What is economic complexity? And how it is helping us understand the economy? More than a decade ago, two papers helped ignite the field. Today, I am publishing the first comprehensive review of Economic Complexity in Nature Review Physics (thread) 1/N
nature.com/articles/s4225…
I start from two findings: relatedness and complexity. Relatedness measures the overall affinity between an activity and a location, and can explain path dependencies and the activities that will grow or decline. /2
Complexity metrics are dimensionality reduction techniques (common in machine learning) that can identify the combinations of factors that best explain the geography of multiple economic activities. /3
These two ideas involve the use of machine learning methods to understand economic development. Originally (in 2007 and 2009), this seemed farfetched, but we have since learned how to connect these ideas with traditional economic models. /4
Economic complexity is tightly related to the idea of a production function, but instead of assuming the nature of factors (e.g. capital, labor), complexity metrics learn the factors directly from the data (this box unpacks the basic math). /5
This is profound, since it provides a means to explain the geography of thousands of economic activities, using production functions, but without assuming what the factors are. /6
Relatedness metrics are similar to recommender system, but instead of measuring the affinity between a user and a product, they do so between locations and activities. During the last decades, economic geographers have validated relatedness in a variety of settings. /7
This makes relatedness a new baseline model in economic geography. It requires variables attempting to predict or explain changes in the geography of an activity to go beyond what we can explain using a relatedness baseline. /8
There are of course some common misconceptions. People confuse metrics of complexity with metrics of diversification (even though they are technically orthogonal), or think of economic complexity and relatedness as exports or trade specific concepts. /9
This is not true. In the last decade the ideas of relatedness and complexity have been translated well to datasets on different activities (industries, occupations, patents, papers), and for many different geographic units (cities, regions, countries). /10
So where are these fields right now?
The study of relatedness has focused on unpacking it into multiple channels. Several studies have measured relatedness with different datasets to see what channels contribute more to explaining the entry and exit of economic activities. /11
People have also used interactions with relatedness to try to identify path-breaking development policies (although the effects tend to be small despite being significant). /12
Economic complexity has also been expanded to multiple areas of application. People have shows that complexity metrics explain variations in economic growth, income inequality, and carbon emissions. /13
People have also looked at the factors that explain changes in complexity, from institutions and demography to FDI, transportation, and internet access. /14
Economic complexity is still young, but it is showing a path forward to understand economic geography by combining tools from machine learning & statistics. I look forward to the future developments of what has been fifteen years of exciting work. //

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with César A. Hidalgo

César A. Hidalgo Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @cesifoti

9 Dec 20
This semester I had the pleasure to teach data visualization studio at an elite US university. Many students were interested in social justice (being 2020 in the US). Yet, many approached the topic in a way that was a bit naive ... (thread🧵) /1
Their instincts were to create projects that "brought attention to the issue." But since this was a hands-on class, where students had to build instead of arguing, we had to push them beyond these first instincts. /2
The class required them to go beyond stating the problem, or assigning blame. They not only had to suggest a solution, they had to implement it. And in that act of making, is where the deepest lessons took place. /3
Read 14 tweets
7 Nov 20
Map Time!
So you’ve seen a lot of maps in the last few days. What maps work, which ones don’t, and how to think about them? Time for a thread ! /1
To begin, let’s go through some data visualization basics. Data visualization, is the use of graphical metaphors to represent quantities. The fact that visualization are metaphors, however, is often forgotten. 2/
Think of a scatter plot showing age vs income. Age is measured in years. Income in dollars, but in a scatter plot they are both represented in inches (a spatial metaphor!). 3/
Read 17 tweets
5 Nov 20
Biden squeezing by to win the 2020 election like...

But in all earnest there are a few lessons we all need to reflect on (thread). 1/
1. The election will leave many people unsatisfied. With 71+ million votes for Biden, and 68+ million votes for Trump, this is the largest number of votes casted in a US presidential election (Biden is the most voted ever). Yet, a 270-268 victory is unsatisfying in two accounts:
It will of course be unsatisfying to the 68+ million Americans who voted for Trump. But those who voted for Biden expected a repudiation of Trump’s government & a landslide win. That didn’t happen. This is America.
Read 9 tweets
17 Oct 20
Today I am leaving the US.
With my family we are exploring a new life in the south of France.
I’ve been in the US for more than 16 years. I earned my citizenship & experienced many ups & downs. But I am grateful. The US was good to me in many ways ...
/1
I published 3 books & about 60 academic papers. I started a company that employs dozens of people & has clients throughout the world. I ran a lab for 9 years at one of the countries top universities. I was invited to the main stage of Ted and to Davos.
/2
I met millionaires, billionaires, movie stars, & rock stars. I had my work published in “The Times.” I hanged out with Nobel prize winners in their darkest moments. I experienced hype & betrayal. I saw the belly of the beast, from the inside, as I rose, fell, & stood up again. /3
Read 24 tweets
5 Sep 20
He visto este tuit varias veces. Lamentablemente, la tesis que presenta no es correcta. Holanda es un gran RE-exportador de productos vegetales, y su volumen exportador se explica por logística, no agricultura. Veamos los datos? (1/N) 🧵
oec.world/en/profile/bil…
1. Holanda si exporta muchos productos vegetales (USD 29.4B el 2018, 3ero en el 🌎), pero importa mucho (USD 21.7B, 4to en el 🌎). La población de Holanda no explica este volumen importador. Lo que pasa es que productos agr. entran a granel en los puertos y salen empaquetados.
Por ejemplo, Holanda exporta mas bananas (si, estas que no crecen en Holanda), que Mexico, Honduras, o la Rep. Dominicana! (Belgica es incluso mas bananero) oec.world/en/profile/hs9…
oec.world/en/profile/bil…
Read 10 tweets
2 Sep 20
La complejidad económica ha sido debatida en Chile las ultimas semanas. Lamentablemente, incluso los expertos entienden poco que es la complejidad o como se mide. Acá un hilo y un artículo aclarando varios malos entendidos. ciperchile.cl/2020/09/01/mit… (1/N)
Mito 1: La complejidad económica es equivalente a la diversificación exportadora.
FALSO!
La complejidad económica es técnicamente perpendicular a la diversificación o concentración de exportaciones.
Mito 2: La complejidad económica es una medida de las exportaciones.
FALSO.
La complejidad económica se ha estimado usando datos de empleo, patentes, salarios, etc. a nivel de municipio o estado para muchos países. Complejidad y exportaciones son cosas muy distintas.
Read 11 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!