Johnson looks weirdly cheerful after his performative lament yesterday. Something has certainly picked him up.
Starmer beaming even more broadly. Welcomes the new Labour MP for Bury South. This is a genuine triumph for him.
Jokes that Tory MPs must have been told to bring their own booze.
Starmer, clearly enjoying himself, rattles through Johnson’s changing defences on partygate. Johnson has shed all of last week’s contrition and starts banging on for no particular reason about Covid restrictions, lying that Labour advocated lockdown.
Johnson knows he’s fighting for his life. Starmer though now getting serious again. Says that Johnson’s answer last week sounded as though a lawyer had written it. Johnson responds with more boilerplate about Sue Gray.
Starmer mocks that answer. Asks whether Sue Gray will now tell him when he first heard about the party. His tactic this week is to make this sound more ridiculous than grave, but that also takes the sting out of the questions.
Johnson now chatting shit about Starmer’s beer and repeats the lie about the European Medicines Agency.
Johnson hilariously accuses Starmer of wasting parliament’s time.
‘I know it’s not going well prime minister but at least the staff at No 10 know how to pack a suitcase.’ 💣
Starmer now asks about the apology to the Queen. Absurd back and forth as the Speaker says MPs don’t discuss the Royal Family.
Starmer lands some blows in his final question but he’s lost his momentum. Johnson delivers a hysterical stump speech in reply. After last week’s high drama this session has felt more like a children’s party - a lot of sugar and laughter but not much in the way of substance.
Johnson needed to deliver a belter and that was probably as good as he could have hoped for. He clearly feels he has nothing to apologise for. Doubt this will allay many MPs’ concerns but may deter waverers from sending more letters today.
The most serious contribution from Blackford: ‘150,000 citizens have died and he parties and laughs.’
Blackford asks when Tory MPs will do the right thing - to be fair, a question many people have been asking for the last 300 years
Diana Johnson correctly asks whether, when the PM’s excuse is that he is stupid rather than dishonest, it is time to go.
I believe not one person has yet asked a question about potential war in Ukraine, which is as damning an indictment as any
Oof. David Davis saves the best for last. Quotes Leo Amery: ‘You have sat too long here for any good you have been doing. In the name of God, go.’
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
At some point we’ll have to confront the culture of ‘open secrets’ that everyone seems to know about and nobody ever publishes.
There’s been a recent explosion in stories about public figures that were brushed under the carpet for years. #MeToo was an obvious one. But it’s the tip of the iceberg.
Part of it is Britain’s ferocious libel laws. Part of it is the establishment’s existential drive to preserve its own power. But it is utterly corrosive.
Johnson apologises. Says he’s learned there are things they didn’t get right. Went into the garden to ‘thank’ people. Believed it was a work event. Rarely seen him look so serious. I guess it’s because for the first time he’s dealing with his own fate and not other people’s #PMQs
It changes absolutely nothing. It wasn’t a work event. He knew it wasn’t. And a week later he threw all his political capital at saving Cummings in a desperate attempt to save his own skin.
My new year’s resolution is not to turn the other cheek when established friends or romantic partners ghost me
This week I challenged a good friend who’d blanked me for months and the sheer arseholery of their reply made me laugh out loud
There’s a serious point. This is meant to be the age of not taking shit from people. And yet when someone close ghosts you you’re supposed to give a free pass. If you challenge them you become the problem - uncool, needy, crazy. It’s not OK. Normalise confronting bad behaviour!
Johnson trying to take initiative by apologising for the clip and pretending he was ‘infuriated’ by it. Somehow doubt that will cut it. #PMQs
This, if anything, should make us even angrier. Johnson knew exactly what happened, and knew what he was doing when he spent all week lying through his teeth. He’s coming clean now because he got caught. The end.
Johnson saying people should focus on what’s happening with Covid now, as though this is a matter of historical interest. Starmer notes the current situation requires moral authority and the prime minister doesn’t have any.
Starmer going on the Downing Street Christmas party last year. Johnson doesn’t deny it and deflects by asking a question about Starmer’s party this year. Starmer reads him the government’s own rules from the time. This could quickly get interesting. #PMQs
Johnson desperate to talk about the rules *right now*. He has not denied that he held a Christmas party last year, which was in direct contravention of his own lockdown rules.
Starmer twists the knife by pointing out his own MPs not following the current rules on masks. Ties it in with his ‘one rule for us, another for them’ line of attack. This could and should be a story. #PMQs
I know the reshuffle has divided opinion but I think it’s been broadly positive. Cooper’s one of Labour’s only genuine big hitters and carries more gravitas than anyone in the government. Lammy as foreign sec a great fit. Nandy in the role she should have had from the start.
Of course Cooper is further to the right on immigration than many of us would like, but that’s where Labour is right now and Patel won’t stand a chance against her. But bizarre to relegate Thornberry and sideline Miliband. Labour needs all the star performers it can get.
Interesting too to look at some of the promotions lower down. Bridget Phillipson has been quietly devastating when attacking gov’s cruelty to children and should flourish at education. Streeting should be effective at health, but that job ought to have Allin-Khan’s name on it.