Been 2+hrs since High Court judge Alex Led granted bail to @JimmyLaiApple , Lai is yet to be allowed to leave court as prosecutors immediately applied for certificate to appeal the bail at Court of Final Appeal and are now cross examining Lai’s ensurers...
All reporters and public members were asked to leave the courtroom as judge decided that the cross examination of ensurers shall be closed door hearing due to privacy concern.

While waiting , we may review the highly uncommon bail conditions @JimmyLaiApple has to undertake ...
1) huge amount of bond money

@JimmyLaiApple has to deposit HKD 10 million cash for the 2 allegations of defraud and collusion with foreign forces. And his three ensurers will in total deposit HKD300,000 for the 2 allegations.
2) De facto house arrest

Lai’s legal team proposed and was granted the condition that Lai would be confined to residential premises during all time on bail except for reporting three times a week to police and attending court hearing.
3) Right of speech completely denied

Part of @JimmyLaiApple undertakings is that he shall NOT make any public statement, take any interview, and make any social media, Twitter included, post, which is more restricted than speech conditions for those in prison.
4) Rough cut of overseas connections

Promising no reoffence, @JimmyLaiApple are not allowed to meet any foreign government officials and not engaged directly or indirectly in any exchange with overseas entities and individuals that could be reasonably considered as lobbying...
...for sanctions, blockage and other hostile activities against PRC and HKSAR.

Some may quickly draw the conditions in parallel to the “residence under surveillance in designated venue” 指定地點監視居住 , a notorious form of secret detention often used by...
...law enforcers in mainland China particularly when handling dissidents and activists.

However harsh the bail conditions for @JimmyLaiApple are, it’s NOT YET “residence under surveillance in designated venue” (RSDV) Because...

1) RSDV is not carried out in one’s own home
2) During RSDV one is denied access to meetings with relatives and legal team

3) During RSDV, one is subject to law enforcers interrogation, which reportedly often involves physical and mental torture

Open court resumes now. Updates come later.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Xinqi Su 蘇昕琪

Xinqi Su 蘇昕琪 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @XinqiSu

24 Dec
On Wednesday mainland Chinese human rights lawyer Lu Siwei who has been working on the case of the #12HKers detained in Shenzhen despite authorities' threats produced 10 Q&A on the case in Chinese as trial is near.

Translate most of them in this #thread:
Q1: What now as family-hired lawyers can’t work on the case?

Family-hired lawyers should continue to submit representation to Yantian’s court and demand reading the case docs. Meanwhile families should demand gov-assigned lawyers to leave the case otherwise they will sue.
Q2: Should Yantian prosecutors provide indictments for defendants’ relatives?

Procuratorates are not required to do so in mainland's laws but defense lawyers should provide copies of the indictments and explain the content, legal basis to the families.
Read 23 tweets
1 Dec
Wong Lai-ping, deputy chief of China news of iCable, said management made lay-off decision without consulting unit heads. Szeto Yuen, China news chief, had decided in advance that he would resign if any one in his team got fired. The rest of team decided to follow Szeto's lead.
China news deputy Wong Lai-ping's voice began to shake when she recalled how iCable ignored the efforts her team paid despite pay cut.

"We went to Wuhan when other news stations evacuated; We never missed one day of news despite manpower crunch under quarantine..."
Wong said the parachuted management "had rather hostile attitudes towards the newsroom", and what happened today has crossed the journos' bottom line although "we had been putting up with everything, hoping it would be our last compromise".
Read 5 tweets
1 Dec
An avalanche is taking place in iCable News, HK's best non-state-owned TV newsroom.

To protest against the short-noticed firing of 40 staff including the award-winning investigative team News Lancet, full China news team and heads of local, financial, intl news have resigned.
Rounds of meetings between staff and parachuted management have taken place but none yielded any meaningful explanation to the decision of chopping away journos who are considered the best and fastest by their peers.
The line-to-take of the management is that the company has to lay off redundancies due to financial difficulties under #covid19 and needs of restructuring. Yet, why started from the best, remains a question unanswered.
Read 13 tweets
16 Nov
The 25-say death inquest for ex-HKUST student #AlexChow kicked off today with Chow’s father and a female police commander being the first two called to the witness stand.

For the first time in slightly over one year, Chow’s parents appeared in public and Chow’s father spoke...
...about Alex, his only child with his wife Lee Lai-lai.

Alex was founding lying in a puddle of blood on the ground of Carpark A of Sheung Tak Estate in Tseung Kwan O in the midnight between 3&4 Nov. He was certified dead in the morning of 8 Nov, nearly three months...
...after his 22nd birthday. Around the time Alex fell in the carpark, riot police were dispersing protesters in Sheung Tak areas, deploying tear gas and other anti-riot weapons. After Alex’s death, the Operation Dawn citywide roadblocking protests soon reached its climax, when...
Read 22 tweets
13 Oct
Mainland lawyer Lu Siwei working on the case of #12HKers issued a new legal opinions, saying:

1) He expects the Shenzhen prosecutors not to extend detention for investigation beyond the 2 months' limit

2) He expects the 2 underaged among the 12 won't be prosecuted as...
...the prosecutors are allowed by China's laws not to and it fulfils international conventions

3) He suggests that families have rights to information, communications and meetings, and they may ask HK's delegates to Beijing to discharge their duties...
...by demanding Yantian authorities to correct their wrongs via the Ministry of Public Security and the Supreme People's Procuratorate

At the end of his opinion, Lu wrote:

"The 8.23 illegal border crossing case is nothing more than a very ordinary case. However...
Read 6 tweets
12 Oct
#JUSTIN #CarrieLam said she told LegCo president this morning that she has to postpone pronouncement of Policy Address originally set on Wednesday morning. Lam said this arrangement is legally sound as it's up to CE to determine the day according to LegCo ordinance.
#CarrieLam said she has to postpone Policy Address because she just got a notification from Beijing asking her to pay a visit to the central government later this month, likely after 20 October, to seek approval of certain policies and projects
#CarrieLam said a HK government delegation led by her will set off to Shenzhen later today. Members of the delegation include Financial Secretary, Secretary for Justice, Security Secretary, Mainland Affairs Secretary, Innovation Secretary, and Chief Executive Office Director.
Read 9 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!