Henry Farrell Profile picture
Feb 2 17 tweets 4 min read
1. Today's the 100th anniversary of the publication of Ulysses. Like many Irish people, I'm related to a minor character in the book. "Professor MacHugh" in the Aeolus episode is based on my great-granduncle Hugh McNeill, an alcoholic reprobate who died in a workhouse.
2. This provides by far the most complete account of his life that I've seen jjon.org/jioyce-s-peopl…. Hugh came from an ambitious family in Glenarm in Antrim. Their father owned a baker's shop. According to family memories, one brother, Archie, left for Canada under a cloud
3. (apparently having stolen money from the business - his children tried to re-establish contact a generation later but rigid attachment to proprieties meant they got a cold shoulder). Charles joined the civil service, retired early, and lived for decades on a dwindling pension.
4. James joined the Indian Civil Service, was promoted quickly, dropped out of sight for a couple of years (I've meant for years to go to India House to see if there are any records of the story why) and became Governor General of Ireland for a period after independence
5. My great-grandfather, John (Eoin) became involved in the Irish language revival and nationalist, and played a controversial part in the Easter Rising (trying to stop it) and the Boundary Commission between the Saorstat and Northern Ireland. Hugh was the black sheep.
6. Like Eoin, he became an academic, but he didn't take well to it, occupying temporary positions, and eventually ending up destitute. In Ulysses, he is depicted hanging around a newspaper office, pontificating about how the Irish were like the Greeks, and the English like Romans
7. builders of an empire that was "vast" but "vile," governed by a "cloacal obsession," building toilets wherever they went (Joyce put words in MacHugh's mouth to score a point off H.G. Wells - m.joyceproject.com/notes/070020cl… ). The real Hugh MacNeill became a hanger-on in slow stages.
8. He started as a "tutor" in Latin at University College Dublin, briefly being styled a professor without actually holding a chair. His position seems to have been tenuous and temporary, reflecting a combination of real intelligence with testiness and unreliability.
9. He also worked as an examiner in Latin, and set up as a private tutor for a little while, and edited the journal of the Gaelic League (which had been founded by Eoin and Douglas Hyde).
10. But he was chronically short of money, looking to his brothers to bail him out. According to the memories of my grandmother, he had problems with gambling and alcohol. He wasn't able to maintain steady employment, and began hanging around in newspaper offices, as per Ulysses.
11. In 1913, he was imprisoned for debt. The Rising and War of Independence caused further tumult (Eoin lost his professorship while in prison; Hugh's son (also Hugh) was imprisoned too (he later played an important role in the Free State Army - dib.ie/biography/mcne… )
12. Hugh senior became estranged from his family and ended up falling ill and dying in a workhouse (stories - apparently untrue - circulated that he had been found dead in a telephone booth).
13. By no reasonable measure could Hugh MacNeill's life be considered a successful one. His early promise was never fulfilled. His family life was tumultuous and bitter, and he died in squalid circumstances. But he achieved a minor measure of immortality that few of us will have.
14. A tangential post script, on the "cloacal obsession." My grandmother Eilis, who passed down what family memories I have, married a man with no great fondness for the English. One evening, when she tried to get him to go out to dinner with an English couple, he tried to refuse
15. Claiming that all the other couple would do would be to "talk about their bowels." Eventually he was prevailed upon to attend, grudgingly and with many imprecations. After they had gotten there, the conversation turned at some point to a recent move the other couple had made.
16. And one of the other couple remarked that the wonderful water in the new place meant that they were "ever so much more regular" than they had been before. My grandfather, beaming with sheer delight, kept them going on the topic for a long while.
17. And after they got home, my grandmother reportedly refused to speak to him in sentences of more than one word for two days. Of such minor engagements, victories and defeats are marriages made.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Henry Farrell

