Sorry I am late to this today. Here is your Niagara weekly deep dive into the local #COVID19 data.
We'll start with the basics: New cases remain in the 20s and for only the second time in just over a month, no new deaths reported today. (thread)
The downward trend in new cases & cases continues. Today's new cases are up from yesterday, but remember we don't get too hung up on one day's data. It is the trend we are interested in.
So on that point, notice the rounding trend of the infection curve. It hasn't reached that flat, plateau that we want to see when infections are no longer rising, but it is absolutely showing a leaving off trend.
Also of note, hospitalizations and outbreaks are not increasing. They have not really fallen significantly this week, but they are not piling up like they had been. Also, as of just a moment ago @niagarahealth reports its facilities are #COVID19 free.
Looking just at new cases per day, you can see Niagara is looking a lot like it did in November, albeit the infection trend is going the other way.
First, there is the ongoing issue of #COVID19 deaths. No deaths today is a good thing, but there are 72 people 80+ and 88 people over 60 currently fighting the virus. They are the ones most at risk. public.flourish.studio/visualisation/…
At least 353 Niagara residents with #COVID19 have died, giving Niagara one of the highest pandemic death rates, and highest number of total deaths, of any region in Ontario:
So if the province's plan to reopen goes ahead over the objection of medical experts next week, where will Niagara be in the rainbow of #COVID19 restrictions? A bit hard to tell, but here are the key metrics the province claims it monitors to make these decisions:
Looking first at cases per 100,000, Niagara is still well above the red zone threshold, which if this was the measuring stick, but would Niagara into the grey lockdown zone.
Of note here, is that in early Dec. when the cases per 100,000 reached the max threshold for red zone, local health leaders asked Niagara to be moved from orange to red to try and blunt the coming crisis. The province did not listen.
Looking at the percentage of positive #COVID19 tests, this number is also falling but at the max threshold for the orange zone, meaning it puts Niagara in the red.
The most encouraging metric is the reproductive number (the number of people a single infected person will get sick.) If that number is 1 or higher, your cases are going to increase. Below one they are decreasing. Right now it is below one:
None of the metrics can tell the tale on their own, they need to be considered together. Another important metric is % of cases with no origin. It sits at 63%, a result in part to public health contact tracing being so overwhelmed detailed investigations are not possible.
This means public health has a very hard time understanding where cases are arising from. And if they do not know what, they cannot take appropriate actions to break the trains of virus transmission.
Watch for a full update on this data and what it might mean for Niagara next week in @StCatStandard later this afternoon.
Be safe, be smart, and be kind.
-30-
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The political #COVID19 debate has heated up in Niagara, on social media at least, with people attacking @mustafahirji and at least one regional councillor caught between questioning the MoH, pushing back against those who threaten to vote her out and pushing misinformation.
In a local hospitality Facebook page that has a lot of cross over with an anti-masker group, people are calling @mustafahirji names, calling for him to be fired and representing the data. Welland reg. coun, Leanna Villella is in the thick of it.
A couple of things to note about what the councillor says here.
The first is that the MoH does not "override" the province. The authority of an MoH is CREATED by provincial law. When an MoH issues a sec. 22 order, it is under his/her authority as granted by the province.
So, some folks and politicians are reacting today's grey zone news by saying, in effect, "cases are very low, we should be red or orange zone."
This overstates where Niagara is, underestimates the 2nd wave, and redefines "low" when it comes to #COVID19 cases. (thread)
So let's look at some data. This chart is very helpful, looking at new cases per day, and can be a useful way to track the general path of the pandemic locally.
"Not having those vaccines in time created the perfect storm," says @WSendzik, in talking about how Niagara's second #COVID19 wave claimed so many lives.
The mayor says "we have really got a handle on #COVID19."
This is not what yesterday's science table modelling showed, which indicated that without strong measures in place, we are headed for a spring 3rd wave.
The mayor is correct when he says the infection rate locally has dropped considerably in recent weeks. But as my reporting later today will show, that drop is VERY recent and @mustafahirji says he has to be pushed down further still.
Big congrats to the team at @cbcfifth for their doc on police accountability and the local cop-on-cop shooting in Niagara. Bit a professional thrill to be part of an episode on an investigative news show I grew up watching and was inspired by! (thread)
It is a truism in journalism that the work done, day in and day out by local, daily newspaper journalists is relied on by our broadcast counterparts for their work, often forming part of the spine of their own investigations.
So, I want to talk about the story we published today about Niagara's deadliest #COVID19 weekend. 22 confirmed deaths in 48 hours. By any stretch, a tragedy that should wound a community deeply. So let's chat a bit. Pull up a chair.
So let's consider that number. 22 people. That is 22 people with names. Families. Friends. They contributed. And despite what the anti-maskers will tell you, they had lives that had value and meaning. Their loss should impact us all. 22 people in 48 hours.
On today's @fordnation#COVID19 update, Doug Ford will not say if health care workers who refuse to vaccinated will still be allowed to work in high-risk setting likes LTC homes. @celliottability also will not say if they will be able to work with vulnerable populations.
Gen. Hillier is asked about another diverted shipment of Moderna vaccines in another community, and again does not answer the question, speaking about the vaccination program generally.
For context, Niagara lost a shipment of Moderna that was diverted elsewhere without any explanation and no one in @fordnation's government will answer questions about it. Also for context 22 Niagara residents with #COVID19 died over the last three days.