According to the study Supplement, the following eligibility criteria were provided:
"...the age differential was permitted to ensure that Black and Hispanic populations could be represented in the trial, given evidence of higher burden of disease necessitating aspirin use." 2/
According the study design manuscript, "minority recruitment has been challenging due to a ⬇️ number of minorities w/o prior cardiovascular events, disability or dementia, who are not taking aspirin, and a reluctance to cease aspirin..." 3/ ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/P…
"In addition, after an NIH moratorium on recruiting US Caucasians was enacted in 2011, there was increased hesitancy expressed by minorities regarding why ASPREE was only recruiting minorities..." 4/ ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/P…
"Facilitation of US minority participation led to a differential age inclusion criterion... due to a ⬆️ prevalence of exclusion criteria, a survival disadvantage and greater risk of other elements of the primary composite endpoint in minorities compared with non-minorities." 5/
In summary, the age-limit, a key outcome of this study was set lower for minority patients because they had:
1. ⬆️ baseline CVD 2. ⬆️ death from CVD 3. ⬆️ hesitancy to join the trial
Achieving #HealthEquity will be impossible without creative & multidisciplinary strategies. 6/6
P.S. What do these data mean for clinical care?
Should I discontinue aspirin in a Black/Hispanic patient >65 because it was too hard to recruit those patients?
Or because those patients have been shown to die earlier?
Are there really two standards for “elderly” in the U.S.?
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
As many have noted, one of the keys to addressing the racial disparities in #COVID19 is ensuring comprehensive race/ethnicity data. Yet, as late as mid-April, 22 states were still not reporting such data on mortality. Here's what else we found...
1/
As of April 21st, of the 28 states reporting race/ethnicity data related to #COVID19 mortality, we found significant variation in the quality of such reporting, with some states reporting as high as >40% missingness in these data.
2/
Among the states (any NYC) that reported race/ethnicity data, we estimated a 3.5-fold higher mortality rate in Blacks vs. whites and a nearly 2-fold higher mortality rate in the Latinx vs. white population.
"Now, emerging data illustrate that Black and Hispanic Americans are dying at far higher rates from Covid-19 than any other groups in the nation. These disparities are just the most recent manifestation of centuries’ worth of racial and ethnic gaps in health outcomes." 2/
"The prevalence of cardiometabolic disease in black and Hispanic communities has continued to rise. However, focusing on individual clinical factors may mislead from identifying the true root causes of racial and ethnic disparities observed in COVID-19 mortality." 3/
Before the grants are reviewed, the IRBs are submitted, the data are analyzed, and the manuscripts are in press, reporters will likely continue to shed light on the issues related to #COVID19 and #HealthEquity.
A thread of articles, to be daily updated, on this topic. 1/
"Public health experts caution that the nature of this virus means that inequality in health outcomes puts the entire population at risk. Pockets of people who are untested or don't get the appropriate medical treatment can quickly become new clusters." 2/ nytimes.com/interactive/20…
“What black folks are accustomed to in Milwaukee and anywhere in the country, really, is pain not being acknowledged and constant inequities that happen in health care delivery." Also quoted, the remarkable Dr. @CamaraJones. 2/
Thrilled to share my first VA paper (and first visual abstract!) with my all-star @vaequity@PittGIM mentor team, on racial and ethnic differences in the medical treatment of opioid use disorder within the VA following a non-fatal opioid overdose. 1/n
In case you missed it, @iamjohnoliver hosted an episode Sunday night on gender and racial bias in medicine. Here are a few of the studies on racial disparities he highlighted on the episode. 1/
@iamjohnoliver In a study of patients admitted to trauma centers in PA, authors found that patients admitted to hospitals with high concentrations of blacks had a 43% higher odds of death compared with patients admitted to hospitals treating low proportions of blacks. 2/ onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.11…
@iamjohnoliver In a well-cited 2016 paper, researchers found ~50% of medical students and residents surveyed reported at least one false belief about biological differences between blacks and whites (e.g. “black people’s skin is thicker than white people’s skin”). 3/ pnas.org/content/113/16…