Wow, this graphic from a new @ERCOT_ISO report on the #TexasBlackouts shows how close the ERCOT grid was to a cascading failure that could have easily blacked out the whole system. ercot.com/content/wcm/ke… 1/
Going into the night of Valentine's Day, February 14th, a new winter peak demand of 69,222 MW was set at 7:06pm. By 1:23am in the middle of the night on February 15th, frigid temps had left more than 35,000 MW of generating capacity offline. 2/
Faced with greater demand & diminished generation capacity, ERCOT, the grid operator, ordered transmission utilities to start disconnecting millions of customers. The initial order was to shed 10,500 MW of demand. This grew to a height of 20,000 MW by the end of Feb 15th. 3/
ERCOT, like all grid operators, must balance supply and demand for electricity at all times, within very tight physical tolerance ranges. If demand exceeds supply, generators strain to meet the greater load and the frequency of the alternating current power system drops. 4/
If sensors at generators detect a decline in frequency of more than one percent for more than a few minutes, power plants automatically disconnect to avoid damaging overworked generators. 6/
As one overworked generator shuts off, it places more strain on the remaining generators, triggering more power plants to trip off, and so on, in a cascade of failures that can blackout the entire system. 7/
A grid operator’s primary job is to avoid this outcome. On February 15, ERCOT was thus faced with no other option but to start emergency blackouts to shed demand and restore balance with the vastly diminished supply. 8/
This new 'after action' report shows that the frequency of the TX grid dropped to a low of 59.4 Hz for 4 mins & 23 seconds. That sounds minor, but as ERCOT explains, more generators would have automatically dropped offline if the frequency had stayed below 49.4 MW for 9 mins+. 9/
This illustrates just how delicate the balancing act is that electricity system operators maintain at all times. The #TexasBlackouts were minutes from being far worse.

(None of which diminishes how devastating & often deadly the days' long blackouts were for all affected) /End
p.s. This chart shows how rapid failure of ~9,000 MW of natural gas plants along with ~2,000 MW of wind just after midnight 2/15 appear to have precipitated the initial frequency drop. >15,000 MW of gas generators eventually went offline + 1,300 MW of nuclear & ~2,000 MW of coal.
Sorry, typo above here

Should say "more generators would have automatically dropped offline if the frequency had stayed below 59.4 Hz for 9 mins+" (Not 49.4 MW!) Blerg.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with JesseJenkins

JesseJenkins Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @JesseJenkins

24 Feb
A good look at the variability of wind and solar resources in Texas, from @VibrantCE. They show that wind power can exhibit significant inter-annual variability, and some extreme years exhibit winter months with near-zero output from wind. This is rare, but happens.
Solar exhibits less interannual & monthly/weekly variation than wind, but there is, of course, this thing called night. That said, batteries + solar can mitigate diurnal cycles well. So solar+storage can be counted on a bit more than wind it seems, with higher capacity value.
This variability needs to be accounted for in resource adequacy planning, including the potential for correlated extreme low wind events during periods of system stress.
Read 5 tweets
20 Feb
The Lessons of the Texas Power Disaster nyti.ms/2NfdrPv

Today's @nytimes editorial cites and echoes my recent op ed on what went wrong in Texas and what it means for building a cleaner & more resilient energy system.
For more on what went wrong in Texas, see my op ed in the @nytimes here
For a forward looking view on how to ensure adequate firm resources in a clean electricity system, my seminar on The Critical Role of Clean Firm Resources here:
Finally, check out this week's issue of @TheEconomist, which has a cover story building on the @Princeton Net-Zero America study about how the United States can regain it's leadership on #ClimateAction and build a clean energy economy
Read 4 tweets
19 Feb
It takes a lot of gall -- or deliberate ignorance -- to see widespread failures of gas wells, pipelines, & power plants resulting in days-long loss of ~28,000 MW of thermal power plants, mostly gas, and say, "this proves we need more gas and coal plants!"
Some facts on the #TexasBlackouts for @KimStrassel and others peddling false narratives that do nothing but mislead and distract from the key steps Texans need to take.

1. ERCOT news release confirms 28,000 MW of thermal plant outages (mostly gas) ercot.com/news/releases/…
2. "nearly half of the state’s natural gas production has screeched to a halt due to the extremely low temperatures, while freezing components at natural gas-fired power plants have forced some operators to shut down."

texastribune.org/2021/02/16/nat…

#TexasFreeze #TexasBlackout
Read 7 tweets
18 Feb
PSA for reporters looking for good experts on how climate change is changing the risk profile for electricity systems and critical infrastructure, here's some recommended sources I know in the thread below...
1. Prof. A.R. Siders @sidersadapts focuses on how communities adapt to climate change and climate-related hazards udel.edu/faculty-staff/…

2. Prof. Michael Craig @TheEnergyCraig studies how climate change impacts power systems energy.umich.edu/energy-faculty…
3. Prof Sarah Fletcher @SFletcherH2O at Stanford studies adaptation and resilience of infrastructure systems in water and energy cee.stanford.edu/person/sarah-f…

4. Prof Emily Grubert @emilygrubert at Georgia Tech studies decision making for water & energy systems ce.gatech.edu/people/Faculty…
Read 6 tweets
17 Feb
Update: it looks like the Texas Commission ordered ERCOT to be prepared to further increase electricity price cap from $9,000/MWh to up to 50x the spot price for natural gas, if necessary to keep incentive for gas generators to run.
That means is spot gas prices are above $180/MMBtu, the market price for electricity could rise above the $9,000/MWh cap that normally occurs during power supply scarcity. @EIAGov is reporting $350/MMBtu spot price in Houston today, so that may be in effect now!
Maybe they will do this retroactively? The current prices reported by ERCOT are still $9,000/MWh including adder to reflect demand shutoffs ongoing. ercot.com/content/cdr/ht…
Read 5 tweets
17 Feb
#TexasBlackout update, 9:24am Central time: the grid operator @ERCOT_ISO's latest data is STILL reporting over 30 GW of thermal generators offline. ERCOT's 'extreme' generator outage scenario planned for just 14 GW.
Wind power is also at only 1,000 MW, below ~1,500 MW ERCOT planned for in an 'extreme low wind' scenario. So that's not helping either, but a far smaller contribution to supply shortage than the 30,000 MW of thermal plant outages that have persisted since Monday morning.
Demand served now is 44,539 MW, well below ~69,000 MW of peak demand experienced on Sunday in similar temps as today. We can't know the counterfactual of how much demand there would be if supply was adequate, but its probably on order of 20,000 MW higher than current levels.
Read 12 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!