LawBeat Profile picture
Feb 8 26 tweets 11 min read
#SupremeCourt to continue hearing a batch of petitions challenging provision of Prevention of Money Laundering Act.
#PMLA
#MoneyLaundering
Senior Advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi appearing for the petitioner- In terms of the act: Use, Projecting and Claiming it to be untainted are three heads, without your Lordships finding these three heads it would be stretching of an offence to bring Money Laundering.
Singhvi: To suggest it to be diluted (the three heads) would not be a correct way of interpreting it.
#PMLA
#MoneyLaundering
Singhvi- The entire uniqueness of the PMLA is the entire heart and soul of the Money Laundering and you cannot presume the heart and soul.
#PMLA
Justice CT Ravikumar: If there is some money that is proceeds of crime and he uses it, then projecting and Claiming will be one part.

Singhvi- Yes, Milords.

#PMLA
#MoneyLaundering
Singhvi: A draconian approch in this Act should not be allowed.
#PMLA
#MoneyLaundering
Singhvi: I'm pressing for complete striking down but there is an alternative for your Lordships to decide.
Where the ED can search place or person without an FIR in the predicate offence, alternatively without doing any investigation on the mere registration of FIR it can search.
Singhvi- The issue of Section 5, the core point is here that the second proviso to 5(1) is either completely unconstitutional or significantly read down. It allows emergency attachment of any property of any person without reference or anchoring to any particular case.
#PMLA
Singhvi- The most important area where it is abused, X has a property and he has this property for 20 years, the FIR of predicate offence registered now today, on what basis the ED proceeds that 20 year old house shall be attached. TC (Crl) 4/2018 it is the direct case.
#PMLA
Singhvi- Milords You are frustrating proceedings under this act.
#PMLA
I'll be coming on the point of value, if a property is of 200 Crores and the offence is of 10 Lakhs they will attach the property to that value but effectively nobody will touch that property, Singhvi added.
Singhvi- Another point is that provisos can never travel beyond the section and the act but in this case it travels beyond the Act also. (The proviso be read in relation to the rule or section to which they are tagged as a proviso)

#PMLA
#MoneyLaundering
Singhvi while referring to a judgment of Justice Krishna Iyer, before joining the profession I used to write for a legal weekly and he liked article so much that he wrote me a letter and I had to take it to my father to understand it as he wrote it in such a flourishing language.
Justice Khanwilkar- We'll continue at 2:00 PM.
Singhvi continues arguing over The issue of taking possession without any adjudication, we are not talking about attachment right now, we are talking about possession without adjudication, it's at the threshold.
#PMLA
#MoneyLaundering
It amounts to takeover of valuable property right with one statutory confirmation. There is no temporal limit to it, the possession may continue till 365 days even if the chargesheet is filed earlier, and may continue beyond 365 days if it is not filed, Singhvi added.
#PMLA
Singhvi argued that, you are attaching property for a moment let's not go into that, but you are taking possession also, what will be more draconian than this.
#PMLA
#MoneyLaundering
Singhvi- It is exceeding the limits of proportionality, you have enough safeguards then why do you require this draconian possession.
#PMLA
#MoneyLaundering
Justice Dinesh Maheshwari- If these are proceeds of crime why that would be allowed to be used at all.

Singhvi- Yes but what is the purpose of keeping it idle for 3 years. Can't it be tailored.

#PMLA
#MoneyLaundering
Singhvi- In 90% of the cases there is no interest of the government that I can see, in operating factories, living houses...the only interest is that there should be size so that in case of conviction, confiscation can happen.
#PMLA
#MoneyLaundering
Justice Khanwilkar- There is inbuilt mention in section 8 until the trial is over there is no confiscation and without possession the property cannot be confiscated.
#PMLA
#MoneyLaundering
Singhvi- Milords this possession is unconstitutional unless such possession is shown that it is necessary.

J Khanwilkar- So you are saying it has to be in rarest of rare case the possession is taken.

