• Nominal int rate: rate of return earned in “money” terms
• Real int rate: rate of return earned in “real” (purchasing power) terms. It's the return after adjusting for effect of #inflation (impact of rising price levels)
2/6
Why the formula is wrong?
“Fisher's Equation” gives the link between:
• Real rate (R),
• Nominal rate (N), and,
• Expected inflation rate (E).
1 + N = (1 + R) * (1 + E)
So,
R = {(1 + N)/(1 + E)} – 1
An “approximation” of this turns out to:
R = N - E
3/6
Yes, this is a common simplification.
But, it can be used only when BOTH nominal rate and inflation rate are very small values.
This may be true for the western world.
But it's not (mostly) true for countries like Sri Lanka.
Let's work some numbers.
4/6
For e.g.:
• If N = 30% and E = 60%
Correct R = -18.75%
Simplified R = -30%
• If N = 30% and E = 25%
Correct R = 4%
Simplified R = 5%
The margin of error in the estimation is much higher, for bigger values of N and E.
5/6
Same goes for your investment decisions and valuations which relied on those simplified real returns.
Caveat emptor!
If you enjoyed this:
• follow me @TheGayan for more insights on #investing
• retweet the top tweet below to share with others
So far #SriLanka has talked about restructuring ext debt & not domestic debt.
Our paper shows that current IMF targets for DR are unlikely to deliver a sustainable pathway for econ recovery & debt management, unless rates are brought down by over 10%.
2/10
We don’t see a path for reducing int rates adequately, given high risk in the economy & lack of confidence on financial management.
Int rates are also high because Govt has a huge borrowing appetite simply to repay what has already been borrowed.
The "Group"
• Known as "an ad-hoc creditor committee"
• Consists of 100+ foreign investors
• Led by a steering committee of 10+ members
• Represents over 55%+ of ISBs non- domestic holdings
• Advised by Rothschild and White & Case
Source: Min. of Finance (23.09.2022)
2/12
Summary
• They are ready to hold debt restructuring talks - quickly and effectively
• They acknowledge Sri Lankan authorities’ engagement with official creditors toward a resolution of the current crisis and restoration of debt sustainability.
China is still a developing country. So, China will try to offer support to all developing countries, but, they expect to be paid back because it's a developing country.
So, a haircut in Chinese context is politically very difficult.
But they understood that there are ways in which they can reach the equivalent of a haircut by stretching maturities, reducing or eliminating interest rates & payments.
Paris Club is also engaging with China.
2/4
There may be a way to reach the same objective of reducing debt burden.
Yes, it's better if debt reduction is done upfront (haircut), compared to reprofiling.
We emphasise the value for China as a lender to have their exposure to countries defined in a rational way.
3/4