It's 4 months into suspension already but WHO is still not satisfied with company's good manufacturing practises (GMPs), it told me last Friday, sharing its assessment of corrective and preventive action (CAPA) plan submitted by company in June. Here's what the WHO exactly said:
"In summary, based on the said CAPA response, the manufacturing site for Covaxin is still considered to be operating at an unacceptable level of compliance with WHO Good Manufacturing Practices for Pharmaceutical Products guidelines,"
On suspension, it said: “[Since the CAPA report has not been accepted] there is no ground to lift the suspension or to initiate any procurement for UN agencies."
WHO also said its assessment of CAPA response had been communicated to @CDSCO_INDIA_INF on July 14 and further details could be gathered from it only or from #BharatBiotech. Wrote to both of them; seeking details and their response to WHO's assessment. None replied, once again.
WHO said in the latest reply, as it said in April to me, CDSCO officials had JOINED WHO inspectors in March inspection.But when I asked govt to share the March inspection report,@MoHFW_INDIA replied my RTI on July 20 saying 'no info available'.
This was not surprising because @PriyankaPulla's RTI application filed with CDSCO in April seeking a copy of the report had met the same fate when the regulator plainly denied having any information about WHO's inspection.
Can #Covaxin lose WHO's EUL status? It will depend on further responses of company and WHO's assessment of revised CAPA if at all it is submitted. But there is a possibility of revocation of EUL in case there are issues with QUALITY as per August update of EUL guidelines of WHO:
Even IND foreign ministry had apparently warned Vinod Paul in April itself to get the issue resolved, not doing which may lead to revocation of EUL status. It may affect international travel. science.thewire.in/health/bharat-…. Although it denied next day as being quoted 'out of context.
For those who had expressed doubts why #BharatBiotech, in first place, should have informed #WHO about changes in manufacturing process post-licensure, here's explanation. (It was not doing that 'precisely' that led to WHO's stricture and suspension against the company in April).
Replying my four RTI applications in 2019, @Pharmadept gave me names of 20 pharma firms, which the govt knew, had bribed the docs. This was info ON RECORD. But not a single company got punished. (1/n) downtoearth.org.in/news/health/th…
But @Pharmadept refused to name the docs bribed, saying, it would be seek permission of those who made complaints against docs. When I also reached to original complainants, they had no obj. Still DoP nvr shared names. Asked what action did it take, it said, ask @MoHFW_INDIA
@MoHFW_INDIA said the companies are part of associations of pharma companies. 'We can't do anything, only this assns can'. And what they can? Guess what,remove them from assn.That's all. But that almost never happens. Neither DoP nor ministry told me what action was finally taken
Eight years of #Modi rule: How did the government perform in #health sector. Thread (1/n)
DISEASE ELIMINATION DEADLINES
Kala-azar: 2017. Revised 2020 ❌
Leprosy: 2018 ❌
Filariasis: 2017 ❌
Now, new deadlines for KA: 2023. Filariasis: 2030
TB elimination deadline: 2025
Interim target to be achieved till 2020: 142 per 100,000
But prevalence in 2019-21: 312 per 100,000
NUTRITION TARGETS FOR POSHAN ABHIYAN LAUNCHED in 2018
Anaemia to⬇️3% PA. Instead it⬆️not only in children but also women b/w NFHS-4 and NFHS-5.
Stunting had to ⬇️ to 25% by 2022. But till 2021 it stood at 35.5%. Now it hs ⬇️ to by at least 10% pts in a yr -- an impossible target.
The #WHO on April 2 issued a statement saying the supply of #Covaxin to UN agencies had been suspended due to "deficiencies in good manufacturing practices". There were not mny details. In an email, they have now told @TheWireScience the following : science.thewire.in/health/who-cov… (1/n)
"Problems were detected in some parts of the manufacturing process. SOME CHANGES WERE MADE after the emergency-use license was granted but were not submitted to the national drug regulator and WHO for evaluation and validation."
The WHO still didn't specify what were those changes. Whether those changes were related to increase the yield, or on the front of raw materials or due to some other reason--we don't know. A GMP expert said major changes, if done post approval, have to be informed.
TRUST DRUG CONTROLLER: Paul's response in @MoHFW_INDIA press conference today, responding to a question why no data in public domain on #Corbevax @TheWireScience
Paul: "Corbevax, clearly, the EUA has been given for adult and children. Be rest assured that the data has been by drug regulator. Be also rest assured for both these groups is being reviewed by the NTAGI because we work in tandem."+
UNTIMELY death of a loved one, even if it has happened more than a decade ago, is an extremely difficult fact to come to terms with. Two days ago a friend and I, out of nowhere, went discussing about last 11 days of another friend who died for want of a liver transplant+
She was our batchmate during graduation at a Varanasi univ. She continued to pursue Master’s from there, I moved to Delhi. We were 21. One fine day during our PG days, we got to know she was suffering from liver cirrhosis—otherwise a totally fit person.
This was 4 days after she got was with ‘jaundice' and we kept talking—we thought it would be just fine.
4 days later got a call saying ur friend has bcm unconsciousness from somebody who knew her. I dialled friends in the univ.With their help she got admitted at the varsity hosp
At times, one has to write just to record for the history. That, a country's regulator invites media for webinar on clinical trials and when a question is asked, the reply is this 👇
"My request was to limit the question regarding understanding the processes involved. About the specifics of the things you are questioning, there are forums…there are weekly press conferences by department / ministry. This question can be asked there." downtoearth.org.in/news/health/dr…
Other issues related to CTs which were asked but were not taken up due to 'paucity of time':
The composition of ethics committees of institutions where these trials are going on
The role Central Drugs Standard Control Organisation’s own subject expert committee