Rhys Thomas Profile picture
Apr 5 26 tweets 17 min read Twitter logo Read on Twitter
A recurring theme on #MedTwitter is frustration with #LookAlike medications.
We get angry at drug companies & demand they fix what we think is a simple problem. But it’s not. It’s very complex, even bordering on “wicked”. I’m hoping this 🧵 might help tease that out. 1/ ImageImageImageImage
First of all, it’s worth pointing out some companies are aware of the issue and are trying to improve things. One notable attempt by Hameln is the use of the ISO 26825 colour scheme for syringe labels, on their ampoules & packaging. 2/ ImageImage
It would certainly have value in anaesthetics as we are familiar with them, & it’s almost a case of “If you’re going to use colours why not those ones?”.
It would certainly help reduce the risk of between-drug-class problems like this (👇) happening. 3/

But there are a couple of problems here. First of all, this only works if you get all your drugs from Hameln. If, due to costs, shortages etc, you need to use a different company, there’s a risk of re-introducing look-alikes. 4/ ImageImageImageImage
But also, in typical complex problem fashion, if followed to its natural conclusion, the Hameln strategy could generate a new problem. An increased risk of within-drug-class errors as all drugs in the same class could end up looking similar. 5/ ImageImageImageImage
And here’s a real world example. Aguettant, to their credit, use the ISO colour codes but 3 of these drugs use purple. But it seems they are aware of this so they used a solid block of colour for one but only a border for another. 6/

And of course look-alikes are not just an anaesthetic problem. So an overlap in colour coding may not be a big issue for a small number of drugs in an anaesthetic tray, but could easily become a problem for 100’s of drugs in a pharmacy. 7/ ImageImageImageImage
And utilising colour coding by class becomes an even bigger concern where a given drug comes in different formulations/concentrations, especially if there are already look-alike/sound-alike issues. 8/ ImageImage
Indeed this issue of different concentrations of the same drug is significant enough for some companies to go rogue & use their own colour system to distinguish between them. While well intentioned this may make things worse as there’s a risk of confusion with the ISO colours. 9/ Image
The above issues reveal a key limitation of colour coding. There just aren’t enough colours! Also relevant is that significant numbers of HCW’s have colour vision deficiency, although the original standard from South Africa did have a rather brutal way to avoid that issue!😳 10/ ImageImage
So if colour’s not going to solve it alone, what else can we try? Tall man lettering is commonly suggested, and used, but the evidence for it’s effectiveness is lacking, and @hypoxicchicken has gone so far as to suggest phasing it out. 11/ ImageImageImageImage
Another option is shape (& size) coding as suggested by @ybitan. Shape coding has a special place in the heart of ergonomists, as it’s linked with the birth of the discipline. Indeed there are already examples in healthcare, and we often use it without even realising it… 12/ ImageImageImageImage
…because for a lot of look-alike errors, the shape (& size) matters just as much as, if not more than, colour because it has a tactile as well as visual component. 13/ ImageImageImageImage
And interestingly, if you go back to the Hameln example, they seem to have attempted some shape coding. It’s hard to say how much it adds, especially without the tactile aspect, but at least they are trying! 14/ ImageImageImage
And going back to the Aguettant syringes, you may have noticed there were actually two that had solid purple colouring. But one of them was shorter than the other one which “should” (😬🤞) be enough to distinguish between them. 15/ Image
And we do already have some different shapes & sizes at our disposal, but they seem to be used haphazardly rather in a systematic way to improve safety. And just like colour, the lack of variety currently utilised would limit it’s impact. 16/ ImageImageImage
So hopefully you’re now beginning to see that while there are some drug companies trying to address the issue of look-alikes, those efforts are sporadic and there’s no coordinated, standardised, international effort to improve things which I think is what’s required. 17/
And because of the global nature of drug manufacturing and logistics, differing regulatory requirements regarding drug labelling, drug shortages, and cost pressures, any changes a given company make are unlikely to improve things, and have the potential to make things worse. 18/
For this reason the problem’s not going to be solved by an individual company and, in keeping with other wicked problems, has no “stopping point”, so is likely to be ultimately unsolvable. But I think we can make progress. 19/
It will need a sustained input of money, time, attention & expertise, international co-ordination, & the recognition that, to paraphrase John Senders, medication safety is a special case of safety, not a special case of medicine, so will need input from other disciplines. 20/
But I think the key ingredient is creativity. Coming up with new ideas, but also doing current things differently. For example, the label is not the only place we can use colour. What about the glass and the ampoule caps? 21/ ImageImageImageImage
And there’s some creative options for shape coding too! 22/ Image
And we’d do well to look at history and learn from the apothecaries who, long before Fitts, Jones or Chapanis, realised the importance of combining text, shape, tactile & colour coding to help stop people drinking poison! 23/ ImageImageImageImage
But we also need to think of new approaches. What about something along the lines of IATA Airport Codes for example? A unique 3 letter code for each drug, with the advantage of it being suitable for oral meds as well.

Ok, this 🧵is already too long so one final, key point. 24/ ImageImageImageImage
Medication safety is about more than physical presentations of drugs. They are only 1 element of a broader medication system & understanding interactions b/w elements of this system is the key to improvement.
@hypoxicchicken & @NicholasChrimes paper covers all this very well. Fin Image
@threadreaderapp unroll please!

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Rhys Thomas

Rhys Thomas Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @DrGetafix

Jan 25, 2022
A 🧵on #Covid, lollipops & design.

This is a lollipop. Lots of people got one for getting their #CovidVaccine. Everyone knows what they are and how to use them, even (or especially!) kids. Give them one and they know which end goes in their mouth.
This is also called a "lollipop"...
...and you can kind of see why as it bears a physical resemblance to an actual lollipop.
Read 13 tweets
Mar 30, 2019
Fantastic presentation on current and possible applications of 3D printing in healthcare by Prof Gordon Wallace from the University of Wollongong.
Some advantages of 3D printing
An amazing array of potential “inks” both synthetic and biological.
Read 14 tweets
Sep 11, 2018
Beyond RCA. #Quality2018
Aviation analogies! #quality2018
The @hsib_org and learning from other industries. #quality2018
Read 20 tweets
Jul 3, 2018
As a doctor, i've always been aware of the importance of exercise. I was never of fan of exercise for exercise's sake, but i'd stay fit by playing sport, bushwalking, chasing after the kids etc. But now that i'm a doctor living with cancer, it's much more complex. 1/8
All at once, exercise became more important, yet harder to do. There is new research popping up all the time about the benefits of exercise for cancer patients, but with all the new #PatientWork i have to deal with such as appointments, scans, blood tests & procedures etc...2/8
...it's harder to find the time. Add in multiple surgeries & hospital stays & I deconditioned pretty quickly. So I have less time to do exercise, & as I'm less fit it feels like more of a chore. Then some weird & not so wonderful immunotherapy side effects... 3/8
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(