Bypoll results of AAP today are important for Delhi's future. These victories tell a story of ideological support and grassroot governance. It's not like any other municipal election in India where the incumbent state government has an advantage. Delhi's not like any other state.
The definition of the State is a monopoly over violence. In Delhi, Police is with the BJP and MHA at GoI, LG controls IAS officers who run election for ECI/SEC and local incumbent in the MCD is the BJP. Over years, AAP has carved a niche through delivery and communication.
For instance, Delhi has had no Delhi Government being formed by the BJP since 1998. 23 years they've been out of government.
And yet, they've ruled the roost at the city corporation level, with every Mayor and committee dominated by BJP.
In 2017, they won 180+ out of 272.
10% less people in total had voted in the municipal polls, some Delhiites bought into the fake media narrative of Punjab, the loss made us an orphan in more ways than one and many bureaucrats/officers saw winds going against us and actively helped the BJP win at the local level.
For instance, valve operators in DJB switched water supply around elections at the instructions of BJP district president or corporator. The solution we came up with was to increase the water supply and max out distribution not politicize. People appreciated us behind our back.
A large percentage (>30%) of people in surveys said that MCD or Committee or the Kameti for Teh Bazari folks was a part of the Delhi Government. Myths take daily persistence and proof to dispel. Ground mobilization and investigative policy PCs by @ipathak25 set the tone for AAP!
The city has been silently thinking about itself, its stories and more importantly its future. Riots in NE Delhi and the handling of the Covid pandemic has shown people that AAP cares and even if it isn't perfect, it tries harder than anyone else. More than enough for now.
I must make special mention and thank leaders and MLAs like @ipathak25, @Saurabh_MLAgk and many new local district or ward leaders who have come up to speak about issues like property tax to professional charges to garbage to air pollution to fiscal imprudence and exposed MCD.
While these bypolls in no way are representative of what could happen in 2022, esp considering the number of corrupt financial futures that will be at collective risk, I hope it encourages more good upstanding citizens to come into politics and not socially distance from it.
There's a great opportunity to create an ecosystem of civic leadership with the MCD polls coming up in less than a year. Women will contest half these seats and they must be judiciously utilized to change the patriarchal nature of power in general. Persist to build muscle.
Honest politics and good policy is when you bleed money, status and power like PayPal to build network effects. It's not venture funded but has personal opportunity cost. It ends up making politics and policy a positive sum game, where it's far greater than the sum of its parts.
AAP in municipal polls in different cities and towns shows us that there is a path to a democracy from the grassroots and where public problems exists. It's just going to be a difficult path amidst a lost cause of a social project. But aren't those the ones worth fighting for? :)
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
If journalists were given the freedom to investigate what AAP has been saying throughout, you would see most 2020/1 "new" policy stories 6-10 years and governance stories 3-4 years before. History will judge Manmohan Singh ji. It might miss us dearly. Hope it never comes to that.
No one asked Anna ji whether he supported the formation of AAP or not. He said yes inside and maintained his intellectual ego outside. Ask anyone what Anna ji said at the Constitution Club. They've hounded AAP pointlessly for pursuing necessary politics of its time.
No one asked Kiran Bedi why she didn't protest Gadkari. She, Anupam Kher, Ramdev, and VK Singh were against Congress. Swami Agnivesh and Santosh Hegde(s): good men with images to safeguard. Others, tired pros. Koyle ki dukaandari hai, mailey haath to honge. Arvind understood.
Delhi Corona app happened through efforts Health/IT/Revenue Department, DeGS, NIC at GNCTD with volunteer independent freelancers, programmers, software engineers, GIS experts, and graphic designers, delivering tech for social good. A thread on the hands building for Delhi. /1
Delhi Corona is the official platform of the Government of NCT of Delhi providing citizens with comprehensive resources to combat COVID as per mandate in F. No. SS-1/HFW/COVID-19/2020/04/20-28.
Global pandemics, by definition, cannot be restricted within the confines of state borders and boundaries. The medium of our response needs to be equally ubiquitous. Tech revolution witnessed in 21st century has brought a smartphone to almost every pocket around us. /3
The distributed nature of Delhi's public health infrastructure with commitment to universal healthcare coverage allows for capacity and flexibility. Prudent resource allocation, conscientious human resource management and private-public-civil society partnership can work wonders!
There are 100 containment zones in Delhi now (with a few de-contained formally). Only 5 lakh people out of 2 crore population and less than 1% area has been put into containment with essential relief at doorstep. Ensures surgical strikes on Corona without at scale inconvenience.
One of the critical aspects of Operation SHIELD in containment zones is door to door checks on citizens treated as probabilistic patients and enquired about general well-being and specific symptoms. This map shows clustering of health checks by Revenue Department across the city.
State governments and cities are finding it particularly hard to deal with #COVID2019india#Covid_19 making #IndiaFightsCorona hard on state capacity, finances, individuals and systems. I collaborated with @Tavpritesh and @guptasud to put together a primer for states/cities.
It is important to know a few basic facts and statistics. Like the difference between Covid19 (the disease), 2019-nCov (nomenclature) and SARS-CoV-2 (the virus). There are some basic statistics that can be helpful based on the state, district, city, town or taluka's planning.
The WHO has declared #CoronavirusPandemic. Indian travel bans imposed. Policy and governance response in India through state governments and local corporations will be key to fighting this. Think global, act local. Here's what India can do given unique constraints + conditions.
First thing to understand is that the response will need clear command and control, collaboration and community response. It will need rapid learning and acting. Some of it has not even been initiated. It must be immediately and sustained over months.
At the national level, only a certain set of restrictive actions and orders can be passed. Given India's state capacity in public and private health as well as Health's constitutional status in the state list states, cities and local bodies is where this battle will be won.
For friends in media, academia, state, market and civil society, here's a thread on #coronavirusindia#CoronavirusReachesDelhi#Covid_19, here's a thread on the complexity, science, public health issues and city governance and capacity that will help inform your work/actions.
The Coronavirus outbreak originating in Wuhan has about 20% severe cases and 2% deaths. This is a heuristic average based on data from different countries. Reports on the incubation period are anywhere from 14-24-28 days. Citizen, community, city, state and national actions reqd.
The most interesting state response (from a public outreach and guidelines perspective) has been Singapore. Not too well to begin with but is seizing the moment with some great work.