Peter Apps Profile picture
20 Apr, 17 tweets, 5 min read
Lunchtime update from the Grenfell Tower Inquiry:

- Residents describe how vital self-closing devices were removed from flat doors by KCTMO staff
- Disabled woman forced to 'bump' her way down stairs to escape fire after no escape plan made
This morning we've heard from two residents: Betty Kasote and Youseff Khalloud, as well as hearing some statements read in.

First, Ms Kasote - a nurse who had lived on the 7th floor of the tower since 1996. Her witness statement is here: assets.grenfelltowerinquiry.org.uk/IWS00001775_Ph…
For the resident witnesses so far, the oral evidence appears to be about picking up specific thematic things and clarifying issues in the witness statement. Makes these documents a bit more important for following the narrative than was the case for the corporates.
Ms Kasote was one of a few residents who had their fire door self-closer disconnected by a TMO handyman before the fire (her statement below).

We know from Phase One that this happened to several others. A TMO caretaker (now deceased) admitted to removing around 10.
Asked if anyone told her about the importance of these mechanisms, or if a risk assessor checked the door she said no.

Ms Kasote also asked about TMO witness alleging that meetings were taken over by "disruptive" residents. She says this is not what she recalls.
Her witness statement referred to leaks experienced in the 2000s. She reported these to an office at the bottom of the tower - they were promptly dealt with and a dehumidifier provided to dry the flat. But in 2016 TMO had taken away this office and provided a central number.
When two serious leaks occurred and damaged her flat, she struggled to get TMO to deal with it and described them as "very abrupt and short with me... like [they] were angry with me that I was making a complaint." TMO workmen then removed damaged floor in her bathroom...
... but broke her toilet in the process. Her rug also went missing and when she phoned to ask where it had gone they responded angrily. She was told someone would check for asbestos, but they never did. She links the decline in service to the removal of the local office:
We then heard extracts from the witness statements of Mariko Toyoshima-Lewis and Mahboubeh Jamalvatan. Both were women with disabilities who were housed in the new lower flats on floor 3 after the refurbishment, which were supposed to be adapted for disability.
Ms Toyoshima-Lewis explained that she could not leave the building on the regular occasions that the lifts broke. This meant she could not take her children to school. No evacuation plan was provided. On the night of the fire, she was carried out by firefighters.
She described asking how she would escape in a fire and being told she should stay in the building:
Ms Jamalvatan also spoke of problems when the lifts broke down - and notes that her complaints were not recorded in internal RBKC/TMO documentation. She had to 'bump' down the stairs on the night of the fire as she was unable to walk down them.
Remember, govt sought to quietly water down the implementation of the inquiry's recommendation that disabled people should get evacuation plans after industry lobbying. It took a legal challenge from bereaved to reopen consultation: insidehousing.co.uk/news/news/gove…
Next, Youseff Khalloud - who lived on the 11th floor. He too describes having his self-closer removed. Says it was done by a TMO workman, never checked and he was never made aware of the importance of self-closers.
Then asked about refurbishment. Says he was not aware of many of the efforts TMO say they made to consult residents such as drop in sessions. Says residents had their own meetings once or twice a month. He was particularly unhappy about plan to put heating units in corridors
Says they were ignored until the local MP intervened and brokered a meeting - but then TMO was willing to move the location of 'boiler' to kitchen. Says TMO was forced to do this because residents were refusing access and should have listened before.
There will be some further statements read into the record shortly and two more live witnesses this afternoon. Will have a report at the end of the day.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Peter Apps

Peter Apps Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @PeteApps

21 Apr
In October, Scottish Tories did not vote on extending free school meals because it was English legislation.

But they made an exception last month to help the govt vote down an amendment to protect English leaseholders from paying cladding costs: insidehousing.co.uk/news/campaigne…
English Votes for English laws rule has been suspended for pandemic. But Scottish Conservatives said they would respect it anyway after being criticised for not voting for free school meals in October Image
But in March all six Scottish Conservatives including leader Douglas Ross helped vote down an amendment to the Fire Safety Bill which had sought to protect leaseholders from paying for cladding remediation. This legislation only applies to England. Here's their explanation: Image
Read 4 tweets
21 Apr
Lunchtime update from the Grenfell Tower Inquiry:

- Eddie Daffarn witness statement describes "heartbreak" at loss of Grenfell Tower community and feels he was "stigmatised as a trouble maker" by TMO in build up to fire Image
Ed Daffarn is of course well known for his efforts to raise fire safety issues and complain about the refurbishment before the fire and his campaigning since. He's submitted a lengthy witness statement which you can read here: assets.grenfelltowerinquiry.org.uk/IWS00002109_Ph…
Several issues covered this morn, some highlights only in this thread. Started with discussions around the various resident groups in the estate: an Estate Management Board, the Lancaster West Residents Association and specific groups for the tower.
Read 25 tweets
19 Apr
Update from this morning at the Grenfell Tower Inquiry:

- Former resident Lee Chapman describes efforts to complain about gas pipe installation in tower's communal staircase
So this morning we've heard from the first resident witness from this part of the inquiry, Lee Chapman - former secretary of the Grenfell Tower Leaseholders Association. He lived on the 22nd floor with his partner Naomi Li.
Primarily, his evidence focused on GTLA's complaints about work from 2016 onwards to install new gas pipes through the tower's staircase. This work was carried out by the National Grid and was separate to the refurbishment of the tower by Rydon et al
Read 11 tweets
17 Mar
I see the government was back in the House of Lords today claiming to be implementing the Grenfell Tower Inquiry recommendations in full. Something which remains... not true
1. Manual fire alarms

The inquiry said all high rise buildings should be "equipped with facilities for use by the fire and rescue services enabling them to send an evacuation signal to the whole or a selected part of the building by means of sounders or similar devices"
That is quite conclusively not something the government is signed up to. Leaked minutes I've seen show an industry response group warning the government this recommendation is a case of “cost against benefit (it’s not cheap)”.
Read 13 tweets
15 Mar
Lunchtime update from the Grenfell Tower Inquiry:

BBA published 'materially wrong' certificate for cladding later used on Grenfell after Arconic 'stonewalled' their request for up to date information for 16 months
Background: In 2007, the British Board of Agrement published a certificate which confirmed th cladding panels later used on Grenfell "may be regarded" as Class 0 - the standard in English regs at the time for high rises. You can read more about that here: insidehousing.co.uk/news/grenfell-…
This morning we've been hearing from Valentina Amoroso from the BBA, who reviewed the certificate in 2014/15.

This review was originally due to be done by January 2014 and the BBA began seeking the info necessary in October 2013:
Read 12 tweets
10 Mar
Report from today at the Grenfell Tower Inquiry:

Senior manager at Arconic wrote an internal document in in 2007 pondering what its responsibility would be if a fire involving its product killed “60 or 70” people in a high rise

insidehousing.co.uk/news/grenfell-…
On this specific document, the marketing manager at Arconic (which later sold the cladding used on Grenfell Tower) went to Norway in 2007 for an industry get-together hosted by a Norwegian products distributor
While there, attendees were invited to give presentations and a consultant from OTEFAL (a German metatls company) did a seminar on the dangers of using ACM as compared to solid aluminium.
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Too expensive? Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal Become our Patreon

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!