Check out the article below. It outlines few current issues Jews face, when #IHRA definition of antisemitism, the most profound one, is applied. Critics bring straw arguments like “it doesn’t allow to criticize Israel without being called antisemitic” which is simply not true. 1/
https://twitter.com/stopantisemites/status/1335343628177301508
Jews are told they cannot define hate against them, because, you know, modern activists claim modern Jews do not have any empirical experience in surviving antisemitism, xenophobia, or racism since those are matters of the past and today Jews live privileged lives. Ridiculous? 2/
Yes, it is. The other reason why we cannot define the hate against us, because Israel is considered a huge obstacle to Jewish oppression. It simply doesn’t allow Jews to be oppressed as they used to be before in MENA, Europe, USSR, Africa & Asia. So Jews were reappointed to be 3/
oppressors. We are constantly told there is no huge danger to Jews as it used to be (statistics say otherwise). Additionally we are told more and more that only danger antisemitism has, is coming strictly from white supremacists and extreme right wing activists (Neo-Nazis). 4/
Jews are also reassigned in a different coordinate system that is unique to USA: white/non white binary choice is suddenly applied to Jews who never lived in USA or even stepped foot on its soil - Jews from Europe or USSR are suddenly reassigned the role of “white” which means 5/
American societal rules somehow should be applied to all Jews globally, including those across the ocean. I see it more and more among young activists, including also Jews. They feel entitled to define how other Jews shall live and how they should be treated. Amazing audacity. 6/
I also reject the notion that American Jews should be somehow put in simplistic boxes of “privileged/not privileged” in USA, primarily because each and every Jew in USA has own history of arrival, struggles, antisemitism, racism and hatred, even if they are what those college 7/
activists call “white passing”. Do people have privileges in USA? Privilege isn’t a static phenomenon, it’s quite dynamic. The same person can have privilege in some matters and no privileges in others. Within one day person can get it on both ends. Brushing Jews as people who 8/
live with flying colors in USA without fear of bullying, hatred, attacks and hate crimes is distortion of the reality. Not once or twice I heard stories Jews had to hide their Jewishness and not only from right wing bigots, but also from left wing progressives. Does it sound 9/
like a story of privilege? Few success stories like Jews who started large companies, succeeded in business, movie industry or politics are not an indicator of the community in whole. USA has millions of Jews and super successful make only a tiny fraction of our population. 10/
Anyway, back to dangers of antisemitism of white supremacists vs left wing antisemitism. While former pose a great danger, they are definitely not the only one who does it. Antisemitism is completely normalized under the guise of antizionism in Academia among professors and 11/
students, among activists (examples are too numerical here), journalists (Twitter is swamped with it) and now politicians (sadly, the UK and US are showing us a negative trend). I am a Soviet Jew. I know what antizionism did to my grandparents, parents and in part to my life. 12/
Learning history of USSR, its law and state system as my university degree I had to learn a lot about things the country did, and even though I and my family experienced the magnitude of antizionism firsthand, even I couldn’t comprehend the scale of hateful politics that USSR 13/
was applying to Jews - basically USSR broadcasted a new form of institutional racism and placed it into minds of radical activists all over the world. Modern antizionists are neither unique nor modern. We saw that in 30s, 40s, 50s, 60s, 70s & 80s. USSR was exporting the same 14/
very ideas which perpetuated hate against Jews, took many lives and put even more lives of Jews in diaspora in danger. Jews who chose to be antizionist today are either ignorant of the history that Soviet Jews have already learned the hard way, or willfully vile and selective 15/
in what they want antizionism (and Zionism) to mean. Either way, if you are an antizionist, no wonder Zionist Jews oppose you. Those who came before modern antizionists sided with those who were oppressing us, who wanted all Jews in Israel dead (but dead under a progressive 16/
label, to sweeten the end). Supporting antizionism is supporting a process of normalizing antisemitism. What pains me more is to see a number of Jews here who willfully joined antizionism. As popular phrase goes: they are trying to feed a crocodile in a hope to be eaten last. 17/
So, if you are an antizionist Jew who thinks you are leading a cool brand new youth movement that never happened before, and you will be liked and lauded by non-Jewish antizionists forever... look at these 3 faces. Then google Yefim Tsetlin, Oscar Ryvkin and Lazar Shatskin. 18/18 
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
