, this short sighted Counter Insurgency generation feels they are best for the job. How? Track record? It will take 20 to 30 years for Army to produce a visionary CDS ONLY if the reset meter to promote merit. Till the time it’s CI and Strike
10. CDS. Corps, don’t expect any change. I have been writing extensively on RADICAL MILITARY REFORMS, which actually reset the systems to promote merit in army. Today Army promotes Infantry and Armoured only. Rest are support. You reap what you sow. Navy and Airforce need
11. CDS. need to alternate CDS for at least two decades while Army refocuses on conventional war on two fronts. While the three services focus on these issues, the Government needs to focus on the THIRD FRONT WAR. Quietly the enemy has opened tge third front. THE ENEMY WITHIN
12. CDS. Govt, Media, Political parties, bureaucracy, social media, ministries, fintech, IT and every possible sector has been targeted by enemy and Indians, in position of authority, are promoting pro-China narrative. The Govt needs to immediately start fighting the War on
13. CDS. on Third Front. This Govt has fallen in trap set by the third front enemy. CDS hence, must be used as a tool to get the country out of this war. We need a much bigger forum of which CDS must be a member. Trade War, Legal War, Media War and it goes on.
14. CDS. Last. Petty minded people who promote Counter Insurgency or such easy rank race oriented operations must stay away from these debates that involve our existence. @PMOIndia @AmitShah @rajnathsingh
15. CDS. Before giving the country an impression of being competent to hold the position, Army must spend two decades to set things right. THIRTY YEARS of Counter Insurgency has produced offrs whose vision is limited to a Company & Battalion AOR. It is carried to highest ranks

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Col Sanjay Pande (Retd)

Col Sanjay Pande (Retd) Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ColSanjayPande

12 Dec 21
1/n @nudelhilawfora Sir, There is a trend when a veteran passes away, his erstwhile service directorate or Regiment publishes an obituary in newspapers. It is always from ‘Director General Regiment of xxx’ or numerous such HQs. What is the need? They left forces many years back!
2/n It is now strictly followed. Pick up any news paper and you can see it on daily basis. Only Officers deaths get an obituary. Is it not a very deeply distressing exercise? Why doesn’t @adgpi stop this practice? Soldiers fade away, but these directorates play with emotions.
3/n No one questions them. Selective obituaries keep popping up in newspapers. These directorates have no clue where and in what state the Veterans and Widows live. They are absolutely clueless but must suddenly rise to pay random tributes to ‘deceased officers’.
Read 17 tweets
24 Nov 21
1. #ArmChairGenerals How many remember Republic Day 2016 when 50 “highly decorated” Lieutenant Generals of the Indian Army were conferred awards for ‘distinguished service’. Ironically,the majority of them were based either in Delhi or in peace posts. READ newindianexpress.com/thesundaystand…
2. #ArmChairGenerals It has become absolutely customary to ‘distribute’ these ‘arm chair’ awards after a person attains a Maj Gen or equivalent rank. It goes by seniority, Command Stream, Lanyard, Rank, Residual Service, Blue Eyes, I mean anything. Each has an entire HQ of staff.
3. #ArmChairGenerals The ‘Staff’ is highly qualified and gets posted on merit. Each looks after his portfolio independently, each senior staffs career progress depends on Generals pen. A Maj Gen practically has no task since forces have absolutely drawn on concrete procedures.
Read 8 tweets
19 Nov 21
1. #IndiaChina Chinese villages, construction, activity and frenzy on Indian side all displays only one aspect, ‘shallowness of our knowledge’ and ‘fear of facts’. Have we ever kept finger on where the problem started? Nehru. Has BJP been….
2. #IndiaChina able to convince India of what went wrong, who is to blame and why 1962 war was avoidable? BJP cannot since the overuse of ‘Nehru’ in any and every ill India faces has brought this serious topic of China to a stage where the inheritance is sinking BJPs credibility
3. #IndiaChina The facts are, 1. Today’s state is due to Nehru 2. BJP has a golden chance to correct everything. 3. BJP has not even one leader or military advisor who has knowledge and courage to bring it to notice. 4. Never have yes men brought this to such a low level.
Read 9 tweets
9 Nov 21
1. #OROP I read lot of tweets on #OROP. Generally the pattern is same. There is a case pending in SC for which I heard in Oct 2020 or so that final date of hearing is to be given by SC. Each time next date is given assigning no reason. Yesterday, again, fresh date was given.
2. #OROP To assume SC is too tight for dates is like gulping quinine without making face. Come over to other side. Veterans. Very imp to read a thread on #MentalHealth and Stupidity of Crowds 👇🏻👇🏻before you read my thread. On Social Media, all veterans are expected to abuse Modi.
3. #OROP Mr Modi & his entire ‘force multipliers’ scream ‘hamne OROP diya’, in the other side there is a case in Supreme Court, which, miraculously, does not get the ‘final’ date since one year. It’s ‘Daya, kuch to gadbad hai’ scenario. My issue is NOT Govt or SC, it is Veterans.
Read 84 tweets
15 Aug 21
1/n #VOICE
15 AUGUST 2021: MAKING LIFE OF VETERAN SOLDIERS AND FORCES WIDOWS RESPECTABLE
colsanjaypande.com/15-aug-2021-vo…

VOICE – Veterans Of India for Constructive Engagement
2/n #VOICE
15 AUGUST 2021: MAKING LIFE OF VETERAN SOLDIERS AND FORCES WIDOWS RESPECTABLE

VOICE
-is what we should do for our own soldiers and armed forces widows
-is what we should have done but never did
-is what we have lost, we lost our voice.
3/n #VOICE
15 AUGUST 2021: MAKING LIFE OF VETERAN SOLDIERS AND FORCES WIDOWS RESPECTABLE

WE OWE IT TO THE SOLDIERS

I owe it to them

DO YOU?

VOICE will constructively engage every government agency and the core strength is INCLUSIVITY. Will you push it?

YOU ARE “VOICE”
Read 20 tweets
15 Aug 21
1. The STRONGEST OPPOSITION is from VETERANS ON ROLLS OF ALL BANKS DISBURSING PENSIONS. Shocked? Each bank employs Veterans of Ranks Retd Lt Generals as in SBI, Major Generals and Brigadiers to head their Defence Departments. These are high paying kushi jobs.
2. Senior most Veteran in these banks sits in the Corporate HQ, hires his lower hierarchy from retired officers. The perks and salary is excellent besides pension. Car, Rent, Loans etc. is a dream job. Their task? GET AS MANY PENSIONERS as possible. Extend loans and increase biz.
3. Banks CHARGE Ministry of Defence Rs 800/- per pensioners account. Each has a ‘Centralised Pension Processing Centre’ e.g. Bank of India in Nagpur, SBI in Belapur etc. If a bank disburses One lac pensions, it earns Rs 8 Cr from MoD budget. 34 lac pensioners of MoD.
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(