Markham Hislop Profile picture
Mar 4, 2023 28 tweets 11 min read Read on X
1/🧵 37 oil sands tailings ponds containing 1.4 TRILLION litres of waste have been a catastrophe waiting to happen for decades.

This story is the canary in the coal mine.

#oilsands #ABleg #YMM
2/A leak of industrial wastewater from @ImperialOil's Kearl oil sands plant 70 kms north of Fort McMurray on May 19, 2022. Imperial reported it to the Alberta Energy Regulator (AER).

Area includes muskeg, forested public lands, wildlife, and a "fish-bearing waterbody." Image
3/"...from June to August 2022, w/regulatory oversight from the AER, Imperial conducted a geochemistry study to determine the source and pathway of Release 1..." which contained "dissolved iron, total arsenic, F2 hydrocarbons, sulphate, total sulphide..."
aer.ca/providing-info…
4/On Nov 29, Imperial confirmed that "wastewater is seeping from its External Tailings Area (ETA) through a common fill layer placed during construction, mixing with shallow groundwater, and coming to surface at locations on the Site and Off-site."

This is bad, but... Image
5/Then on Feb 4, 5.3 million litres of industrial wastewater overflowed a storage pond set up to hold seepage from a tailings pond.

How did that much wastewater seep from the tailings pond to begin with?

Tailings ponds have been leaking for years:
6/The AER demanded a communications plan by Feb 10.

Finally, the Athabasca Chipewyan First Nation was told about the spill.

Chief Alan Adam said the Nation received only one call from Imperial about the earlier leak. He called it a "cover up."
cbc.ca/news/canada/ed…
7/Chief Adam has a point. Imperial knows exactly what its obligations are in this situation. Even if it could argue that the first release was a grey area, why didn't it act out of an abundance of caution and concern for human health?
8/"Imperial Oil has submitted and is required to implement a communications plan providing for regular updates to potentially affected parties, including Indigenous communities such as ACFN," says the AER.

Why no follow up by the AER to ensure communication occurred?
9/"Time and time again we have been told to trust that the Alberta Government will protect our lands and waters and that industry has our best interests in mind, and once again this trust has been broken," Eriel Deranger, ACFN Executive Director of Indigenous Climate Action.
10/The NWT govt found out about the spill via media stories.

"This lack of transparency and information sharing from our Alberta partners is not an isolated incident, which increases our frustration in this matter," Env Min Shane Thompson said.
gov.nt.ca/en/newsroom/sh…
11/AB Env Min @sonyasavage said she and Premier @ABDanielleSmith are "monitoring the situation."

She couldn't resist a dig at federal Env Min @s_guilbeault, who was "offered a briefing today by our government but did not take that opportunity.."
alberta.ca/release.cfm?xI…
12/UAlberta economics professor @andrew_leach raises an interesting issue: if the first release happened in May, why are the Premier and Env Min only being briefed almost a year later?

Savage was energy min until Smith became premier in August. How did she not know? Image
13/Guilbeault promised aid to the communities, including fresh water, pledged full cooperation from federal enforcement officers, said CANGov would require a clear remediation plan from the company and an explanation for the poor communications. Image
14/Well, how did Alberta get into this mess?

Nina Lothian, former fossil fuels director of the Pembina Institute, says industry and the AER have been unsuccessfully grappling with the tailings pond problem for decades.

Why haven't they succeeded?
15/Bottom line: even though industry has spent hundred of millions searching for a solution, reclaiming tailings ponds has proven to be harder than expected.

But Dr Mohamed Gamal El-Din, engineering prof, @UAlberta, says it comes down to cost.
16/Dr. Vikram Yadav, assoc prof of Chemical Engineering at @ubcscience and CEO of Vancouver-based Tersa, says mining companies around the world are having similar problems.

His firm's process uses a microbe to remove metals and toxins from the tailings.
share.transistor.fm/s/19d3751a
17/It works in the lab, but now needs capital to fund a small-scale demonstration project, followed by a pilot, then full-scale commercialization.

He's confident his technology will work, but he's not the first to think he's solved this knotty problem.
19/Every expert I interview says there is plenty of good will within industry to solve it, but companies want a cost-effective solution.

Both ABGov and AER are reluctant to push too hard for fear of killing the golden goose of the Alberta economy.
20/So they let industry punt the issue down the road again and again, hoping for a technology breakthrough in the future.

There was AER Directive 74 in 2009. Deadlines came and went with no progress.

Directive 85 isn't likely to be any more successful.
aer.ca/providing-info…
21/ABGov's Mine Financial Security program is supposed to collect $$ from producers against future reclamation costs (estimated at $31 billion). It has ~$1 billion.

UCalgary lawyer @DrewYewchuk explains how UCP weakened an already weak program.
22/AB govts have never been willing to force industry's hand.

And the AER has "given every reason not to trust that they have their eye on the public interest,” says @UCalgaryLaw professor Martin Olszynski.

Is AER "captured" by industry?
theglobeandmail.com/business/artic…
23/At a glance:

*ABGov doesn't have the backbone to act, regardless of the party in power
*AER is far too cozy with industry.
*Industry wants an easy, cheap solution, which doesn't seem likely within a reasonable timeframe.

What to do?
24/Industry has no will to fix the tailings pond problem. That leaves either ABGov or CANGov.

Smith/Savage's response to the Kearl leak was pathetic. Smith's RStar program to give up to $20 billion to industry to clean up abandoned wells shows she is in industry's pocket.
25/Would an @albertaNDP govt under @RachelNotley have the fortitude to act?

