This is your daily pension announcement: The Pension War Room™️is again venturing into the moldy root cellar of UCP pension policy. I will bring you some odds and ends that were triggered by Dr. Bob's fantastic paper "Can AIMCO be fixed". #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
In reality, the question is more can Travis and the UCP be fixed?
According to Joe Ceci, joint sponsorship for pensions would take “the politics out of pensions” (Alberta Hansard, 29th Legislature, 4th Session, 2373).
As my loyal army will remember, Travis procured a bill that destroyed the trust with plan members and employee associations that is essential for pension plans to operate. Not public money.
Travis has tried his best never to comment on this issue.
When he does @ToewsforAlberta disingenuously claims that "pension payments do not vary with investment return".
Yet unmet investment objectives are real and primary risk to plans in question. #AbLeg
Travis is not the trustee of the plans. He seems to be granting powers to AIMCO that only the trustee can. See the lawsuit that final checked this overreach on the investment management agreements. #AbLeg
TBF sent out a thorough study that Bill Moreneau did for Ontario as research and support @ToewsforAlberta's position.
Apparently, he can' read because the study recommends that funds have the ability to leave their government appointed investment manager. #irony
This cuts right to the fundamentally illogical nature of TBF under the UCP. There only goal seems to be putting the politics back in pensions.
Significantly, Morneau did not find a compelling case for economies of scale above $50-billion in managed assets. (AIMCO >$100 billion)
To quote Travis:
" AIMCo is expected to provide maximum returns to its clients, and processes will be expanded to support broader agency involvement (TBF, 2019, 120)." #AbLeg
Travis never ever defined broader agency involvement. #AbLeg#chillling
This can be taken a couple of ways. My interpretation:
@ToewsforAlberta knew their was a return problem with Kevin and AIMCO and plans were likely to flee.
AND, @aimcoinvests was going to have a key role in selling the APP and other financial chicanery to 'berta. #AbLeg
Shortly thereafter Kevin, AIMCO CEO at the time, was appointed to the Premier's Economic Recovery Council. Again angering the pension plans that were responsible for paying most of his salary. #AbLeg
We have had some really confusing comments from the UCP.
Government House Leader and noted marksman Jason Nixon, said that savings of 0.25 per cent or $41 million on administrative fees would be achieved. And yet the ATRF does not even spend $40 million on administration. #AbLeg
Again, we are closing in on D-Day, the release of @aimcoinvests Annual Report. Please share this tweet stream with at least 10 plan members (LAPP, ATRF, PSPP, etc). They all have a financial interest in @aimcoinvests whether they like it or not. #AbLeg
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
This is your daily pension announcement: The Pension War Room™️again sinks into the pond of liquefied hog manure to find a kernel of truth!
@aimcoinvests Annual Report is coming soon! Guaranteed to be interesting reading combined with some salacious details. #AbLeg
For @MarkDWiseman it is an opportunity for him to justify why the AIMCO Board does not release their expenses to the public like every other board in AB.
(some of their investment professionals are rightfully excluded from expense disclosure-not the Board) #AbLeg
For @ewsiddall, it is an opportunity to further distance the org from the prior CEO Kevin's Dec, 2020 Op Ed where he exhorted Albertans to take pride in AIMCO and concluded with gratitude for the...
“vote of confidence the Alberta government has made in AIMCo.”
Erin here has this entirely wrong. As I have said before, contribution rates are going down for teachers and GOA this Sept. ONLY BECAUSE OF THE OUTSTANDING RETURNS OF ATRF OVER THE LAST 7-10 YEARS.
@aimcoinvests only took possession of all of @ATRFPension assets last October. In any sane democracy you would not see a government destroy a top quartile investment manager providing employment in their home jurisdiction. #AbLeg
ATRF did a simulation using asset class returns that showed ATRF outperformed AIMCO by $1.3 billion over a seven year period starting in 2013.
This study, which was made public, was NOT EVER CHALLENGED by AIMCo or the Finance Minister’s office. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
“Given the plans are funded by participating employees and employers and the assets held in the plan belong to the members, it follows that employees and employers should be able to make decisions that will impact these plans.” (Alberta Hansard, 29th Legislature, 4th Ses, 2027)
This statement above is from Jessica Littlewood, MLA for Fort Sask at the time. This supported a joint governance bill that would "take the politics out of pensions". Please note that, much like an RRSP, pension plan assets belong to the employee (as is recognized here). #AbLeg
Travis, of course, had a different idea and engaged Kevin in a course of action to bring politics back into pensions. Smart as a rock.
In the process, trust was lost with all plan members and employee associations. #AbLeg
This is your daily pension announcement: The Pension War Room™️is ramping up activity as we approach D-day: the day that @aimcoinvests releases its Annual Report. We will be looking for several things from this year's tome. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
We will be looking for Kevin Uebelein's severance "pay" LTIP bonus. He was already paid millions in severance, but apparently (setting a new precedent) he has earned a bonus for this year even though he has not worked. #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
We will be looking for any disinformation and outright lies like this chart from last year. This chart allegedly shows how tragically underpaid @aimcoinvests execs are. Unfortunately, this chart is not normed to assets under management. Misleading at best.
This is your daily pension announcement: The Pension War Room™️reminisces! I just came across my copy of the Nov 30, 2019 Ponoka News Where @RonOrrMLA is busy repeating the UCP line! All the greatest hits like... #AbLeg#handsoffmypension
"...this means that every teacher will get paid a government guaranteed pension until the day they die;"
Well, @RonOrrMLA that just isn't true. The guarantee was removed in 1992. Which makes this decision by Kevin and Travis highly suspect and oppressive. #AbLeg#handsoff
"Their union told them that the ATRF managers had higher returns than AIMCO."
No Ron. Just no. The ATRF WHICH IS A JOINT BODY HALF APPOINTED BY GOA told both the teachers and Travis that ATRF had demonstrably outperformed @aimcoinvests. #AbLeg