Today’s hearing on #HR51 will be on Monday AM at 11 AM: oversight.house.gov/legislation/he
oversight.house.gov/legislation/he…
Context: statehood.dc.gov
Some Washingtonians will be showing up at the @USCapitol in support of #DCStatehood this morning. We may go as our daily civics lesson. 🇺🇸
We were late to the #DCStatehood demonstration outside the @uscapitol, but I marched with the native Washingtonian in the family down through newly opened streets to peacefully protest for redress of grievances & freely express ourselves about Congress making DC the 51st state.
We're listening to House hearing on #HR1: Making DC the 51st State
oversight.house.gov/legislation/he…
Livestream: #DCStatehood
It is constitutional for Congress to carve out a federal district & enfranchise ~712,000 Americans.
It should so so.
Our elected leader, @MayorBowser, is now testifying in favor for #DCStatehood, refuting the false claims regarding the constitutionality of #HR1

Carving out a federal district is constitutional:
statehood.dc.gov

Opposition isn't about money or legality: it's about power
"Power concedes nothing without a demand. It never did and it never will."– Frederick Douglass, one of our greatest Americans.
loc.gov/resource/mfd.2…
If #HR1 becomes law, DC will become the Douglass Commonwealth, a fitting honor for the abolitionist.

Progress requires struggle.
Vermont (population 623,347) & Wyoming
(population 582,328) are both less populous than DC.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_s…
Should hundreds of thousands of Americans be unrepresented because they live in either?

Of course not.

DC's population is a specious argument.

#DCStatehoodNow
A meta note about progress: today's @OversightDems hearing livestream has someone signing for the deaf & closed captions.

This the right standard for all Congressional hearings online, which should always be open & accessible to all Americans.

#DCStatehood #OpenGov #a11y
Congress heard testimony that referenced the 23rd Amendment. Read & learn about it here: constitution.congress.gov/constitution/a…
Congress is not "nullifying" this with #HR1.
A federal district that has no residents would be entitled to no electors.
Argument on DC's area is specious.
#DCStatehood
Q by DC's Representative: Does the text of 23rd Amendment describe the population or size of the District?
Mainon Schwartz, Congressional Research Service attorney:
No

"Those who oppose only need to do what I have done:
Read the words written in the Constitution"- @EleanorNorton
The House has heard testimony on the Admissions Clause of the Constitution (Article IV.S3.C1.1.1.2), on the admission of & the rights of new States, including doctrine & practice:
constitution.congress.gov/browse/essay/a…

There are no clauses about airports or car dealerships in the Constitution
If @CongressmanHice would like to “balance” the admission of DC with a pair, 2 states at the same time, I nominate Puerto Rico — if they vote for it — & the US Virgin Islands, Guam, Marianas, & American Samoa.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Territori…
~4 million Americans taxed, but unrepresented.
There is nothing about the nature of commerce nor local economies in the Admissions Clause, neither retail, mining, manufacturing, agriculture, drilling, or tourism.
The idea that manufacturing, agriculture, & mining is "where the wealth of a country comes" from in 2021 is ludicrous.
Cf LA & movies, Silicon Valley, NY & stock market, & so on.

"We do not have any mines, Congressman, but we are investing in other energy sources"-@MayorBowser
Of all the arguments today, the notion ~712,000 Americans in the District won't be able to support ourselves because we aren't miners or farmers or factory workers is the most simultaneously archaic & ludicrous.
Would "No taxation without misrespresentation" really ask too much?
~11,000+ Americans from DC are currently serving in the US military & can be sent to defend our democracy & that of our nation's allies abroad, but none of them have full voting rights at home.
Those troops are disenfranchised, too
If you support our troops, vote for #DCStatehood
Opposing #DCStatehood because most folks who live in DC are registered Democrats isn't a constitutional argument.
It is naked partisanship, seeking to continue to deny the franchise to ~712,000 Americans who live here instead of competing for our votes. And yes, race is a factor.
#DCStatehood is not a political political plot, says @RepMaloney:
It is an effort to right the wrongs of 200 years of disenfranchisement.
712,000 people who live in Americans: they pay taxes & deserve representation.

Amen, Chairwoman.

& with that, today's hearing is adjourned.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Alex Howard (he/him) is getting vaccinated

Alex Howard (he/him) is getting vaccinated Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @digiphile

20 Mar
It is wrong to lie about voter fraud, attempt a self coup, & then incite an insurrection to seek to stop the count of electoral votes with seditious mob violence:
law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18…
@POTUS45 should have been convicted & removed from office, but @LeaderMcConnell blocked it.
The @pewresearch Center found that 82% of the Republicans who believed President Trump’s lie about him winning the 2020 election now say his conduct was not wrong.

