Trump lawyer Van der Veen gives reasons for acquittal:
1) jurisdiction
2) Rule 23 (each allegation as separate article)
3) due process
4) First Amendment
He doesn’t mention innocence as a possibility. #VoteToConvict
On reason 1) Jurisdiction: The Constitution requires a Senate trial. Trump was impeached while in office, for actions committed while in office, so that question is moot. The Senate voted to recognized its jurisdiction & ALL 100 SENATORS swore to serve as jurors.
On reason 2) Rule 23 - The argument that Trump did so many things wrong he must be acquitted because there is only one article is nonsense & shocking. The other crimes are provided as evidence of the core crime, both of Trump’s state of mind & ongoing intent.
On reason 3) due process - This is not a criminal trial, so the same rules do not apply. Nevertheless, Trump was testify; he declined. He was invited to provide exculpatory evidence; he declined. His lawyers argued process, never innocence. He had due process.
On reason 4) the #1stAmendment - inciting insurrection is not protected speech; seditious lies are not protected speech; defamation & extortionate threats are not protected speech. The 1st Amendment does, however, bar Congress from reducing the people’s right to redress.
On innocence - Trump’s lawyers failed at any time to present even a hint of exculpatory evidence. They compared Trump to the KKK & a corrupt sheriff who threatened voters & jurors. They said he should be arrested & that DOJ knows “what to do with such people.”
They have repeatedly failed to argue—even when listing reasons for which Senators might vote to acquit—that innocence was a reason for acquittal. They have deflected & spun & refused to answer when directly asked if Trump knew he was putting lives in danger on January 6.
At numerous times over several days, Trump’s lawyers lied—about his behavior, about his known state of mind, about the testimony of witnesses, about evidence presented against him, about the law, the Constitution, the process, and the actions of the House Managers.
The debased, chaotic, mendacious non-defense offered by Trump’s lawyers amounts to a solicitation of illegal acts by United States Senators in furtherance of a seditious conspiracy & giving material aid & comfort to the instigator of a terrorist insurrection.
Everyone not captured by Trump’s cult of radicalization—including every @GOP official & former Trump aide—knows that acquitting Trump today amounts to support for an attempted coup against the American democratic republic. All Senators have a duty to #VoteToConvict.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Joseph Robertson

Joseph Robertson Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @poet_economist

12 Feb
Maybe Trump knew the likely result of his speech was violent insurrection bc 1) he had told the violent insurrectionists to “stand by”, 2) they had massed outside DC awaiting orders, 3) his team intervened to change the rally date to Jan 6, then 4) moved route to the Capitol...
5) he celebrated attempted murder when supporters tried to run a bus off the road; 6) he celebrated the invasion of the Michigan Capitol by armed insurrectionists; 7) he celebrated attempted kidnap & murder of the governor of Michigan...
8) he had personally ordered an illegal paramilitary attack on peaceful protesters in Lafayette Park, where chemical agents were used in an offensive manner, 9) a grave crime his supporters imitated when they attacked the Capitol...
Read 7 tweets
11 Jan
No one should use powers of office to influence campaigns; they should do what is right. But since ⁦@HouseGOP⁩ seem to think it would be too risky to break from #TerroristTraitorTrump, they should rethink their notions of future electability... thehill.com/homenews/house…
You cannot campaign as being for “law & order” if you don’t stand firm against Trump’s incitement of armed insurrection against the Constitution itself. You cannot call yourself a patriot if you don’t stand firm against the seditious conspiracy & ALL of its adherents...
You will not be able to claim the mantle of Lincoln if, when your nation was attacked by Nazis & traitors, you stood by & asked that the rest of the country try to understand them. You will not be able to call yourself conservative in any way, if you stand with coup plotters.
Read 21 tweets
11 Jan
The @FBI is warning of dozens of coordinated paramilitary plots connected to the Capitol insurrection, targeting DC & state capitals. We are in the midst of an ONGOING TERRORIST COUP PLOT. Any use of office that provides aid or comfort is unlawful. #14thAmendmentSection3
Trump worked for months to foment this insurrection in an effort, by his own words, to overturn the results of a free & fair election. ANY use of public office to provide him with any personal aid or comfort, in these circumstances, is unlawful. #18USC2384
There is, by the way, no such thing as “armed protests” that also happen to be planning to “storm” government buildings or carry out “an uprising”. This is a paramilitary coup plot. It is now nationwide & it is all traceable to Donald Trump’s incitement. cnn.com/2021/01/11/pol…
Read 7 tweets
11 Jan
If Bill Belichick accepts the Medal of Freedom from Trump after he instigated a terrorist insurrection, he opens himself, the @Patriots & the @NFL to potential liability for providing aid & comfort to a seditious conspiracy. #18USC2384
If Belichick goes ahead with the ceremony, the @Patriots should immediately announce his dismissal & the @NFL should initiate proceedings to bar him from any future association with the league. Records of any support for Trump-linked groups should be turned over to the FBI.
Before any Trump fan or @Patriots fan says this sounds too extreme or unfair, consider that Bill Barr, the loyal AG who acted to protect Trump from indictment or impeachment, said Trump orchestrated the insurrection & “betrayed his office.”
Read 4 tweets
11 Jan
Please share this: The attack on the Capitol was a terrorist attack, in support of a seditious conspiracy. With sedition, homicide & felony murder charges, participants could face 60+ years in prison. Anyone present who invaded the Capitol should voluntarily surrender to the FBI.
There were explosives & other deadly weapons & evidence of a plot to kidnap & murder elected officials. Funding for the event, for the campaign of seditious lies that radicalized some attackers & for events where direct incitement occurred will be traced.
Anyone who provided any tacit or direct support to any of these elements of the conspiracy—lies about the election, threats or extortion of public officials, infiltration of law enforcement, or funding of any kind—should surrender to the FBI.
Read 4 tweets
10 Jan
The first question in filing criminal charges against Trump for seditious conspiracy & instigating insurrection is: Would any of this have happened if Trump weren’t doing what he has been doing?
The second operative question is: Did Trump actively & knowingly court the allegiance & mobilization of armed paramilitaries who later took part in or helped orchestrate the attack on the Capitol?
On this point, we know from highly visible public acts but also from less known detailed investigative reporting that Trump courted, incited & condoned these extremists groups not once or twice but EVERY SINGLE TIME for years.
Read 10 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!