eddie synot Profile picture
May 2 17 tweets 15 min read Twitter logo Read on Twitter
The Voice is about empowering communities, not the same privileged few. Here's Warren (@nyunggai) supporting $500m in cuts to community programs in 2014 while arguing for $600m more. His finger prints are all over the failure to close the gap 🧵#auspol #VoteYes #VoiceToParliament
This was under the Indigenous Advancement Strategy. Abbott's landmark policy that brought Indigenous affairs into PM&C & gutted community support. The IAS was key reason behind many calling for change at the regional dialogues leading to Uluru #auspol #VoteYes #VoiceToParliament
Warren was chair of the PM's advisory council, later a candidate for the Coalition under another PM. Here he justifies cuts, but also refuses to answer questions about cuts to vital community programs with lasting negative impacts #auspol #VoteYes #VoiceToParliament
It wasn't the men and women in community calling for the Voice and for things to change that are responsible for failure in Indigenous affairs, but it was Warren & the Govt over the past decade with their deliberate decisions. #auspol #VoteYes #VoiceToParliament
Warren disgustingly dismisses the community & calls for the Voice as "elite". Here he is, talking about the PM contacting him privately & being privy to private briefings as they slashed hundreds of millions from communities in desperate need #auspol #VoteYes #VoiceToParliament
Warren's advice & support directly led to many community programs that were and are vital to addressing many ongoing issues in community being defunded. decimating the support and community control that was key. #auspol #VoteYes #VoiceToParliament
Warren claims here that through cuts & changes the foundations for closing the gap & real progress would be in place in 5-6 years. Will Warren & the Coalition own up to their failure, rather than lecture community about what will close the gap? #auspol #VoteYes #VoiceToParliament
Warren has had more access than almost any other Australian. He walks the halls of parliament. Has had direct input into the failure of policy and continues to deny real change, continues to deny our voices being heard. #auspol #VoteYes #VoiceToParliament
The IAS was a failure. It did not result in promised improvements. It set back real reform. It gave money to Minister Nigel Scullion's mates & even funded a tv program called "Mundine Means Business" while gutting vital community support #auspol #VoteYes #VoiceToParliament
Here's Nigel Scullion giving $150,000 to the NT Seafood Council, $170,000 to the NT Amateur Fishermen’s Association and $165,000 to the NT Cattlemen’s Association - all money supposed to be for Indigenous advancement #auspol #VoteYes #VoiceToParliament sbs.com.au/nitv/article/s…
Here's Warren Mundine being funded for a TV program "Mundine Means Business" to the tune of $330,000 of Indigenous advancement money while vital community support and programs were gutted. Elite much? #auspol #VoteYes #VoiceToParliament buzzfeed.com/hannahryan/war…
The National Audit Office issued a scathing audit of the IAS under the Coalition in 2017. It was scathing of the process and how decisions were made and said it did not meet the standards required. #auspol #VoteYes #VoiceToParliament anao.gov.au/work/performan… Image
The ANAO found that the PM&C lost *300 applications* - that's right - LOST 300 APPLICATIONS. Further feedback and advice was not given. There was no communication with the community. #auspol #VoteYes #VoiceToParliament ImageImage
The IAS was treated like the personal discretionary trust & piggy bank of Nigel Scullion, to give grants as they liked while refusing real need on ground in community. These events are one of the clearest examples of why the voice is needed. #auspol #VoteYes #VoiceToParliament
Nigel Scullion's response to the Voice at the time was we didn't need it because we had him! Imagine. After what he had been up to! #auspol #VoteYes #VoiceToParliament
This failure is exactly why the Nationals & the Coalition do not have a leg to stand on when the lecture about what will & won't close the gap. The failed miserably and made it worse. Warren Mundine's finger prints are all over that failure. #auspol #VoteYes #VoiceToParliament
Despite all of this, the regional delegates at Uluru, from communities across this country, came together to achieve something more, to achieve real change. Warren does not speak for them. It's time they were heard. It's time for the Voice #auspol #VoteYes #VoiceToParliament

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with eddie synot

eddie synot Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @EddieSynot

Jan 29
There will never be “veto power” for Voice, or Treaty, or any kind of arrangement for Indigenous peoples in Australia. It’s impossible. It’s important to understand why. This is not a limitation of the Voice proposal. It’s an impossibility 🧵 #VoteYes #UluruStatement #auspol
Under the Australian system of democratic governance established by our constitution, the parliament has legislative power/authority. That’s the house of reps & senate. That’s it. They’re/it’s sovereign. #VoteYes #UluruStatement #auspol
Being able to give “veto power” to another institution would be to fundamentally alter the entire system of governance established by our Constitution, it would mean tearing it up & starting all over again. #VoteYes #UluruStatement #auspol
Read 9 tweets
Jan 29
This is quite something from David Littleproud & @The_Nationals - I’ll think you’ll find bureaucrats swanning in & out of Indigenous communities is a massive part of the problem we have now, that is the status quo that is failing our people. #UluruStatement #auspol #VoteYes 🧵
Let’s not forget again here @The_Nationals have zero credibility on what will work for closing the gap. They had the Indigenous affairs portfolio for almost 7 years out of the past decade. #UluruStatement #auspol #VoteYes
This idea the Voice is just another layer of bureaucracy is nonsense. Those pointing to the Langton & Calma model are conveniently ignoring the fact it’s an example only & Govt is committed to designing final Voice with community itself. #UluruStatement #auspol #VoteYes
Read 5 tweets
Jan 29
This is embarrassing. What a very confused No case. Misquoting source of “all men are created equal” saying it’s US Constitution rather than Declaration of Independence, then also saying it’s a good example to draw on? #VoteYes #UluruStatement #auspol 🧵 theguardian.com/australia-news…
Warren, that same US carried on & enabled slavery after declaring independence under banner of “equality for all” 🙃 And let’s not erase the history & experience of Native American people, including the recognition of their rights & place too #VoteYes #UluruStatement #auspol
The key thing here anyway is this: “This approach was previously rejected by multiple rounds of consultation including the 2017 Uluru statement from the heart, which called for a voice to parliament.” No one wants symbolism. #VoteYes #UluruStatement #auspol
Read 7 tweets
Jan 28
A lot of talk about what practical benefit the Voice would have & people jumping to voting intentions without thinking or engaging. Some genuine; some I think less than genuine in light of Alice Springs. Let me unpack a little. 🧵 #UluruStatement #auspol #VoteYes
Firstly, an immediate response seems to be “just listen now” or “why isn’t the advice already being listened to” - or we don’t need a voice to listen. Again, some genuine concern here along with disingenuous talk from those fundamentally opposed #UluruStatement #auspol #VoteYes
Clearly we need a Voice. The current failures are result of a system that fails our people. When it does listen, it does so with its fingers & toes crossed. The response to welfare issues & the Voice proposals clearly should not be the status quo. #UluruStatement #auspol #VoteYes
Read 9 tweets
May 25, 2022
The #UluruStatement sequence is key. A Voice to Parliament protected by the Constitution, then a Makarrata Commission for treaty & truth telling. This was settled by the USFH process & should not be re-litigated. Below are some points on why this is key for Voice & Treaty #auspol
Questions have been asked about the advisory only nature of the Voice, implications about its lack of power, and about it ceding Indigenous sovereignty or rights. None of this is correct (has been disproven multiple times) & misunderstands challenges faced #UluruStatement #auspol
Treaty has been the important goal for the Indigenous community for a reason. It remains part of the #UluruStatement for that same reason. But Treaty, because of our local circumstances & history, cannot deliver on the expectations that are attached to it. #auspol
Read 14 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(