Maybe, but she did nothing while premier from 2015 to 2019.

She called for an investigation of Kearl leak/spill, but no suggestion she would fix a broken system if NDP were govt.
26/Can CANGov act? This question is fraught with political tension, as well as constitutional and regulatory uncertainty.

I'll interview experts in the coming week to explore the extent of the problem, potential solutions, and which actors in this sad drama need to lead.
27/Why not just shut down the oil sands b/c tailings pond, uber high GHGs, etc?

Because bitumen is a fantastic feedstock for advanced materials manufacturing.

It's too valuable to burn and should be used to make stuff.
energi.media/markham-on-ene…
28/Oil sands need a rethink.

Current structure of the industry is designed for the 20th century.

Energy transition of the 21st century is creating a very different energy future.

Our choice: change how we extract/use bitumen or watch the sector decline.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Markham Hislop

Markham Hislop Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @politicalham

May 3
1/Dear @rebeccakschulz

Stop spinning the data. From the 2024 CANGov NIR data released yesterday re. AB GHGs in Mt/yr:

2021: 269.9
2022: 271.0

You're bragging about an improvement of 1.1 Mt/yr? Seriously?
2/This graph nicely illustrates why @s_guilbeault hasn't been praising Alberta's emissions record.

Would you like to retract your tweet?

This chart clearly shows that Alberta is the ONLY province whose emissions rose between 2005 and 2021. Image
@s_guilbeault 3/I made this graph from last year's data. From this year's data:

2021: 155.8
2022: 155.3

Now you're bragging about one-half of one Mt/yr improvement! Image
Read 7 tweets
Feb 28
1/🧵Came across some old USA data that shows rise of new energy technology (ICE tractors + petroleum) and decline of old (animal power).

Smooth lines disguise plenty of market speed bumps, eg Great Depression starts in 1930.

Don't fret about EV sales. EVs = tractors
#Alberta Image
2/The first "tractors" were powered by steam. They date back to the early 1890s.

In Western Canada, they were uneconomic for plowing, but very good at breaking new farm land and powering the big threshing machines that toured farms during harvest.

Sales declined in 1920s. Image
3/Around 1908, first "big gas tractors" sold in the West.

Still uneconomic for 1/4 section farms, a few big commercial farms experimented with teams of them. Economics weren't much better than steam tractors.

Never caught on. Kinda like some of the early EVs that failed. Image
Read 9 tweets
Jan 16
1/From 2015 to 2019 @RachelNotley introduced some of the most forward-thinking energy and climate policies in North America.

She did it during a very difficult time of low oil and gas prices.

All the best in the next phase of your career, Ms Notley.
energi.media/markham-on-ene…
2/Notley signals that partial upgrading, petrochemicals will play bigger role in solving crude oil market access issue
energi.media/markham-on-ene…
3/Battle over Bill C69 demonstrates Notley govt support for Alberta oil and gas industry

energi.media/markham-on-ene…
Read 10 tweets
Jan 4
1/🧵The Death of King Oil

Will global oil demand peak in 2030 then decline quickly @IEA or peak in 2045 and decline slowly @OPEC?

The answer has significant implications for #Canada and oil-producing provinces, especially #Alberta.
#OOTT #ABleg #cdnpoli
share.transistor.fm/s/72e05025
2/Framing the peak oil demand discussion: Fast vs slow energy transition

International Energy Agency (IEA) = fast
*Peak oil demand by 2030, short plateau, rapid decline in 2 of 3 scenarios

OPEC = slow
*Peak oil demand in 2045, long plateau, slow decline
energi.media/energi-notes/w…
3/My hypothesis: IEA's modelling and analysis is more credible than OPEC's.

Several of OPEC's key assumptions (discussed later in this thread) are falling apart only a few months after the release of World Oil Outlook 2045.
opec.org/opec_web/en/pr…
Read 68 tweets
Aug 3, 2023
🧵 about @ABDanielleSmith's 7-month moratorium on new wind, solar projects.

Move roundly condemned by economists, clean energy groups.

The criticism is deserved, but there's more to this story, IMO.
#ABleg #ABpoli
alberta.ca/release.cfm?xI…
2/Min @neudorf_ab says moratorium a response to AB Utilities Commission (AUC) July 21 letter that raised 2 issues:

1. "development of power plants on high value agricultural lands"

2. "lack of mandatory reclamation security requirements for power plants"
alberta.ca/external/news/…
3/AB Electricity System Operator (AESO) also wrote a letter dated July 21 that supported "an inquiry into land use and reclamation issues..."
alberta.ca/external/news/…
Read 17 tweets
Jul 15, 2023
🧵 re the coming threat to the #Alberta economy courtesy of the global energy transition.

AB is out of step with rest of the world.

We think we have plenty of time. We don't.

@Alberta_UCP mandate letters illustrate why.
#OOTT #ABleg #cdnpoli
energi.media/energi-notes/w…
First, the big picture.

The common response among advanced nations to the energy transition + climate crisis is some version of this 3-pronged strategy:

1. Adopt clean energy supply (renewables, nuclear, hydrogen, batteries, geothermal, etc) Image
2. Adopt clean energy demand technology (EVs, heat pumps, etc)

ELECTRIFY. EVERYTHING.

What can't be electrified will switch to zero or low-emission fuel like hydrogen.

But it will be mostly electricity. Image
Read 24 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(