A short thread🧵 on why #NoToSelfID is important right now. @scotgov want to reform the Gender Recognition Act #GRA & remove the need for a medical diagnosis of gender dysphoria. To a process where people can self declare the gender they wish to live as This is Self ID /1
Self-ID allows individuals to declare themselves to be something they are not. They use the word ‘gender’, which is not adequately defined for individuals to declare whether they are a man or a woman and a boy or a girl /2
Implications for women & girls are:
👉Self ID allows any man to say he's a woman & be treated on a female hospital ward
👉Self ID allows any man to say he's a woman & play in women's sports
👉Self ID allows any man to say he's a woman & enter a rape crisis centre
/3
👉Self ID allows any man to say he’s a woman & provide intimate care to vulnerable women & girls
👉Self ID allows any man to say he's a woman & provide intimate care to people with disabilities who can't consent
👉Self ID allows any boy to say he's a girl & use girls toilets
/4
👉Self ID allows any boy to say he’s a girl & sleep in the same room as girls on residential outings
👉Self ID allows any police man to say he's a women & intimately search female suspects
👉Self ID allows any man to say he's a woman & take a job that is for women only
/5
👉Self ID allows any man to say he's a woman & accept an award for women only
👉Self ID allows any man to say he's a woman & be counted as a woman in official data
/6
👉Self ID allows any man to say he's a woman & if he commits a crime it is recorded as a woman's crime
👉Self ID allows any man to say he's a woman & serve his sentence in a female prison /7
@ForWomenScot @fairplaywomen @SexMattersOrg @mbmpolicy
have helpful information about the implications for GRA reform and have made it easy for us to contribute.
It is important that we have our say as decisions in Scotland will affect the UK & NI. /2
Over the coming days, alongside the consultation, we have a series of questions & comments in graphics to use to highlight to our politicians that this needs to be addressed. /3
If it succeeds, it will mean Self-ID throughout the UK by extension.
BUT WE CAN STOP IT.
1/4
For the Bill to become law, Scottish Ministers have to ask the UK Government to grant permission that a Scottish GRC is recognised outside of Scotland.
The UK Government can refuse this.
Tell the Government they must say NO! to Self-ID.
2/4
If you would like to show your support and say NO! to Self-ID, you can contact your political representatives and express your concerns.
Exhibit B:
Karen White (previously known as David Thompson & Stephen Wood) already had a conviction for indecent assault & gross indecency with a child when remanded to New Hall women’s prison. White does not have a GRC #AllIWantForChristmas #KeepPrisonsSingleSex
During White’s trial the prosecutor said White used “a transgender persona to put herself in contact with vulnerable persons she can then abuse”. Reference was also made to White’s erect penis “sticking out of the top of her pants” #AllIWantForChristmas #KeepPrisonsSingleSex
What we have learnt from Emma Barnett's interview with Nancy Kelley is that she contradicts her own views and beliefs constantly and her thinking is completely inconsistent.
This is what Nancy had to say:
On impartiality:
Nancy: the BBC needs to be impartial on all issues. Particularly news. But being part of Workplace policy doesn't have a real affect on impartiality.
Also Nancy: We would love to have more influence on how the BBC covers LGBTQ
More on impartiality:
Nancy: We support people on inclusion and in a completely separate team we engage with officials and politicians.
Also Nancy: we want progressive change. That is what we do