@ray_moishe Ray Buckner provides advice for sanghas in making their space and practices more accessible for all practitioners (not Pure Land-based, but pretty universally applicable) lionsroar.com/our-opportunit…
You can take your sangha’s efforts further by implementing the recommendation of the breakthrough “Developing Trans*Competence guide” transbuddhists.org/retreat-guide/…
Some of the same folks who produced the guide also contributed to “Transcending,” which is arguably the most important published book on trans/nonbinary/genderqueer Buddhism. It is a rich collection of voices: banyen.com/products/trans…
@TransBuddhism isn’t currently active, but the account has lots of archived stuff of use and interest
As for Jodo Shinshu, we've long had openly trans, nonbinary, and genderqueer people in our sanghas. Their experiences vary and let’s not pretend they’ve all been positive. Ignorance is common, and prejudice occurs. At the same time, they’ve been here and are here and belong here.
There is no possible religious basis for exclusion of anyone from Jodo Shinshu Buddhism. Amida Buddha, the light of Great Compassion by which we guide our lives and build our sanghas, embraces and cares for everyone unconditionally.
Failures of inclusion are precisely that: failures. In this age of Mappo, we foolish beings will commit many. Amida understands and embraces us, prejudices and all. But also asks us to do better.
When we fail, we should acknowledge that failure, say the nembutsu in humility and regret, and resolve not to repeat our hurtful mistakes.
We must strive to embody the teachings and not be a barrier to anyone who seeks refuge in the Dharma. To do otherwise is to rupture the sangha, one of the five grave offences. It violates our wish to practice right bodhisattva speech, action, and thought.
The largest lineage of Jodo Shinshu is Nishi Honganji (Honpa Honganji-ha). The highest body of religious experts is the Kangaku. The Kangaku has affirmed the inclusion of transgender Buddhists just as they are as valued members of the sangha.
An important Jodo Shinshu trans Buddhist is Hoshina Seki, the long-time president of the American Buddhist Studies Center, which is one of the oldest and most important Buddhist educational organizations on the East Coast. ambuddhist.org
Beyond Jodo Shinshu, viewers of Queer Eye for the Straight Guy will likely be familiar with the Jodo Shu Pure Land monk Nishimura Kodo tricycle.org/magazine/buddh…
In Osaka, Shozenji is a Shingon temple run by Shibutani Soshuku, a transgender nun who offers her temple as a welcoming refuge matcha-jp.com/en/9828
Shinran, the founder of Jodo Shinshu, wrote hymns of praise to Shotoku Taishi, who, in a vision, set him on the Pure Land path. Thus many temple altars include images of Shotoku, who over many lifetimes embodied the truth of gender fluidity.
Shinran recognized this in his songs, for instance:
In India, Prince Shotoku
Was born as Queen Srimala,
And in China appeared
As Master Hui-ssu.
He appeared in China
To benefit sentient beings;
He was reborn five hundred times
As both man and woman.
To all transgender, nonbinary, and genderqueer Jodo Shinshu Buddhists: thank you for the gift of your presence. Through the exercise of wisdom and compassion, may we act in ways worthy of that gift. Namo Amida Butsu. 🙏
Rev. Gregory Gibbs: "There are two things that anyone must do to be at home in the world. The one thing we must do to have peace in our lives is to change our attitudes toward the world. We must soften our tone, deflate pretentions, set more realistic goals for ourselves."
"The other thing that we must do, in order to be at home in the world, is to act to change the world. We must act to change the world so that it comes to accord more closely with the most positive values and aspirations we have developed as Buddhists."
"At a minimum, we must speak out in defense of the
bullied, oppressed and marginalized. We must oppose
tyrants, tyrannical ideas, and garden variety bullies. We must decry blocks to freedom of all sorts."
An example of Pure Land Deficiency Syndrome: Natalie Goldberg's @tricyclemag essay on Chiyo-ni never mentions that she was a Pure Land nun. It generically calls her Buddhist while naming Goldberg's Zen in the third line. This makes Chiyo-ni seem Zen too tricycle.org/magazine/chiyo…
It's part of a decades-long pattern of anything Japanese being subsumed under an umbrella of Zen, such that all good Japanese things are revealed to be Zen at heart, and all Zen things are good. This has been good PR for Zen but caused massive misundertanding and erasure.
The origin lies with D.T. Suzuki, whose romanticized Zen writings laid the foundation for what English readers took to be Zen, Japanese culture, Buddhism, etc. Without competition from other writers, he was able to shape (and warp) the conversation permanently at an early stage.
"In your mind, put Buddhism in the position of host,
And society in the position of guest.
Standing upon Buddhism,
Your acts in society should be done as occasion demands."
-Rennyo, "Goichidai-kikigaki"
Rennyo, the "second founder" of Jodo Shinshu, provides us perspective on Pure Land Buddhist social engagement. First, we must clarify our understanding and commitment to the Dharma, taking cues from the example of Amida Buddha, the Great Compassion.
Then, acting from our grounding in Amida Buddha's Primal Vow, we respond to the needs of people in our society as they seek relief from suffering.
Been saying this for some time. Very unpopular opinion but it's 100% true: Pema Chodron is a conscious enabler of a sexual predator (Chogyam Trungpa) and a whole organization full of predators (Shambhala).
Here's the money quote: "a woman reported to Chödrön that she had been raped by a Shambhala Center director and subsequently miscarried. She says that Chödrön told her that “I don’t believe you” and “If it’s true I suspect that you were into it.” lionsroar.com/pema-chodron-a…
Apologies are great, but they came after 4+ decades of pushing the myth of enlightened Trungpa (and enabling his abusive ways and those of his successors).
In honour of #Pride, here is a thread of resources and discussion for trans+ folx and their sanghas. (The first tweet references another thread, found here, for reference:
This thread references the Kangaku expressing inclusion of transfolx. The specific Jodo Shinshu member whose situation provoked the query and affirmation was American Michelle Kammerer, a pioneer in multiple ways: andrejkoymasky.com/liv/fam/biok1/…
That was over 20 years ago. Back then Ms. Kammerer's same-sex marriage was already common in Jodo Shinshu temples. But this was the first time one of the partners was known to be transgender. This too proved to be no big deal, but there wasn't a track record establishing that yet