“So you’re saying that trans kids are too young to consent, but intersex kids aren’t?” asked Bria Brown-King, director of engagement for the intersex rights group InterAct. “How does that make sense?” #TransIntersexSolidarity@19thnews 19thnews.org/2023/03/bills-…
More than two-thirds of the bills introduced this year that would ban gender-affirming care for transgender youth have specific intersex exemptions.
Those carve-outs have consequences, advocates say: Some of the first explicit anti-intersex language is being written into law.
The controversial exemptions allow doctors to assign minors who are born with secondary sex characteristics as “male” or “female” through surgeries, hormones or other interventions.
While doctors have operated on intersex minors to assign them “male” or “female” sexes for decades, human rights organizations have long condemned the surgeries on kids as cosmetic, unnecessary and inhumane.
"The bills are really authorizing in the law the practice of performing these unnecessary surgeries,” Moran said. @uliveinasociety
@SeanSaifaWall thinks the bills are not about protecting children at all and said they are really about reinforcing rigid gender ideals and heterosexuality.
“I see the attack on trans people, and I see the mandates to continue doing surgeries on intersex infants and children as a way of crushing bodily autonomy as a way of upholding ‘male’ and ‘female’ as sacred,” he said.
“This harm has been really endemic and it’s been long-standing. The scary part about it, though, is when there’s a codifying it into law.”
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The discrimination faced by Caster Semenya today is another example of the intense ignorance faced by women athletes who have differences in their sex traits. Intersex women are women. Trans women are women. ALL women's bodies are different. #threadtheguardian.com/sport/2019/may…
Caster Semenya is a record-making South African runner. She was thrown into the spotlight for having higher than average natural testosterone levels, and traits that some critiqued as being not 'feminine' enough, as if there is one way to look like and be a woman.
Caster has never used the word 'intersex' to describe herself, and her medical information was leaked because of the scale of her case. We want to acknowledge Caster's violated privacy, while we express outrage over the discrimination her case represents.
Preface: everyone is different, this is of course one opinion. Also, while they are common themes among intersex people, medical trauma, non-consensual surgeries, or even a diagnosis are not requirements to ID as intersex, and we don't endorse gatekeeping.
What is or is not intersex is somewhat subjective. At its simplest, IDing as #intersex is about having experiences with your body's inherent sex differences, and if that word feels right to you.