Henry Farrell Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @henryfarrell

Jan 15
That Amazon weaponizes this popularity so as to politically reinforce its monopoly power is a not unimportant consideration when one wants to weigh up the pros and cons pure.mpg.de/rest/items/ite…
One crude - but nonetheless useful - understanding of contemporary US capitalism is to see it as a tacit alliance between consumers and monopolists against workers. If your universal metric of general wellbeing is consumer welfare, then that looks like a good thing.
If, alternatively, you are worried about power imbalances in the economy and distributional outcomes, that looks considerably more problematic. bloomberg.com/news/features/…
Read 8 tweets
Oct 20, 2021
1. I'm really pleased about this webcast conversation- stanford.zoom.us/webinar/regist… with @zephoria @billjaneway @cmcilwain @zeynep, Marion Fourcade and me. It's part of @CASBSStanford project on moral political economy, and a forthcoming @DaedalusJournal special issue.
2. What Marion and I are contributing is a piece on what we call "High Tech Modernism." It will be part of the special issue (which @margaretlevi and I are editing), and we're excited to see it going out into the world (draft is available at dropbox.com/s/3wy36804jhlc… ).
3. The idea behind it is pretty simple, but, we think, useful. James Scott has famously written about the "High Modernism" of the 19th and 20th century - the process of bureaucratic categorization and information collection that reshaped the world and made it "legible."
Read 15 tweets
Sep 21, 2021
1. There are a lot of people in political science today complaining that John Eastman is speaking at APSA 2021 and suggesting APSA should do something about it. My opinions of Eastman and his memo are exactly what you'd expect given my past writing washingtonpost.com/outlook/a-cyni… But ...
2. The complaints - if they are more than just popcorn throwing, don't seem particularly deeply thought out. I say this as someone who has co-chaired an APSA meeting in the past but has no current role in the organization beyond membership and is speaking purely as an individual.
3. The first point is that APSA-as-an-organization has much less power over who does or does not attend its meetings than people seem to believe. There are some theme panels that the chairs can put together, and other places where there is a little wriggle room ...
Read 16 tweets
Aug 6, 2021
1. A thread on this comparison by @michaelbd of Orban's Hungary with De Valera's Ireland nationalreview.com/2021/08/hungar…. As said earlier, I don't think that the comparison works. Here's why- for the huge audience for 20th century Irish history/ 21st century Hungary politics crossovers.
2. Dougherty's argument is that Orban - like De Valera - is the leader of a small country trying to preserve itself in the face of a big hostile world. And that explains much of Orban's strategy and his appeal. There are some things that explains - but much more that it does not.
3. First - as Dougherty says, Orban is genuinely popular, as Dev was. And he could go further. One reason for Dev's success was that he offered a different and more populist conservatism as an alternative to the then frugal "Treasury View" type Cumann na nGaedheal government.
Read 21 tweets
Aug 2, 2021
1. A thread, responding to a series of complaints about political science by @BrankoMilan which seem to me to be generally quite wrong-headed. Note before beginning - while I've only the most tenuous personal acquaintance with him, I think his work is very good and use it.
2. This round of complaints started with the suggestion that political scientists were caught "totally flat-footed when Piketty produced a slew of cross-country data showing the transformation of labor parties into the parties of an educated elite."
3. That followed a tweet a few months previous, complaining that political scientists did not seem interested in studying "comparative democracy & voting patterns" outside 20 odd developed countries. Both tweets provoked howls of outrage
Read 25 tweets
May 25, 2021
1. So this went up yesterday - preposterousuniverse.com/podcast/2021/0… - and I'm very happy with it - @seanmcarroll questions and sense of how the various arguments pulled together meant that I sound far more coherent than I usually feel.
2. As noted in the interview, anything genuinely intelligent-sounding that I said should likely be attributed to the co-authors whom I am leaning on heavily throughout. We discussed work with Cosma Shalizi, with @hugoreasoning and Melissa Schwartzberg, and with Marion Fourcade .
3. Also, by sheer coincidence (the interview took place a couple of months ago), we talked about the main themes of a report by @schneierblog and I that @SNFAgoraJHU published yesterday on the current state of American democracy. It's here - snfagora.jhu.edu/publication/re…
Read 11 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

:(