Provocative and articulate thoughts from our small business community asking Canadians "Where are your values?" Indeed, values, economy, family and health all intersect within the C19 response. Have we struck a balance? 1/
The answer is a resounding "no". A walk through a shattered urban landscape and twitter discussions of force isolation and anal swabbing of children tells you this train left the tracks a very long time ago. Who is responsible? 2/
Let start with our ever bewildering public health community. A cascade of poor decisions fueled by an incorrect viral assessment, an amoral value system, stunning hubris and ideas that should never see the light of day. A terrible combination. 3/
Then politicians who allowed an undisciplined public health community to run amok, destroying everything they touch and blaming others for their mistakes. Our political class, of course, thinks everything is fine as long as the polls tell them so. 4/
And then there is us, the people who put far too much faith in our "experts" and "politicians". It seems our gullibility has no bounds and we will give up everything for the illusion of safety. It is btw an illusion. 5/
History teaches us that these debacles end when money dries up and people tell the "experts" to stop. Vaccines might be the narrative but make no mistake, its a populous with pitch folks and the absence of a magic money tree that ends these debacles. 6/
It will be up to people to put their lives back together and the costs are incalculable. It's also upon the people to ensure that this blundering mess never happens again. So let's prioritize a few requests. 7/
1) A full public inquiry at the provincial and federal level. If malfeasance is uncovered, civil and criminal proceedings should ensue.
2) High profile resignations should be considered, particularly in light of the scale and depth of societal damage. 8/
3) The public health community should be removed from pandemic planning permanently. And....
4) We should develop a professional emergency response agency whose mandate includes pandemic responses. 9/
The final request is key. Canada is a trillion dollar, highly integrated economy and our current lemonade stand operation isn't up to the task. It's time to put the wheels in motion and fix what is so desperately wrong. End.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
These editorial sentiments are well meaning but lets be clear. The C19 response has revealed the dark art of public health as destructive and incompatible with 21st century life. Much to criticize especially its use of behavioral psychology....1/
Canada's C19 response started with two blundering mistakes. 1) wildly inaccurate claims of a viral threat; and 2) vaccines were the only way out. Both were disturbingly naive, but moving forward it locked Canada into a dangerous narrative....2/
That narrative involves the use of behavioral psychology to raise general anxiety and to reinforce conformity of thought and action. These dangerous weapons pull apart the underpinnings of society and shattered the psychological grounding of too many Canadians....3/
This british article highlights the strong push to put a spot light on how death was attributed to C19. Undoubtedly, one of the most serious failures of the current response. A deeper look reveals other interesting nuggets. 1/
One, MPs including those in gov't are pushing this forward. Second, they accept that significant errors were made by default. Third, a procedural issue was raised as to whether this is a stand alone issue or whether it should be rolled into a public inquiry. 2/
These are welcome statements, with remarkable candid, something we haven't seen in a very long time. The stars are aligning for a public inquiry and perhaps more. The public mood is moving swiftly towards more serious proceedings for those in position of authority. 3/
Undoubtably, one the the very best discussions I've seens on C19. Two analytical thinkers (Nick Hudson and Kelly Brown) carefully and methodically destroy the broad lockdown narrative. There are a few take away messages. 1/
One, there was a near complete lack of serious analytical analysis. Two, public health is flying blind and lacks the neccessary skill sets to guide society through the mess. Three, vested interests play an ever increasing role in shaping the C19 narrative for financial gain. 2/
The last is interesting in the Canadian context, with respect to the news media. Both the CBC and the Toronto Star have been hemorrhaging eye balls and revenues for years until C19 magically reversed their fortunes. Coincidence? 3/
For me, one of the few bright spots of the C19 response has been the number of clever people who have reached out. Of particular note have been civil servants, business leaders, financial analysts and students. 1/
Believe it or not, many in the civil service are just as frustrated as you are. They have kept me focused and calibrated. Just when you think its all a conspiracy, they ride to the rescue and remind me, gov't really is this dumb. The examples are numerous. 2/
Business leaders kept me humble, reminding me of my privilege in academia. Not one missed paycheck while others struggle to keep businesses afloat and fight depression. When this is done, academia and our public health community should open their eyes and beg for forgiveness. 3/
I do like to keep people abreast of the C19 origin story. Many unanswered questions but two things are clear. The origin time has moved back to atleast mid Sept. 2019-early Oct. A large portion of initial patients can't be linked to the Wuhan market. 1/
Still lots to learn but one of particular note is whether other regions of Oceania were hit before we actively monitored the virus. What fragments of evidence we do have suggests yes. Lets dig a bit more. 2/
Here is data from Australia showing an unprecedented spike in flu-like illness in mid 2019. 3/
Thes employment numbers should shock people. Expressed relative to those participating in the labour market, I roughly calculate 1 in 25 ontarians lost their job this year. This was preventable if we stuck to standard public health policy. 1/
Making matters worse, companies are starting to move capital and new jobs out of the province. Sorry to say but the calculations have been done and the future cost structure is just too high. Shrinking tax base and market impact, its looking really grim. 2/
Further, we need to grapple with our crippling debt. Ontario and Canada are primed for inflation followed by a long term deflationary cycle. Canada is starting to look like first world nation struggling with a third world debt crisis. 3/