Killing time waiting for @ScotVoting SES data to drop so here, unrequested, are my 10 #ScottishElections2021 things to watch for as the results roll in over the weekend
1 Turnout – polling figures (8,9,10/10 likely to vote) highly variable but some down on like-for-like polls
in 2016 suggesting turnout could dip below 50.
Last time, around ¾ of folks returned their postal votes. Interested to see what the highest ever request for postal ballots does to turnout.
2 Pollsters – everyone overestimated SNP support in 2016 (although some only by a very little) and everyone underestimated Con support. This is the Scottish incarnation of a UK-wide habit of overestimating Lab support in polls. It’s *possible* they’ve bucked the trend but ...
3 A 'resurgent' Labour is a destabilising force, especially in three way marginals. Having shed voters in successive elections, mostly to the SNP but some to the Cons, they’ll come home in uneven numbers in different constituencies.
Polling picking up strong % for Sarwar himself, Labour competence, where they're nipping at SNP heels on some issues & have unseated Cons as 2nd best on economic issues, plus they seem to be the preferred option of voters with itchy feet
NONE of that might translate into seats
4 Leadership – sometimes good ratings help a party (SNP), sometimes they don’t help much (Lab), sometimes bad numbers don’t hinder (Cons). Part of that is explained by the extent to which constitutional tribes are ‘locked’ onto parties, but always volatility in the No Remain camp
Ones to watch. I look out for 3 things: marginals, bellwethers and other interesting stories.
5 Most of the marginals are up on Friday (Dumbarton, Ayr, Ed C and Southern plus the 3 way Eastwood). Dumbarton voters no strangers to bucking national polling trends but ...
6 Bellwethers – both Renfrewshire N&W and Strathkelvin Bearsden are close to Scottish national voting patterns. Both also up on Friday.
7 Friday's interesting constituency: Glasgow Southern. Sturgeon will likely outperform her party vote again but I'll be keen to see how much Sarwar’s positive ratings make a difference. This is also Scotland’s most heterogeneous constituency by ethnicity.
8 Saturday’s interesting constituency: Glasgow Kelvin. I remember doing media stuff (if memory serves to an audience that included @BBCDouglasF and @ianswansonen) in 1999 and saying it’s all very fine rejoicing you have visible minority female candidates but if you put
them up to run against Donald Dewar in Anniesland then you’re not exactly helping their prospects are you? A long road to Holyrood for her, but the SNP’s @kaukabstewart should take this one and be Holyrood’s first Muslim female MSP.
9 and speaking of representation, we should see a better gender balance in this cohort, possibly north of 60. Some of this due to SNP putting up women in their seats with retiring incumbents (9 men and 7 women outgoing, 2 men and 14 women standing) and improved #s on lists
10 Don't forget Wales.
-Obvious comparison of Welsh Labour & Scottish Labour
-Interesting to see how increased % for indy transforms into Plaid seats (or not).
-Possible seats for the Abolish the Senedd party prove you can have a polarised electorate even without an indyref!
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
🧵And now, my attempt to convince you that Lothians has something for everyone.
1 You've got 3 of the seats represented by 3 different parties since 1999: Ed Southern, Central and Pentlands
Ed Southern stands out as its Westminster counterpart hosts Scotland's only Lab MP.
Ed Pentlands was the site of Con constituency recovery in 2003. After the Scottish map drained itself of blue from the top down, that reappearance emerged in the south and EdP (the Westminster seat was also Malcolm Rifkind's when he was SoS)
Ed Central's story is one of Scotland in miniature - Labour stronghold, giving way to the two poles on the constitutional debate.
All three are also 3-way marginals, more vulnerable to smaller changes in opinion.
Plus you've got interesting histories for Ed N&L, 2 Greens off
🧵On where we are as a union (and the enduring challenge for Labour) - a quick look at S, W and Eng
1 General pattern in Scotland is that the SNP is doing well for a party in government so long, with unionist manouevres not quite managing to translate volatility into seat gains.
The party that is perceived to best stand up for Scotland (and this is an issue where they're streets ahead of competitors) is winning, if not making large gains.
2 In Wales, by contrast, Welsh Labour's soft nationalism is managing to ride the indy wave without losing
ground to Plaid. Indeed some fairly impressive Plaid to Lab swings in evidence.
3 In England - it's simplistic to see results (incl Hartlepool) as purely Leave/COVID related. This is a Conservative partly perceived to stand up for England and reveals the depth of
The Basics
1 Easy start. The 73 constituencies in 1999 were based on the then-72 Westminster seats in Scotland. Where did the 73rd constituency come from?
2 Which Scottish constituency has only ever been represented by people named Alasdair?
2 student performance not that of cohort or socio-ec circs should be relevant
1/n
3 assume teachers are capable of professional judgement
4 if estimation errors, assume underestimation is more damaging to prospects
2/
Solutions:
1 whatever modelling produces, if lower than prelims, use prelim mark
2 model exam mark on basis of
a) student's perf across all subjects last 2 years
b) perf in same or similar subjects last 2 years
c) teacher estimated mark
d) available coursework marks
3/
So @DrAmandaConroy 's tweet got me thinking about admin and teaching in Canada vs the UK so I give to you, a 4 tweet thread about the diffs between teaching in Canada and what you have to do in the UK (n=1, me)
If you inherit a course, here's what you have to do: