I've got some questions for non-native japanese speakers/learners (natives are welcome to contribute to this thread, too).
It's about 漢語 vocab if there is a possibility to learn it without dull rote memorisation. It's a topic I've been thinking about since years.
Thread 1/x.
First of all: I speak five languages. 2 germanic (german native, english learned), 2 slavic (slovene native, serbocroatian learned) and have some okay-ish passive command of italian/spanish.
And, of course, Japanese.
I honestly can't even remember how I really learned english and serbo-croatian. It just "kinda happened".
Well, of course I know what helped: They are similar languages, so the amount of vocab and grammar I had to learn anew was comperatively low.
Example:
The english "table". Even without ever hearing it, I instantly knew the meaning, especially when context was given: "Let's sit at the table".
There is the german word "Tafel", which today mostly means "Blackboard", but also has the archaic meaning of "table".
The same goes for slovenian and serbo-croatian.
And for romance languages? Well, there is Latin. "Politica e una cosa difficile" means "Politics is a difficult cause" or "Politik ist eine diffizile Causa" if I translate it into strange, but understandable german/english.
Result: I understand romance languages to a certain degree thanks to Latin.

But now, let's turn to Japanese.
Of course, JP is not an indo-germanic language, so there is next to zero vocab which I can infer the meaning by comparing words to another language, except katakana words
Well, that's just how it is, so if course one has to memorize a big chunk of vocab to become conversational. From this, one can infer the meaning of a lot of native japanese words without bigger problems.
Example: 読む + 終わる = 読み終わる = to finish reading.
Easy, isn't it?
Even if one would hear those native japanese words for the first time in a conversation, there would be no problem at all to know the meaning.

BUT!

Then there is what I call "Random Onyomi-Chaos".
What's that? Let's take the word 救急車. Imagine you've never heard/read this word and it suddenly comes up in a convers.
It's made up of three On'yomi, which could belong to a big number of Kanji.
So without seeing how it's written, how in the world can anyone guess the meaning?
It could be written 旧急者, 級糾社, or simply just 急救車.
If the word would instead be 急いで救う車: I would instantly know what it means.
But without looking it up, I find myself guessing Kanji "from context" far too often. Not good, when you're in the middle of a conversation
So I was wondering: Am I the only one with this problem?
I have the impression that this is never adressed from a linguistic/language-teaching perspective. How come??

Happy to hear all your thoughts.
And yes, this and exactly this is the final boss of the Japanese language for me.
Random On'yomi stacked upon each other without having a clue which Kanji they belong to.
And yes, I actually DO have a okay-ish command of 漢語. The thing is: I acquired this knowledge mostly by rote memorisation of random syllables derived from ancient chinese which belong to certain Kanji. This just feels like a very odd and unnatural way of language acquisition.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Gregor Wakounig

Gregor Wakounig Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Gregor_Wakounig

14 Jan
Leugnung bzw. auch Glorifizierung des Faschismus ist in Japan Staatsideologie.

"Korea war nie 1 Kolonie Japans. Zwangsarbeit, Deportationen, Vergewaltigungen, Entführungen und Folter gab es nicht".
So Ex-Außenminister und derzeitiger LDP-Abgeordneter Masahisa Sato am 12.1.2020.
Man stelle sich vor, ein/e hochrangige/r deutsche PolitikerIn würde einfach so sagen: "Deutschland hat Polen nie überfallen. Es gab keine Zwangsarbeiter. Es gab keine Konzentrationslager und keine Gaskammern. Alles Lüge".
Natürlich hat Masahisa Sato auch beste Verbindungen in die extreme Rechte. So versuchte er 2011 mit Nobuyuki Suzuki (Bild), Chef der offen faschistischen "National Party of Japan", auf die koreanische Insel Jukdo zu reisen, Propaganda für JP Gebietsansprüche.

"Versuchte"??
Read 4 tweets
7 Dec 20
I want to tell you a story about a female town council member who was raped by the town's mayor. His victim lost her job and was humiliated again.
This didn't happen in 50s USA. It happened today in JAPAN. A horrifying story. Thread, please read.
#草津町の新井祥子町議を支持します
The town of Kusatsu is a small one. The population is just above 6000 people. Pretty much the only thing it's known for are it's hot springs, called "onsen" in Japanese.
But Kusatsu is also a place where the other, very dark reality of this "Japan" is visible. In 2015, the female town council member Shoko Arai was raped. The rapist was Nobutada Kuroiwa (see photo). He raped Shoko Arai in his office.
Read 20 tweets
1 Aug 20
Was in Europa besetzte Häuser sind, nämlich Zentren eines alternativen, linken gesellschaftlichen Lebensentwurfs sowie linker Politik, das waren in Japan lange Zeit selbstverwaltete StudentInnenheime. Ein Thread dazu, wie immer mit vielen Bildern. Es wird spannend :)
In den 50ern erstritten sich linke StudentInnenorganisationen (AstA, öH-Style) Autonomie über die Studiheime. Sogar die Miete wurde selbst bestimmt und war dementsprechend niedrig. In den wenigen noch bestehenden Heimen liegt sie heute oft nur bei 20-30 Euro pro Monat.
Bis in die 80er gab es über 100 selbstverwaltete Studiheime. Nicht alle politisch, aber viele. Diese wurden zu den Zentren der militanten Linken Studibewegung der 60er und 70er. Neben den Heimen gab wurden ganze Campus-Trakte besetzt und wurden eine No-Go Area für die Polizei.
Read 11 tweets
31 Jul 20
Was im Westen die Hasskappe ist, ist in Japan der Helm. DAS Symbol der radikalen, militanten Linken, insbesondere in den 60ern. Das japanische Wort dafür ist "Geba-heru", ein Lehnwort aus dem Deutschen(!) und bedeutet "Gewalthelm". Ein kleiner Thread bzw. Galerie. Viel Spaß.
Markenzeichen des "Geba-heru": Jede Gruppe hat(te) ihren eigenen Helm, mit der Aufschrift der Gruppe und einheitlicher Farbe. Auf aufgetreten wird gemeinsam, wie auf den Bildern ersichtlich.
Read 10 tweets
30 Jul 20
Rant (thread) about how researching about social movements in Japan can be a major pain in the ass due to the "outer/inner" (uchi/soto)-dynamics that run the country. And why I, as a non-japanese often feel out due to being a "gaijin".
Since I came to Tokyo last year, one of the biggest struggles in my research about anti-fascist movements in JP was to get adequate informations. Articles and books, which go deeper than what's available in a mainstream bookshops.
I am especially interested in the ideological changes and developments of anti-fascist groups. From being fiercly anti-japanese until the 80s, to becoming more and more liberal and sometimes even openly rightwing since Fukushima.
Read 22 tweets
28 Jun 20
Wie reagiert übrigens eine der vielen Erdogan-Außenstellen in Österreich auf #ekh und #favoriten ?
Nun, gerade jetzt lädt die Kleinstpartei SÖZ etwa zu einer Diskussion "Atelier X" in der hippen favoritner Ankerbrotfabrik.
Mehr Infos in diesem Thread, weiterlesen bitte.
Der Chef der SÖZ ist Hakan Gördü. Zuvor war er der Sprecher der UETD, einer Art außenstelle von Erdogans Partei AKP. Das Geld für diese Tätigkeit erhielt Gördü direkt aus Ankara. Er organisierte nicht nur den letzten Erdogan-Wahlauftritt in Wien, sondern auch Pro-Erdogan Demos.
Er gibt zwar immer wieder vor, dass er "nichts" mit der AKP/Erdogan zu tun habe, aber die Beweislage spricht natürlich gegen ihn. Mitunter kann er auch wirklich sauer werden.
Read 11 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!