History was never reason for 🇩🇪 not to deliver weapons to 🇺🇦. If anything opposite.
Other reasons (not to provoke Putin in negotiations; won't make difference in fight) mute/disproven.
We shouldn't wait for more pictures of Putin's atrocities to pour in before changing course.
Greatest obstacle was political capital SPD & Green leaders would need to spend to overcome firm opposition in their parties to weapons deliveries. Given limited difference 🇩🇪 weapons would make I had sympathy for decision not to spend capital. Things are very different now.
As pictures of atrocities of Putin's troops pour in, 🇩🇪public debate will shift. But we shouldn't wait for that & take decision now regardless of how much 🇩🇪 able to deliver. When you are on the wrong side of history, the least you can do is switch lanes as soon as possible.
If the Netherlands can change course on weapons to Ukraine, so can Germany.

As many MPs as possible from all parties (especially SPD & Greens) need to speak out forcefully preparing ground for change of course of party leadership & government.

nltimes.nl/2022/02/26/net…
To those in 🇩🇪 who warn NATO supplying arms to 🇺🇦 means risk of NATO-Russia escalation. That's a concern not to be dismissed lightly.
But do you really think it will make any difference to Putin's reaction if 🇩🇪 continues to say No while most key NATO members supply weapons?
To those in 🇩🇪 who say supplying weapons to 🇺🇦 will only lead to more deaths & who recommend Ukrainians accept Putin's terms & surrender: who are we to tell Ukrainians what is best for them if they tell us they are willing to fight for themselves?
At the end of a long weekend German government has arrived at the right spot.
It felt like a long weekend but it’s ony at the end of a long Saturday.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Thorsten Benner

Thorsten Benner Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @thorstenbenner

Feb 27
#Zeitenwende speech by 🇩🇪 chancellor Olaf Scholz:

Question is "whether we allow Putin to turn back clock or whether we mobilize power to set boundaries for warmongers such as Putin. This requires own strength. Yes, we want to & will secure our freedom, democracy & prosperity". Image
Scholz outlines five areas of action to meet Zeitenwende challenges:
First, support Ukraine including with weapons.
Second, use sanctions to get Putin off his war path
"Putin won't change course over night. But soon Russian leadership will feel what high price it is paying".
Scholz:
Third area of action is increasing German contribution to collective security in NATO especially on Eastern flank.
Details additional Bundeswehr engagement in Lithuania, Romania, Slovakia and in North/Baltic sea & Mediterranean.
Read 9 tweets
Feb 26
On many fronts, things will get a lot worse. I really hope 🇩🇪 government will make some decisive moves to get ahead of the curve & also prepare citizens for what's to come. Too many have impression 🇩🇪 does right thing only way too late after having been dragged into doing it.
🇩🇪 government needs utterly compelling reasons to go against majority view of allies on particular steps
e.g. sanctions because right now signaling determination vis-à-vis Kremlin key. If so it needs water-tight communications strategy. Otherwise 🇩🇪reputation needlessly tanks.
Criticism from sidelines is easy. I have lot of respect for those facing crisis bigger than any of Merkel's tenure right after coming to office in country with worst possible combination of dependencies on 🇷🇺 energy & basic mindset furthest away from what's needed in new world.
Read 4 tweets
Feb 26
Green party MP & state secretary:
"In past years, I was always rock solid against increasing defense budget. This position is no longer tenable in light of current situation".

Exactly. With more voices like @svenlehmann Germany can achieve the rapid change of course it needs.
What makes Lehmann's intervention all the more remarkable is that he's one of the key voices of the Green party's left camp.
Things are moving fast in Green party discussion. @JTrittin, another prominent left-winger, says we need to deter worst case scenario of attack on NATO & deploy more 🇩🇪 troops to Lithuania.
"That's signal to Putin: if you attack🇱🇹 you don't just attack 🇱🇹 but also 🇩🇪 soldiers". Image
Read 4 tweets
Feb 25
Not convinced cutting off all academic cooperation is right answer.
🇪🇺 needs to terminate all cooperation that enhances technological/economic/military base of Russia & anything that legitimizes Kremlin politically. But an across the board cut of everything is counterproductive.
With the necessary due diligence and risk management activities that don't enhance tech/economic/military base should be allowed to continue. Many will terminate anyway due to worsening conditions. But totally shutting door would hurt academics who are not on Putin's side.
Don't get me wrong: risk management/due diligence should be very tough (as it should have been anyway & should also be e.g. with China). But I believe it's in our interest not to fully shut the door on academic cooperation. We need to keep some channels open if conditions allow.
Read 5 tweets
Feb 24
This week, Scholz has very much said & done right things. Today's speeches were strong. Positively surprising expectations on NS2 helped 🇩🇪 standing. Whatever the arguments on merit, holding off on SWIFT against US, UK, Central/Eastern Europe pressure is PR battle 🇩🇪 cannot win.
Scholz clearly on losing side of public argument of not going for SWIFT now. On substance would be curious to know how many of those calling passionately for SWIFT to be applied have looked into details and trade-off before making their passionate call.
foreignaffairs.com/articles/ukrai…
Daleep Singh & others in US government have clearly stated sanctions are structured to spare energy sector since it's there that 🇷🇺 has systemic importance for global economy. One concern about SWIFT that is shared in Berlin is that if you cut 🇷🇺 off it will disrupt gas payments.
Read 8 tweets
Feb 24
Habeck: „Wir erleben eine tiefe Zäsur. Sie wird den Energiesektor, die deutsche Wirtschaft, auch die Wehrhaftigkeit der Bundeswehr, das transatlantische Verhältnis noch einmal völlig neu ausrichten“.
Habeck bringt es auf den Punkt. Zäsur für meisten in meiner Generation, die (wie ich) schöne, aber falsche Grundgewißheiten aus 1989 gezogen hat. Umfassende Investitionen in Wehrhaftigkeit nötig, nicht nur beim Militär. Habecks etwas altertümlicher Begriff paßt da sehr gut.
Wenn Habeck davon spricht, "transatlantische Beziehungen" neu auszurichten, kann es auch hier kein zurück zu alten Gewißheiten geben angesichts der 🇺🇸inneren Turbulenzen & Orientierung Indo-Pazifik.🇪🇺 wird sich in Lage versetzen müssen, großen Teil Abschreckung selbst zu leisten.
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(