Singhvi- Exactly, it has to be an rare exception.
#PMLA
#MoneyLaundering
Singhvi- Now I have section 45 for last 45 minutes.
#PMLA
#MoneyLaundering
Singhvi- The maximum punishment for PMLA is 7 years and with an exception to NDPS it is 10 years, Your Lordships has more draconian provisions in IPC and other laws.
#PMLA
#MoneyLaundering
Singhvi- Look at the injustice of extreme nature, when the act was passed some alignment would have been done. There are several bailable offences and when they come into PMLA it is barred. This is manifestly arbitrary. The PMLA crime cannot be more serious than of original crime
J Khanwilkar- we'll continue tomorrow only 5 minutes are left.

Singhvi- I'll only take 15 minutes tomorrow.

The matter will be taken up at 10:30 AM tomorrow.

#PMLA
#MoneyLaundering

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with LawBeat

LawBeat Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @LawBeatInd

Feb 8
Senior Advocate Nakul Dewan appearing for amazon mentions Amazon matter stating that, we wish to file brief written submissions.
CJI- You want to complicate matter we have no issue, order is ready now you want to file affidavit, we'll have to issue notice we'll also give opportunity to other side.
I don't understand what is this practice.

Senior Advocate KV Viswanathan submits Milords we are opposing.
CJI- Mr Viswanathan you are for the other side, if you want to file, you also file.

CJI- It's a luxurious litigation it appears.
How many pages is going to be?

Dewan- 7 pages.

CJI- 7 pages in a small matter.
Read 4 tweets
Feb 8
Delhi High Court will today start hearing a batch of petitions demanding registration of first information reports (FIRs) against several politicians for their role in instigating the #DelhiRiots.
Sr. Adv. Colin Gonsalves for one of the petitioners: We have submitted a compilation.

#DelhiRiots
HC: There are prayers like provide food etc to affected families, ensure protection and safety of affected families of #DelhiRiots, these are not relevant anymore.
Read 49 tweets
Feb 8
#Karnataka High Court to hear case of Resham Farooq, filed through her brother seeking relief on account of alleged denial by the Government PU college for 8 girl students allegedly on account of wearing Hijab before a bench of Justice Krishna Dixit #KarnatakaHijabRow
Devdatt Kamat, Sr.Adv requests for listing of fresh writ petition which was moved yesterday challenging the GO. Court permits for listing of this matter with other similar matters . #KarnatakaHijabRow #karnatakahijab
AG for #Karnataka says he is ready to argue #KarnatakaHijabRow
Abhishek Janardhan counsel for petitioner: I seek for a short date for matter milords as there are other cases coming.
J
ustice Dixit: The quantity of matters does not matter,if we decide one matter, the rest is good
Read 108 tweets
Feb 7
BREAKING: The District and Sessions Court, Haridwar has granted bail to Yati Narsinghanand, the head priest of Dasna Devi temple (Uttar Pradesh) in 'Haridwar Dharam Sansad' alleged hate speech case.
@ISalilTiwari reports
lawbeat.in/top-stories/br…
Note: Some News portals have incorrectly reported that Narsinghanand has been granted bail in a case registered u/s 295,509,323,504, and 153A of the Indian Penal Code.

In the instant case, he was arrested only for offences u/s 153A and 295A.
Important observations by the court:
1. The court has noted that the prosecution itself has accepted that the informant in the instant matter, Gulbahar Khan, was not present at the Dharm Sansad. He filed a case only on the basis of a video he saw on Facebook.
Read 7 tweets
Feb 7
The Madras High Court grants bail to a suspected Maoist on condition that she would file a sworn affidavit in Tamil owing faith and allegiance to the Indian Constitution and stating that she does not believe in Maoism.
#MadrasHighCourt
Court said that in cases where people wedded to a certain ideology are involved, they do everything possible to prevent the conduct of the trial and such things remain unknown to the media or the outside world.
#madrashighcourt
“On account of such dilatory tactics adopted by the accused, evidences disappear eventually leading to their acquittal. At that time, there will be a hue and cry saying that the system, without any material thereof, had kept the person in prolonged incarceration," court added.
Read 5 tweets
Feb 7
*need not
J: Mr. Mehta, let me clarify, this bench had no role in having the matter listed.

SG: Central government didn't get time. Your Lordship need not clarify anything on that.
J Shakdher: The central government has to take a decision. This is a matter where we want to hear you.

It doesn't gel with us if we keep the matter pending.

You're under instruction, I understand. It's not easy doing a solicitor's job.
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

:(