'Biden's victory is a disastrous failure for Biden'
It's just so fucking transparent
I dont want to talk too much about this cos I'm very much not american.
But a lot of the reaction is through the frame of pre-election polls that turned out to be off.
For the Dems to win the Senate, in the states that were being run, they'd have needed a big poll lead.
But some people spent years saying that Trump was all but invincible - unless, of course, the Dems picked Sanders.
According to the Jacobin lot, he was a useless, rambling, senile old establishment sell-out who'd crash and burn.
Instead he is going to win.
A few words on Sanders, from a speculative perspective - again, I'm in the UK not the US.
I like Sanders. If I was a US Dem I'd have voted for him. Nothing I've ever written about Corbyn applies to Sanders.
But.
The primary polling showing him outperforming the other Dems in head to heads v Trump was based on enormous youth voting that didnt actually happen even in the primaries.
And US polling ought now to be treated with instinctive scepticism
He only came close to winning the nomination because he had so many rivals. He got nowhere near majority support.
His rivals rallied behind Biden. That was their right. If he couldnt win over Dem primary voters, why be so sure he'd win over disillusioned key state voters?
Could he have beaten Trump? Perhaps. We'll never know.
Its unlikely you'd have had the Lincoln Project types backing him - though we dont know how much impact they actually had.
You can be pretty sure Cubans and Venezuelans in Florida wouldn't have backed him.
Maybe his outsider, anti establishment pitch would have won over disillusioned white working class voters.
How many suburban votes heading to Biden would he have lost? Pass. Independent voters? Pass. We'll never know.
But good god, it's not exactly open and shut.
And bear in mind also, one of Sanders' key campaign strengths is big rallies.
None of that during Covid.
But even if Sanders had done all of that, won the primaries, won the White House, even won the Senate, he'd *still* have to negotiate with centrist Dem senators and deal with an inhospitable SCOTUS.
tldr: shutup Owen
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Nothing says ‘the left’ quite like the left treating a very possible victory like an abject defeat
ngl I spent all night watching CNN and frankly that seems to have left me in a much better mood than everyone who spent the night doomscrolling through this pit of mutual despair
Obv if Trump does win, that is an unmitigated disaster
The sheer shock of actions actually having consequences for members of the political class.
There is, I suppose, a question of the precise grounds on which he has been suspended, and whether they can form grounds for a more permanent severance.
After all, Starmer would look ridiculous if he had to back down. Having alienated the left, he’d just alienate everyone else.
As @jamesjohnson252 says, this will define Starmer in the eyes of the public, mostly favourably (‘strong’, ‘decisive’).
You’d have to think there’ll be a left wing breakaway party. But the history of the Socialist Labour Party and Respect bodes very badly for it.
I've been thinking through how a Corbyn government would have handled the coronavirus pandemic, and whether he would have done a better job of it than Boris Johnson.
TLDR: Almost certainly yes - but with caveats /1
First, it's important to consider the circumstances of a Corbyn government after GE19 - almost certainly a minority government, with some loose arrangement with the SNP and/or LDs, and with a great deal of wariness from many Labour MPs.
That imposes certain constraints /2
In addition, much of the right wing press would remain completely hostile, and other sections of the media would remain suspicious. There would be outright communists likely occupying positions of power as advisors. This would not be quietly accepted b opponents /3
The government’s problem so far in its handling of Cummings - apart from the obvious refusal to sack him - is they still think their Brexit ‘culture war’ strategy is operative. It isn’t. It hasn’t been at any stage in this pandemic. This, is, not, America.
First, this isn’t Brexit, which has happened anyway. Brexit itself has been detoxified somewhat - hence many Leavers say they’d accept an extension. Leavers’ trust in Boris has kept his ratings afloat during corona BUT that bond of trust isn’t as strong as Trump and the Trumpists
The American culture wars are founded heavily on religious fundamentalism and a view of ‘freedom’ that is deep rooted and frankly bonkers (gun nuts). Abortion, gay rights, seen as murder and hellfire. And Fox News making the Sun look like the Encyclopaedia Britannica.