Large Farmers to Middle men to Large Farmers - The vicious cycle

Punjab is an agriculturally developed but land scarce economy. The ownership of land is an economic asset and carries a social prestige in the society. The small farmers find it difficult to keep their land intact.
The number of operational holdings in the state was 11.17 lakh in 1990-91, which declined to 9.97 lakh in 2000-01. The picture of small farmers (< 5 acres of land) was very precarious as their number has declined from 5 lakh to about 3 lakh during this period.
This shows that about 2 lakh small farmers have either leased out or sold their entire land or part of it. A report on the status of farmers who left farming in Punjab states that out of 2 lakh families who left farming, about 36 per cent families have sold their entire land
whereas another 11.4 per cent families have sold part of their land.
The field survey of the Research study from which I am quoting these reveals that about 10 per cent farmers sold their means of production including land, tractor, farm implements and other assets like
livestock, gold ornaments, and trees to repay the loan. Some of these farmers sold their assets even at distress prices due to the continuous pressure of the commission agents. Another recent field survey on ‘land market in rural Punjab’ reveals that in land sold to
commission agents by the farmers, the buyers were largely non- traditional commission agents. This is a new trend of purchasing land of the farmers by the commission agents. The traditional commission agents are least interested in purchasing the land of the farmers;
if they purchase, they try to recover their disbursed amount by diverting it through the large farmers under some specific mechanism. Sometimes, they extend the financial support to the medium and large farmers for purchasing the land of indebted farmers.
In this way, they recover their loan ‘on paper’ merely by diverting these loans from the distressed peasantry towards medium and large farmers.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Krishna Kumar Murugan

Krishna Kumar Murugan Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ikkmurugan

9 Dec
Fuel Dynamics: Is India really bad on fuel price?

Taxes on Retail Fuel Price

🇮🇳 India - 69%
🇫🇷 France - 64%
🇩🇪 Germany - 64%
🇬🇧 Britain - 62%
🇪🇸 Spain - 53%
🇯🇵 Japan - 47%
🇨🇳 China - 38%
🇨🇦 Canada - 33%
Crude Oil Import as a % on Overall consumption

🇪🇸 Spain - 100%
🇩🇪 Germany - 97%
🇮🇳 India - 80%
🇯🇵 Japan - 78%
🇫🇷 France - 64%
🇨🇳 China - 60%
🇨🇦 Canada - 56%
🇬🇧 Britain - 11%
Total Oil Consumption in bbl/day

🇨🇳 China - 14,056,000
🇮🇳 India - 5,271,000
🇯🇵 Japan - 3,812,000
🇩🇪 Germany - 2,281,000
🇨🇦 Canada - 2,403,000
🇫🇷 France - 1,530,000
🇪🇸 Spain - 1,226,000
🇬🇧 Britain - 1,118,000
Read 12 tweets
7 Dec
After AAP sacking YoYa in 2015, he started campaigning for Farmers in Haryana & Punjab. Gave a lot of interviews during this period till 2019 Lok Sabha election.

No mention of Middlemen in any of these interviews. Not even once.

All his interviews focused only on increasing MSP
He spoke of everything except middlemen in this interview in 2018. Demonetisation affected but no mention of middlemen anywhere google.co.in/amp/s/amp.scro…
Farmers want guaranteed income but no mention of middlemen again google.co.in/amp/s/www.down…
Read 14 tweets
5 Dec
The Arhtiyas (Middlemen) of Punjab

The Arhtiyas of Punjab are political connected.

In July 2017, in a public function the Arhyiyas felicitated Amarinder Singh with the title of ‘Fakhr-e-Quam’(Pride of the Community).
Post that function, the CM had said it would be difficult to waive off the debt owed by farmers to the arhtiyas.

As many as 86% of farmer & 80% of agricultural labours are mired in debt, says a study on Indebtedness among Farmers & Agricultural Labourers in Rural Punjab.
Its authors, researchers at Punjabi University, Patiala, say over a fifth of that debt was owed to commission agents and moneylenders.

No less than 8,294 farmers took their own lives between 2000 & 2015, says a study presented last year before the Vidhan Sabha’s Committee.
Read 14 tweets
3 Dec
Will Rajini’s entry affect DMK or ADMK or both?

☀️ DMK got 22.5% Votes-1991
☀️ DMK got 42.1% Votes-1996
☀️ DMK got 30.9% Votes-2001
☀️ DMK got 26.5% Votes-2006

🍃 ADMK got 44.4% Votes-1991
🍃 ADMK got 21.5% Votes-1996
🍃 ADMK got 31.4% Votes-2001
🍃 ADMK got 32.6% Votes-2006
Votes Polled
🗳 1991 - 2.5 Cr
🗳 1996 - 2.8 Cr
🗳 2001 - 2.8 Cr
🗳 2006 - 3.3 Cr

How many votes did DMK & ADMK get when they lost?

🍃1991 - ADMK - 1.11 Cr
☀️1996 - DMK - 1.18 Cr
🍃 2001 - ADMK - 88 L
☀️ 2006 - DMK - 87 L
How many votes did DMK & ADMK get when they lost?

☀️1991 - DMK - 55 L
🍃1996 - ADMK - 60 L
☀️2001 - DMK - 86 L
🍃 2006 - ADMK - 107 L

ADMK lost 51 Lakh votes in 96, DMK lost 38 Lakh votes in 2001.

In 2006, DMK just gained 1 lakh votes & ADMK gained 30 Lakh votes but DMK won
Read 18 tweets
30 Nov
Farm Bill politics Thread:

Indian Food grain Production for the year 19-20: Top 5 states

🚜 Haryana : 17.8 Lakh Tons
🚜 Rajasthan : 23.2 Lakh Tons
🚜 Punjab : 29.9 Lakh Tons
🚜 Madhya Pradesh : 33 Lakh Tons
🚜 Uttar Pradesh : 55 Lakh Tons

Protests only in Punjab
Gross Value Added: Agri & Allied Industries (GVA is Selling - Production Cost)

₹ in Lakh Crores

🚜 Punjab: 0.9

States with less output but more profits than Punjab.

🚜 Maha : 1.9
🚜 AP: 1.8
🚜 WB: 1.4
🚜 TN : 1.2

Who is eating all the profits in Punjab?
Reasons for Farmer Protests only in Punjab:

⚡️ Middlemen left out - Huge revenue loss
⚡️ 1800 Mandi tax per year is gone
⚡️ Akali dal split in two; they want to use this to counter the insurgency
⚡️ Khalistan separatists looking for a launch pad
⚡️ State ruled by congress
Read 12 tweets
25 Nov
2016 Assembly Election: How BJP Damaged DMK’s chances. DMK can expect triple the damage now.

1. Coimbatore North: DMK lost to AIADMK. Winning margin was 7724 Votes. BJP got 16741 votes.

2. Coimbatore South: INC lost to AIADMK. Winning margin was 17419 Votes. BJP got 33113 votes
3. Hosur: INC lost to AIADMK. Winning margin was 22964 Votes. BJP got 28850 votes.

4. Kavundanpalayam : DMK lost to AIADMK. Winning margin was 8025 Votes. BJP got 22444 votes.

5. Kinathukadavu : DMK lost to AIADMK. Winning margin was 1332 Votes. BJP got 11354 votes.
6. Radhapuram: DMK lost to AIADMK. Winning margin was 49 Votes. BJP got 11131 votes.

7. Srivaikuntam: INC lost to AIADMK. Winning margin was 3531 Votes. BJP got 9582 votes.

8. Tenkasi: INC lost to AIADMK. Winning margin was 462 Votes. BJP got 11716 votes.
Read 9 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!