1/n Pattern of killing and rioting for Music in front of Mosque has long been a pattern.
A thread on excerpts from "Pakistan or Partition of India" by #Ambedkar where he documents the issue.
2/n #Ambedkar talks about playing of Music in Muslim Neighborhood during religious procession as immediate cause of "Trouble".
3/n Summer of 1927, Calcutta. Reason: Passage of Hindu Procession with Bands playing in neighborhood with Mosques.
4/n April-September, 1927, major riots (not less than 25) occur because of Hindus playing Music in neighborhood with Mosque, or because of slaughtering of cow by Muslims.
5/n Muslims insisted on cow-slaughter. #Ambedkar points says, "(...)no Musalman, when he goes to Haj, sacrifices the cow in Mecca or Medina. But in India they will not be content with the sacrifice of any other animal."
And he also points Muslims insist no Music before Mosque.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
I observed an interesting thing while chronicling the life of Babur.
Although Babur has not penned the patch between 1509-1519 AD, many recent historians have written the account being very sympathetic.
I’ve taken a different approach to cater to this issue.
I have used the excerpt from Baburnama translation by Annette Beveridge for this period. She has used the secondary sources like Tarikh-i-Rashidi & works of Ferishta.
This is just like chronicling the events.
I’m added it in Appendix.
Perhaps this approach may set free the tale of Timurid Colonisation beginning from the generic academic biases.
As a keen History Researcher,I have been aware but you brought the zithers in my spine.
2/n Here I'm going to put across my takeaways from #TheKashmirFiles
A)@vivekagnihotri , it was very important to give the background of term "#Aazadi" & how it was highly sinister of the #JNU students to orchestrate it.
It only meant making Kashmir "Dar-Ul-Islam".
3/n One will never know it until they have cared to read the history of #Kashmir during the era of insurgency.
What freedom, those Islamic Gangs were talking of? It was an absolute freedom from "Dar-al-Harb" which was state of India.
It is been almost 1000 days since the great professional historian #AudreyTruschke blocked me for just fact-check on #Hindutva.
& her audacity kept thickening.
Recently she made baseless allegations of plagiarism on @vikramsampath
Each charges made by her appeared so laughable & was exposed so well by @sanjeevsanyal
But then came the time to look at her own works. One would expect looking at her charges that her book would be full of citations way more than Dr Sampath in terms of % but...
I was taken aback. The size of her biography on Aurangzeb itself has total size= size of @vikramsampath ‘s citations.
Interestingly she quotes so many people but the book is devoid of any citation, footnotes, referencing. Check these pages
AL Basham, the teacher of #RomilaThapar writes about India after talking of Inequality by birth:
"(...) Yet our overall impression is that in no other part of the ancient world were the relations of man and man, and of man and the state, so fair and humane. (...)"
He further showers glory to India saying:
"In no other early civilisation were slaves so few in number, and in no other ancient lawbook are their rights so well protected as in the Arthasastra."
Then he says, "No other ancient lawgiver proclaimed such noble ideals of fair play in battle as did Manu."
Imagine that the Teacher of #RomilaThapar is praising Manu for giving best world ideals of ancient times.
So audacious,appearing immortals, chanting the same Vaidik Ruchas composed millenniums back on the banks of #Saraswati, #Sindhu & many #Sindhus till today.
The Hindus(inhabitants of land beyond Sindhu), followers of Dharma, ie Sanatana,long way we have come.
2/n I always say that it impossible to give a date to Sanatana Dharma.
We need to decode both the words to understand meaning wisely.
Sanatana refers to "imperishable" & "eternal." (refer Śivapurāṇa 2.2.16, 2.2.42)