I agree with @NoahRFeldman.
And a key bilateral point:
The House has a duty to send articles...
Just like the Senate has a duty to have a real trial.
A good example of structure & original public meaning filling in textual gaps.
bloomberg.com/amp/opinion/ar…
And a key bilateral point:
The House has a duty to send articles...
Just like the Senate has a duty to have a real trial.
A good example of structure & original public meaning filling in textual gaps.
bloomberg.com/amp/opinion/ar…
A vote to impeach without attempting a prosecution (like not delivering the articles) is unrecognizable historically as “Impeachment.”
The House can call it whatever it wants, but as long as it withholds, as a matter of Article II constitutional meaning, it falls short.
The House can call it whatever it wants, but as long as it withholds, as a matter of Article II constitutional meaning, it falls short.
People are taking the word “sole” and sticking every result they want - every power they want Pelosi and House Dems to have - into that word.
The word “sole” means that there is no judicial impeachment or review.
It doesn’t empower the House to change the Constitution’s meaning
The word “sole” means that there is no judicial impeachment or review.
It doesn’t empower the House to change the Constitution’s meaning