The parallel to Germany in 1919 is unsettling:
nytimes.com/2020/11/30/opi… ImageImageImageImage
“The lie outlasts the liar.”—@TimothyDSnyder google.com/amp/s/www.nyti…
“The idea that Germany lost the First World War in 1918 because of a Jewish ‘stab in the back’ was 15 years old when Hitler came to power. How will Trump’s [Big Lie] function 15 years from now?” ImageImageImageImage
Read 9 tweets
19 Mar
The @WhiteHouse posted something to /Disclosures: a link to financial disclosures
whitehouse.gov/disclosures/fi…
No ethics waivers yet. (Best not to grant them at all, IMO.)
Like @ObamaWhiteHouse & @whitehouse46, public must request access to disclosures.
Still no /opengov
#SunshineWeek ImageImage
If @WHCOS @WHCommsDir are listening, I'd suggest editing wh.gov menu down to /Disclosures, where Americans would assume @WhiteHouse visitor logs will be, & welcome any answers they @POTUS +@VP have to the coalition's questions on #opengov governing.digital/letters/letter… Image
This would be a good day for @OMBPress to tweet a link to its FOIA page: whitehouse.gov/omb/freedom-of…
Ditto @WHOSTP whitehouse.gov/ostp/legal/WHO…
The Executive Office of the President is not subject to the Freedom of Information Act, but @WhiteHouse can & should celebrate it.
#SunshineWeek
Read 5 tweets
18 Mar
Now listening to the 2021 DC #OpenGov Summit. dcogc.org/blog/2021-open…
In past years, the annual #SunshineWeek event was at @PressClubDC. The wifi is (much) better at home, but I miss seeing people. Thanks to @DCOGC for putting this together!
To lead off, @GingerMcCall asked @CouncilOfDC Members @chenderson & @CMBrookePinto why #opengov is important.

Henderson it's not just posting info online, but helping people to understand & engage, helping govt to be more responsive.
#OpenGov is fundamental to everything we do, said @CMBrookePinto, who was at the Office of @AGKarlRacine, including we're doing, why, & what our processes are as we go.

Pinto also said residents should be educated about how to make FOIA requests. cc @CouncilOfDC @DCOPENGOV
Read 11 tweets
18 Mar
The @NYTimes could have built a social network around subscriber profiles (Remember Times People?), invested in a commenting system & building communities:
mashable.com/2008/09/22/tim…
What @NYTFood did: built up a Facebook Group, & left it:

Notable context:
@nytimes @nytfood Per @Benyt, kernel of the problem was a @NYTimes staffer "moderating comments for Facebook rather than working for the Times."

This POV seems off.

Over the past decade, editors spent time moderating social media as part of their work.
That was labor, & many were told to do it.
IMO, @NYTimes would be FAR better off closing group, citing @Facebook's new rules & say it decided not to add the staff it would need to moderate ~77,000 folks (& maybe cite other biz practices), & offer all 3 free months of @nytfood & a warm invitation to comment on recipe pages
Read 4 tweets
17 Mar
It's frustrating to see an administration @POTUS committed to "truth & transparency" revert to the practice of "senior administration officials" talking with the press.

Why wasn't this briefing on the record during #SunshineWeek, @StateDeptSpox @PressSec? whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/…
Per @NBCNews, the Biden administration is restricting info @CBP staff share with media in an unofficial gag order & denying "ride-a-longs," & US officials aren't going on the record *during #SunshineWeek* nbcnews.com/politics/immig…
@cbptroymiller should host a press conference.
“Senior Administration Officials Preview of National Security Advisor @JakeSullivan46 & @SecBlinken’s Trip to Anchorage, Alaska”
state.gov/senior-adminis…
@StateDept attributes journalists by name in transcripts, but not US officials. That’s not leading by example.
#SunshineWeek
Read 4 tweets
17 Mar
Could @VP @AmbRice46 @SamanthaJPower @SpeakerPelosi @SenWarren lead efforts to co-create commitments on anti-corruption with the American people in 2021?
opengovpartnership.org/members/united…
(Enacting laws >> voluntary commitments, but the latter could drive progress.)
#SunshineWeek #OpenGov
It seems inconceivable a @POTUS wouldn't join Merkel, @JustinTrudeau @EmmanuelMacron & other world leaders in a global #opengov partnership the USA founded, under @POTUS44:

…but this @WhiteHouse still hasn't celebrated #SunshineWeek or responded to Q's.
12 years ago, @ObamaWhiteHouse began trying to engage Americans with Change .gov, an @OpenGov44 Initiative, @WeThePeople44, @ChallengeGov, & 3 national #opengov plans for @OpenGovPart.
Record on FOIA + transparency was *mixed*: sunlightfoundation.com/2016/09/02/how… but intent & action mattered
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!