The Doctor : "Do I have the right? Simply touch one wire against the other and that's it. The Daleks cease to exist. Hundreds of millions of people, thousands of generations can live without fear... in peace, and never even know the word "Dalek"."

#DoctorWho on ethics Image
You might think "Of course I would wipe out the Daleks" but the Doctor steps it deeper. Are his orders to do so just? What about all the unions and bridges made between others in the struggle against the Daleks? Does he have the right? Is it right? What does it do to him? Image
NuWho would revisit this "Have I the right" decades later, this time with John Hurt as the Doctor (or whatever name he went by).

There is also the plot device that some things are 'fixed' in time, like Adric's death, and must be. Image
#doctorwho Genesis of the Daleks

The Timelords gave the Doctor 3 victory conditions

Prevent the Genesis of the Daleks
Or
Make them evolve into a less brutal species
Or
Find (or make) a weakness to combat them

The last sounds like a thermal exhaust port idea ImageImage
The Daleks are eugenics loving cultish Nazis, which reminds me of the #StarTrek episode, Patterns of Force, that made not the least attempt to hide their Nazi story

"We were betrayed by a self-seeking adventurer who has led us all to the very brink of disaster." - Professor Gill Image
KIRK: He drew the wrong conclusion from history. The problem with the Nazis wasn't simply that their leaders were evil, psychotic men. They were, but the main problem, I think, was the leader principle. Image
Genesis of the Daleks gives us another such cultist, eugenics loving leader in Davros.

A plot point is that the species, due to generations of war, is cascading genetically, mutating. Davros himself is notably different in a society fixated on purity (like a Voldemort) Image
The Daleks were created (conceptually) by Terry Nation (below), who also wrote Genesis of the Daleks.

The Dalek design came from Raymond Cusick, who never got much credit for his design. Image
Note that Davros controls what is and is not 'fact' to his faction, but abandons his edicts as it suits him.

He is offered a challenge to make the Daleks a force for good, but is not interested.

He quickly grasps the power the Doctors foreknowledge is. Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Jeffs Comics

Jeffs Comics Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @jeffs_comics

22 Jan
Gives ya chills, doesn't it?

From the 1928 film, The Man Who Laughs, an adaptation of the Victor Hugo novel.

So, if asked "Who created the Joker, Batman's arch foe?", perhaps Victor Hugo and the people behind this movie deserve a nod.
Here is an article that says Finger, Kane and Robinson did credit the film, specifically a still of Veidt in makeup as Gwynplaine, for the inspiration.

Funny that Universal did not remake this film as a talkie (it did get a release with sync music)

northparktheatre.org/the-man-who-la…
A few images from the book or the movie.

The book was published in 1869, and is set in England during the time surrounding the brief turbulent reign of Catholic James II. The mutiliation of the protagonist is a symbol for what society is doing to people. ImageImage
Read 6 tweets
21 Jan
My First Adventure with Mary Poppins

This is my first time going through P.L. Traver's book, Mary Poppins (The first in a series). I grew up with the Disney film, so it brings up the differences in adaptations, particularly in how Disney softened Mary Poppins. Image
In this first book, Mary Poppins is not there to fix anything really. She just, well, "Pops in". She is stern, aloof, vain, curt and, quite honestly, a liar in that she fervently denies several of the adventures with Jane and Michael ever happening. Image
The version of the book I went through is not the original 1934 version. The chapter called "Bad Tuesday" originally had Mary Poppins, Jane and Michael visiting people in different parts of the globe. Criticism about stereotypes prompted Travers to revise it in 1967... Image
Read 7 tweets
18 Sep 20
How does Close Encounters of the Third Kind stand for you?

Meh? Good? Great? Spielberg's Greatest?

I can give you some of my feelings on it
My threads of this type can get a dozen tweets or longer, and be built over several hours as I pop on and off Twitter.

Please interject anytime if it catches your interest, or check in again in a few hours to see a more complete post.

Let's cast off
Now the Gizmondo article discusses how Spielberg both wrote and directed this film and how its emotionally level throughout.

In a way, its a Columbo episode. There is never a "Oh, the aliens *are* real" moment. We know that from the start, liking knowing Robert Culp did it.
Read 40 tweets
31 Aug 20
How to Pick your Next Read
1: Walking the Aisle

You have a basic idea of what you want to read, now you walk the aisle and feel the Muse. Maybe its the spine, or the condition, or the cover or the color. Something inspires you to reach for ...that...book...
How to Pick your Next Read
2: Browse the online market

Whether its an online bookseller or a library, you just browse it all from your comfy chair, and never worry about how many books you can actually carry (or read).
How to Pick your Next Read
3: Fix the immediate need

You are looking for solutions. From minor repairs to planning a wedding to getting a mortgage or writing a resume. You need some solutions to the problems that you are worried about right now.
Read 32 tweets
25 May 20
How about a little #ShakespeareSunday with #StarTrek

The Conscience of the King

Just the 13th episode, a fit number for this tragedy.

It originally aired December 8, 1966

A sad tale is best for Winter

(art by juan ortiz)
The episode begins with a murder - the on stage murder by Macbeth, as played by actor Anton Karidian (a play on Carradine?).

Arnold Moss is the actor playing the actor. A veteran of Shakespeare and Broadway, his voice oozes gravitas.
This episode is wonderful #startrek in exploring moral issues, but in some ways its very much not Star Trek.

By that, I mean there is very little scifi or science fantasy here. Its a script that could be adapted easily to other settings. You can argue thats deliberate.
Read 40 tweets
8 May 20
Close-up of Action Comics 43 (cover date Dec, 1941)

While America isn't in the War yet, Superman is on this great cover by Fred Ray of Harrisburg, PA in his first year of doing Action covers.

This Superman - part flying, part leaping, still defines how I see Superman in flight.
The Superfriends cartoon was inconsistent in how it showed Superman in flight, but I always liked the bent leg and one arm forward look.

That is how my Mego Superman always flew
I know conversations of created or co-created a character can create controversy, but consider the corollary of continued creation.

Fred Ray was mostly a cover artist, but came early to Superman, redesigning the S emblem and creating covers like this one.
Read 22 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!